5 ms·
> Comments that reinforce systemic oppression related to gender, gender identity and expression, sexual orientation, disability, mental illness, neurodiversity,
by whatshisface 9y ago
> Comments that reinforce systemic oppression related to gender, gender identity and expression, sexual orientation, disability, mental illness, neurodiversity, physical appearance, body size, age, race, or religion.
So, there's a lot of "politicking" going on back and forth over this, but I'd like to suggest a specific problem: by attempting to formalize what used to be intuition, you're opening the door for people to follow up bad behavior with legal arguments that it was actually allowed. For example, someone could say something that was obviously meant against a group, and then defend it by pointing to specific wording in the CoC. ("But can you prove the oppression was systemic? Says the person who is obviously acting maliciously but is not obviously part of a system.")
- rayiner 9y agoBy that reasoning, we should never have rules, because any rule will create the possibility of people trying to lawyer out of the rules.
- whatshisface 9y agoThe cost of rules is a court system and the lawyers to argue in it. In the end, introducing rules can lead to more time spent on strife than was spent before the rules, because of this overhead. If you try to avoid this by interpreting the rules according to the present and changing intuitions of the project leaders, then you haven't really changed much from before.
- coldtea 9y agoDoesn't sound bad. Most communities survived 20+ years, and even thrived, without any such rules.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- detaro 9y agoA group thriving does not mean it didn't do damage to (former) members or others while doing so, and neither should "but look at what we achieved!" be a good excuse for it. (of course, groups also can have written rules and still behave badly, rules do not automatically solve these problems)
- alangpierce 9y agoI think a lot of potential technicalities like that are handled pretty well by this paragraph at the start: > This document is not an exhaustive list of things that you should not do. Rather, consider it a guide to make it easier to enrich all of us and the technical communities in which we participate.
- klipt 9y agoThat's vague and hand wavey. Their definitions are ripe for abuse and I'm sure someone will create e.g. an app for female rape victims and argue that excluding male rape victims is fine because "you can't be sexist against men."
- soyiuz 9y agoYour hypothetical worry about "excluding male rape victims" is strongly outweighed by the needs of actual rape victims.
- klipt 9y agoYour assumption that male rape victims aren't "actual" rape victims is exactly the kind of sexism I was referring to.
- soyiuz 9y agoI did not gender my example. Check your logic. You wrote "I'm sure someone will create an app" etc. My point is that your hypothetical example of a potential future bias is outweighed by the preponderance of existing evidence today.
- soyiuz 9y agoPossibly. But the benefits outweigh the marginal scenario you are envisioning. I again return to the example of HN, which has higher standards of conversation than many other boards, due in part to strong moderating guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html To draw a parallel, do you think HN would be more successful if it relied on "intuition" for norms of discussion?
- Yver 9y agoThe benefits of that kind of CoC remain to be proven. Meanwhile, I note that HN's moderating guidelines do not mention sex, gender, religion, food choices, or most of what FreeBSD's new CoC describes. HN's moderating guidelines are about content whereas FreeBSD's new Code of Conduct codifies human behaviour, as the name would imply. They are different things.
- pvg 9y agoI note that HN's moderating guidelines do not mention sex, gender, religion, food choices, or most of what FreeBSD's new CoC describes. You might also note that HN regularly fills up with pages upon pages of sexist (more rarely, racist) tripe. Which might be ok for HN but the people who participate in the FreeBSD project have decided it's not ok for their thing.
- youdontknowtho 9y agoyeah, ive been wondering if it was just me or if comments were starting to seem more reactionary?
- youdontknowtho 9y agoI guess that would mean yes...
- soyiuz 9y agoTo your first point: The detriments of that kind of COC remain to be proven as well. But why even bring this up? Even a perceived benefit to a marginalized group is worth it. Do we imagine the status quo as somehow harmed by stronger anti-harassment policies? There are numerous examples of sexual harassment online and in person. The potential chilling effects of stronger guidelines have to be weighed against the actual chilling effects (trauma, non-participation) of those affected. To your second point: The BSD guidelines address content ("comments") and physical meetings, which I assume apply to conferences and hackathons. I don't see the distinction you are making between "content" and "human behavior," as content is human behavior online. There is good research on moderated communities. Anecdotally, I am talking to you here and not on Reddit because of stronger guidelines (and the resulting, to my mind, higher quality of discussion).
- pvg 9y agoYour example is not a 'legal argument', nor is the CoC a law. Lots of organizations have rules that don't have the formality or rigor of laws and they have little trouble interpreting them, applying them and enforcing them in letter and spirit. It's pretty much a non-problem.