2 ms·
I realized as I wrote it that the analogies were flawed, but I rushed myself a bit to finish writing. The teacher analogy depends entirely on the school distri
by zdragnar 9y ago
I realized as I wrote it that the analogies were flawed, but I rushed myself a bit to finish writing.
The teacher analogy depends entirely on the school district, and perhaps might apply more to a university setting than a grade school one.
As for the builder, of course there's a discussion between the builder and the client... On the desired results. What a disciplined builder won't do is ask "can we" when they know that the current status is structurally unsound or flawed. There's some substantial differences in cost / financing and risk between the professions, so it's a bit of a stretch no matter what, I'll grant you that.
If we can at least agree that there is a certain amount of discipline that embodies a profession, and that the agile manifesto emphasises priorities characteristic of that discipline (correctly or incorrectly) rather than a "business process" or "project management" scheme, then I think we're agreeing on the important points.