5 ms·
> If people want to use Facebook then why shouldn't they have the choice of doing so without additional cost? Because now a potential Facebook competitor is no
by geofft 9y ago
> If people want to use Facebook then why shouldn't they have the choice of doing so without additional cost?
Because now a potential Facebook competitor is now artificially on an uneven playing field because access to Facebook is free and access to the competitor costs mobile data (on top of naturally being on an uneven playing field because of network effects). It's short-term good for Facebook users, yes, but if you believe in competition / innovation, it has negative structural effects.
If accessing things without additional cost is good, people should have the choice of accessing everything without additional cost, not just Facebook and Wikipedia.
> Many mobile providers zero-rate music streaming such as Spotify. Is that bad too?
Yes. EFF has come out strongly against T-Mobile's "Binge On" program (see e.g. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/01/eff-confirms-t-mobiles-bingeon-optimization-just-throttling-applies https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/01/eff-confirms-t-mobiles... ), and that (plus the truly awful reaction of the T-Mobile CEO, who clearly doesn't realize that his customers include EFF members / supporters) is why I quit and moved to AT&T's prepaid plan, which as far as I know does not have the same scheme. AT&T does have a plan where any provider can sign up to pay for their customers' data use, which is different from waiving costs for certain large, established sites.
I think it's important to stick up for the sort of products you want to see in the world long-term, for prisoners'-dilemma reasons.
- nwjtkjn 9y ago> AT&T does have a plan where any provider can sign up to pay for their customers' data use, which is different from waiving costs for certain large, established sites. Wait, how is that different?
- ves 9y agoIt’s like a customer-acquisition cost shouldered by the company, and presumably an option available to all companies. Zero-metering or other things being discussed privilege a fixed, arbitrary list of companies/websites, which is why they’re bad. Also, the extra cost is shouldered by either the ISP or the customer, which is like the company/website in question benefiting from a negative externality.
- geofft 9y agoIt's not great, but it's open to everyone who "just" has money, reducing it to the previously not-quite-solved problem of giving capital to potential upstarts. As a Spotify competitor, you can't just sign up for Binge On, unless perhaps you have connections with people who work at T-Mobile.
- tzs 9y ago> As a Spotify competitor, you can't just sign up for Binge On, unless perhaps you have connections with people who work at T-Mobile. Binge On is video. The zero-rating program for music is Music Freedom. If you are a Spotify competitor and want to get included in Music Freedom, you contact T-Mobile at the email address documented in the Music Freedom. You don't need any inside connections. T-Mobile's stated policy is to get as many music streaming services as possible covered. For video providers who want to be included in Binge On, there is a different T-Mobile address to mail to, also documented on the T-Mobile site. For Binge On, the video service can actually choose one of four ways to participate: 1. Do nothing. Their content will not be zero-rated. If a T-Mobile customer has enabled Binge On T-Mobile will try to optimize the bandwidth usage if it can detect the video. 2. Be zero-rated. T-Mobile detects and optimized bandwidth usage. 3. Be zero-rated. The video service detects when the customer is on T-Mobile and handle optimizing bandwidth. 4. Disallow Binge On. Their content will not be zero-rated, and T-Mobile will not try to optimize its bandwidth use for customers who have Binge On enabled. Here are the technical details: https://www.t-mobile.com/content/dam/tmo/en-g/pdf/BingeOn-Video-Technical-Criteria-March-2016.pdf https://www.t-mobile.com/content/dam/tmo/en-g/pdf/BingeOn-Vi...
- kuschku 9y agoI’ve tried joining Stream On (the term for T-Mobile#s Binge On and Music Freedom outside the US), but the requirements are insane. 4 weeks before I make any changes to any service I run via Stream On, I need to inform T-Mobile, and they have to approve the changes, or can end Stream On immediately. All Stream On content needs to run via separate hostnames, and has to transmit the hostname in cleartext. I have to be using forms of adaptive streaming, the bandwidth will be limited during this so that the user at most will be able to watch 480p videos. 50'000 EUR fine for each violation from my side, no fines if T-Mobile just kicks me out. And so on and so on. It’s ridiculous. Give me a single form where I enter a URL, and it’ll be zero-rated – or don’t zero-rate anything.
- skykooler 9y agoAnd also, if someone were to start a Wikipedia competitor it would also be on an uneven playing field.
- gonvaled 9y agoNot regarding network access