3 ms·
> Are employees in the US really such ducklings that they swallow such insult and paternalism? AFAICT: yes. But they don't really have a choice. "At will" e
by mpweiher 9y ago
> Are employees in the US really such ducklings that they swallow such insult and paternalism?
AFAICT: yes.
But they don't really have a choice. "At will" employment, combined with employer-based health insurance, huge debt loads (student loans, mortgages) and no social security puts employees in a pretty weak position. And that apparently weakens management skills considerably, we had an import from the US whose exclusive management skill apart from blaming the team for his obvious and blatant screwups appeared to be ultimatums of the form "if you don't like it, you can leave".
H1Bs are in an even worse situation, because in theory they have to leave the country at the very moment their employment is terminated (in practice there is a small grace period).
I threw up a little at the "binding arbitration clause" mentioned in the article forced onto employees with their contracts. In Germany, for example, arbitration clauses are simply illegal in employment law. More generally, when involving consumers, they must be separate, signed agreements, so cannot be imposed as fine-print or as parts of a different agreement.
- csa 9y agoWhile I think most of your points are valid, I want to clear up some issues with the H1B. From: http://www.immi-usa.com/h1b-grace-period-sgm-law-group/ http://www.immi-usa.com/h1b-grace-period-sgm-law-group/ > However, as of January 17, 2017, foreign professionals under the H-1B visa will have a 60-day grace period if their employment is terminated. Note that the time given to leave after the end of the regular employment term is still 10 days, and that is a point of confusion for some people. IMO, 10 days, while tight, is not unreasonable if you know it’s coming far in advance. Let me make it very clear that I am not trying to make a value judgment about the H1B visa program — rather, I just want to get some facts straight for others who are reading.
- mpweiher 9y agoThanks for the update about the change of the rules. When I was in the US on an H1B, the pro-forma rule was still "you have to be outside the country immediately".
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoIn most of Europe and other developed countries a 2-3 month period for termination + leaving would be considered normal. 10 days would be considered unreasonable and very harsh by most people I know.
- csa 9y agoMaybe one of us is misunderstanding. 10 days is just at the end of your regular contract — that is, something that is determined very far in advance. 60 days if you are terminated.