3 ms·
My point, which I didn't convey entirely well, is that you can't use downvotes as a signal because there is no agreed upon criteria for when they should be used
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
My point, which I didn't convey entirely well, is that you can't use downvotes as a signal because there is no agreed upon criteria for when they should be used. Don't agree with the comment? Downvote is fine. Don't think the comment is on topic? Downvote. Have an emotional response to the comment? Downvote. I'm not sure how you can pull signal out of that noise.
Very, very carefully and with a low statistical confidence level, relying quite heavily on other factors to inform your conclusions.
As stated above, I think it is problematic to ignore them entirely. I don't see how I could state that more clearly.
I'm aware that I generally think a great deal more about social stuff than most people I meet. I'm aware I do sometimes overthink it and sometimes the answer is "Someone fat fingered it and there really is no social signalling to be derived from it."
- pasabagi 9y agoI have doubts about what exactly the signal is you're receiving in any case. Superbowl ads are popular. Agatha Christie is popular. Racism is popular. Many, many awful things - indeed, most awful things, are very well liked by most people. As I see it, the only possible content of votes is popularity - which, when it comes to quality, is a very bad metric. In a relatively small, educated group like HN, it's a little bit less diabolically awful than it might be if it was in, say, 1930's Germany, but it's still the same metric.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThat does not fit with my experience of participating here.