5 ms·
Unfortunately, it isn't actually that simple. Since WW2, the vast majority of our financing mechanisms and housing policy has been aimed at creating family hou
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
Unfortunately, it isn't actually that simple.
Since WW2, the vast majority of our financing mechanisms and housing policy has been aimed at creating family housing because that was what the parents of the Baby Boomers wanted and needed. Meanwhile, our population has diversified away from that. Plus there are myriad zoning policies, tax policies etc at all levels of government that are pieces of the puzzle for how SF has ended up this way.
There isn't anyone on the planet who actually knows exactly what needs to be dismantled to untangle this mess and trying to do so comes at high risk. It isn't at all unusual for the baby to be thrown out with the bath water when dealing with things as complicated as city planning.
I wanted to be an urban planner before life got in the way. It is why I took a class on homelessness and public policy. I have a good grasp of what is generally wrong. I can't give you a point by pint list if instructions on how to fix it for SF.
San Francisco proper is physically much smaller than New York City, 231 sq. miles vs 468. Part of it is built on infill, reclaiming land from the waters around it. Such infill has serious structural limitations. You can't build on it like it is solid ground. San Francisco also needs to be built to withstand serious earthquakes. All of these geographic factors further constrain what you can realistically build there.
I generally agree that simply building more housing would help. But when I lived in Fairfield years ago, SROs in San Francisco were $1000/mo. San Francisco is one if the few US cities that still has more than a few SROs and it still is not cheap enough. I am not convinced the problem is as easy to solve as you suggest.
Easy fixes very often come at a hidden cost. That cost can be quite high, catastrophically so.
- otterley 9y agoTo say that matters are complex is not really helpful, though. We must demand our representatives break down these barriers and eliminate complexity. The infill argument is totally bogus. The majority of the Financial District, which is where the majority of high rises are today, is on the very same infill you claim cannot support high rise structures. Singapore is largely infill and is mostly high rises. Tokyo is very dense and is in an earthquake prone area. The absolute area argument is similarly specious. That argument would be valid only if, per unit area, we were already building at a density similar to New York. Moreover, it’s irrelevant how large the city is within its political boundaries if you consider this to be a regional problem, which it is. So I’m not really sure whose side you’re on in this matter since you muddied the waters instead of clarifying them. The problem is entirely political. You can either help or make excuses.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoNo, I stated clearly that I generally agree that building more housing would help. I don't agree that the problem is entirely political. Characterizing my comment as merely making excuses and being part of the problem is not good faith engagement. I am bowing out now.
- DrScump 9y agoSan Francisco proper is physically much smaller than New York City, 231 sq. miles vs 468. In fact, San Francisco measures only 47 square miles. And that's if you round upward.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThanks. I did a quick Google and was surprised at the figure. Yours makes much more sense. From Wikipedia: City and county 231.89 sq mi (600.59 km2) • Land 46.89 sq mi (121.46 km2) • Water 185.00 sq mi (479.14 km2) So both figures are correct from some perspective, but yours is the more relevant for purposes of talking about building stuff.
- andrewjl 9y agoSF is already notoriously family unfriendly. The side effects you're describing sound like they'd impact suburban areas more so than the city. SF needs an overhauled planning process and possibly a way to fast track review of housing in already over priced areas that can contribute to a reduction in median rent. Edit: what is also clear is that the longer we delay these changes the more A) folks will get displaced that wouldn't have otherwise and B) the greater backlog of housing will need to be built to make up for past deficit and correspondingly the greater magnitude of change to the city in a shorter time (which I agree with you should be minimized to a reasonable extent)
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI have actually studied some stuff relevant to this problem space. I am trying to figure out how to put useful info together and I am getting involved locally where I live, which is outside California. I don't know if that I am doing will go anywhere and I don't currently have firm suggestions for SF. But it is quite hard to find genuinely viable solutions that don't have seriously undesirable side effects. I think discussing it on HN can have a constructive purpose, but it isn't guaranteed to have one. I wish I knew how to more seriously engage people trying to come up with real solutions. My mother always said it is easy to criticize, it is hard to create. If you have any thoughts on how I can more effectively connect, I would love to hear them. You could also try connecting with me on Reddit where I created a space called Housing Works.
- otterley 9y agoWhat are the "undesirable side effects" to which you refer?
- andrewjl 9y agoFolks are getting involved in the community planning meetings, which are a major way here for potential developments to get more visibility. In SF this week there's a case of a man who owns a laundromat, and would like to turn it into a 75 unit apartment building. It sounds like he met all the objective criteria and is getting stonewalled by NIMBY's due to the usual excuses: "neighborhood character" and historical value of the building. The building is a laundromat, and by all appearances fairly mundane and not at all historical. I can think of no obvious opposition a reasonable urban planner would have to this development. Yet it's being stonewalled. What undesirable side effects would it have? I grew up in New York City, which is also dense. People love living there. What's wrong with SF moving in that direction if it means accommodating all the new residents AND providing reasonably priced housing to all the current ones. Pardon the rant, this issue hits close to home for me. Edit: Re your earlier point on SF geography, earthquake proofing is a well developed tech. It will add some cost to development, but that doesn't make it infeasible. I live in a part of the city where they had to drill many many feet down to bedrock. It can be done.
- AnimalMuppet 9y ago> I can't give you a point by pint list if instructions on how to fix it for SF. I'm sure that was a typo, but a "point by pint" list (or discussion, either one) sounds pretty fun...