3 ms·
There's actually plenty of evidence that it's not. What is the evidence? Even if you accept essentially any and all finding, however iffy, about gender-based c
by pvg 9y ago
There's actually plenty of evidence that it's not.
What is the evidence? Even if you accept essentially any and all finding, however iffy, about gender-based cognitive differences, there is a huge leap from that to 'women are simply unsuitable for your typical programming job, to an 80/20 ratio'. I can't think of any actual scientists that make that argument, again, on the basis of any finding. It's not at all obvious how such a question could even be answered scientifically.
- naasking 9y ago> Even if you accept essentially any and all finding, however iffy, about gender-based cognitive differences, there is a huge leap from that to 'women are simply unsuitable for your typical programming job, to an 80/20 ratio Who said anything about unsuitability? I said the difference isn't necessarily artificial like the OP claimed, and you jump somehow to it being a matter of ability or temperament? You're putting words in my mouth. The things vs. people hypothesis much better explains the gender ratios, and explains why it's seen across cultures, which doesn't fit well with the oppression hypothesis. This is the latest metanalysis I'm currently reading, but there's a slew of studies confirming this gendered difference in preferences: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00189/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.0018... Certainly some such inclinations might be socially conditioned, but as discussed in the above, they show up as young as grade 3. Regardless, even if it were all conditioned, hiring quotas and marketing programs directed even at high schoolers would already be too late and thus largely ineffective given these facts.
- pvg 9y agoI said the difference isn't necessarily artificial like the OP claimed How do you connect any things/people preference to performance or disparity thereof in a generic programming job? It explains the disparity only if you make a substantial assumption not in evidence.
- naasking 9y agoDid you even read what I wrote? Who's talking about performance?
- therealdrag0 9y agoAside: I feel for you here `naasking`. It's amazing how hard it is to have a conversation on these types of topics without people jumping to the conclusions about the position you're trying to illuminate.
- pvg 9y ago'Did you even read that' being the typical polite invitation to reasoned conversation.