5 ms·
Advanced Data Analysis from an Elementary Point of View (2017) [pdf]
- eanzenberg 9y agoLove this book, it's a great intro into statistics based learning.
- minimaxir 9y agoI did take this class at CMU in 2012; I liked it a lot and it's good to see the curriculum hasn't changed much since. That said, working with highly-bespoke R packages made life crazy, and I'm thankful that post-graduation ggplot2 was an option for R data visualization and the development of the rest of the tidyverse packages after I graduated let me use R now in a much less messy manner.
- justin--sane 9y agoWow.
- audiometry 9y ago`This book does not presume that you once learned but have forgotten the material from the pre-requisites; it presumes that you know that material and can go beyond it. The book also presumes a firm grasp on linear algebra and multivariable calculus, and that you can read and write simple functions in R. If you are lacking in any of these areas, now would be an excellent time to leave.` ouch.
- usgroup 9y agoPretty much par for the course for graduate level maths. Linear Algebra Multivar Calculus They underpin most of which is practical in maths, or so it seems to me.
- carlmr 9y agoI took a quick look, and they start at very very basic stuff.
- muninn_ 9y ago>now would be an excellent time to leave What does the author gain from this statement? Now, if I were to be interested in this book, I would now be not interested and would encourage others to avoid it. Quite rude.
- whorleater 9y agoThe fact that the book isn't meant for you, and the annoyance of people constantly emailing you "I read your thing and I don't get it help".
- rubidium 9y agoOn the contrary, I like that the author spells out clear guidance on what is necessary preparation for the material. It lets me know right away if I should keep reading or look for more introductory material. I didn't read it as rude. Rather a "hey you better know what you're signing up for here".
- kevinalexbrown 9y agoHis writing is somewhat tongue in cheek. For whatever it’s worth, he seems to be a dedicated teacher who posts self criticisms of his courses publicly online. The course this book is based on has grown quite successful as well. I’m not sure if you’re just trolling, but encouraging others to avoid this book might be a mistake. It’s quite good.
- fwdpropaganda 9y ago> What does the author gain from this statement? Now, if I were to be interested in this book, I would now be not interested and would encourage others to avoid it. That's not very rational. That your feelings are hurt has no impact on how good or bad the book is. That is a great example of a previous conversation about feelings here on HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16384453 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16384453
- muninn_ 9y ago> That's not very rational. Don't need to be rational. Human beings aren't rational. > That your feelings are hurt has no impact on how good or bad the book is. It could be a great book, but if somebody is rude then (some are suggesting that the comment is tongue-in-cheek but meh) I don't really need to engage with that person. There are plenty of great books that cover this material so I would just suggest others to look elsewhere instead. Ultimately - I don't reward poor behavior. There are very few people who could make a significant enough contribution that I would give a pass on rude behavior towards others, particularly if they are condescending or mean for no reason. I also found it peculiar that you would believe that my feelings would be hurt. Why would they be? I just found out about this particular book and have no emotional attachment to it, nor the author whatsoever. Maybe you're defensive because you believe the book is good and worthy of being read despite the author's rudeness? That would certainly better explain your need to attempt to attack my "rationality" and suggest that my "feelings were hurt" alongside posting a link that wasn't worth reading.
- pulisse 9y agoThis probably reflects the fact that the text is an only partially rewritten set of lecture notes. It would an absolutely vanilla thing to say at the beginning of the first lecture of a crowded course.
- isoprophlex 9y agoI call myself a data professional or whatever, but looking at this table of contents I realise there is so much i can still learn!
- pjmorris 9y agoFrom the book's website: "This is a draft textbook on data analysis methods, intended for a one-semester course for advance undergraduate students who have already taken classes in probability, mathematical statistics, and linear regression. It began as the lecture notes for 36-402 at Carnegie Mellon University."
- LexAckson 9y agoThe author has a pretty interesting homepage. Especially the notebooks http://bactra.org http://bactra.org
- cosmic_ape 9y agoSecond that. Some of these notebooks are excellent literature reviews, highlighting really neat connections between results.
- jxramos 9y agoThis author has an amazing writing style, I just learned about the history of the term "regression" as used in statistics. Definitely worth looking up, it has nothing to do with curve fitting in general but was inspired by a canonical example that first inspired drawing a fit.
- savagedata 9y agoThis is my favorite statistics factoid! Regression/reversion to the mean is the idea that if you observe an extreme value and remeasure it, it will tend toward the average value on the second observation. For example, students who have a very high or very low score on a test will have a more average score if you retest them. Sir Francis Galton demonstrated the idea of regression to the mean by inventing linear "regression." He plotted the heights of children vs the heights of their parents and showed that very tall parents have children who are not as tall. The fact that we call linear regression "regression" has nothing to do with reverting to the mean other than, coincidentally, linear regression was first used to illustrate the concept.
- d33k4y 9y agoAfter only 10 minutes of skimming through a few topics, I've discovered two new approaches to take in my current work, and I've learned the name of two things I've already been doing! Today is a good day. The author's website ( http://bactra.org http://bactra.org) is also definitely worth checking out. Also, this quote: " Just as an undergraduate “modern physics” course aims to bring the student up to about 1930 (more specifically, to 1926), this class aims to bring the student up to about 1990, maybe 1995."
- cosmic_ape 9y agoThere is also an overview of tools for "complex systems", by the same author: https://arxiv.org/abs/nlin/0307015 https://arxiv.org/abs/nlin/0307015