4 ms·
The article uses words 'natural' and 'processed' in a very superstitious way that implies always bad or negative. Just saying natural without explanation can i
by nabla9 9y ago
The article uses words 'natural' and 'processed' in a very superstitious way that implies always bad or negative.
Just saying natural without explanation can imply: natural as obviously better or healthier, natural as in way it has been always done, natural as with non-modified biological growth process, natural as no processing or raw. Same for the word processed.
In fact, beer is “ultra-processed” in the way this article describes quorn. Quorn is product from common and unmodified mold found in earth's soil. It is grown in tanks where they add required nutrients, mostly sugars. I fail to see how it is unnatural. Is yeast unnatural? If the protein growing process involves continuous fermentation, flash drying, filtration etc. Is the processing somehow bad and unnatural? Allergy concerns are of course real, but the same thing applies to peanuts and most foods. Mycoprotein seems to cause much less allergic reactions than most 'natural' foods.
If the process that produces mucoprotein contains less chemical processing than the processed meat that most people eat, isn't that natural? World Health Organization classifies nitrite processed meat as a Group 1 - carcinogenic to humans.
- ianai 9y agoIf it's mostly a mold, then isn't it essentially a whole food? It's not like molds have to be spun up in a vat from inorganic compounds. It's mold - a whole organism like any other.
- nabla9 9y agoWhole foods are plant foods that are unprocessed and unrefined. The process extracts proteins, so it's not whole food. Again, the assumption that whole food is automatically better is not true. There are good reasons why whole foods are generally healthier (good mix of nutrients, micronutrient, fibers, water), but there is no reason to assume that they have some kind of magical quality in them.
- YouAreGreat 9y ago> magical quality Taste, cravings, satiety etc. are based on evolved heuristics. Heavily processed food can fool those heuristics (and is engineered to do just that), while whole foods can't. The "magic" therefore is that it's a lot safer to eat whole foods.
- nabla9 9y ago> The "magic" therefore is that it's a lot safer to eat whole foods. Only 'in generally speaking' or 'on average'. There is magical thinking in health food business where generic statements replace knowledge. Take for example seeds like pumpkin seed, sunflowers etc. Many vegetarians and health conscious people eat lots of these. What they are not aware is that they accumulate heavy metals, especially cadmium. If you are not aware of the heavy metal content of the foods you ingest you should consume them only in moderation.
- ianai 9y agoYou should probably check everything out for heavy metals. Municipal water sources can carry heavy metals as well.
- Turing_Machine 9y agoRight. Outside of fresh fruit and (some, not all) vegetables, there are very few foods that aren't "processed" in some way. For instance, virtually all grains and legumes are eaten cooked, often being ground into flour or meal before cooking. Someone mentioned soybeans below. Raw soybeans are actually toxic to humans (though not to ruminants like cattle).
- glenstein 9y agoI came away from the article with a similar feeling. The whole article is stuffed with cheap shots. From the equivocation on processed foods, to reliance on impossible to refute claims that don't even seem to say anything: "it's different from what 'plant food' would seem to denote" and suggesting gullibility of people who "will take it at face value." First of all, would they really take it as a face value substitute for a familiar food? Secondly, what exactly is the problem? Is it that the ingredients are bad? If so shouldn't you just say that? Is it that they aren't bad but people might be tricked into thinking they are the real thing? Because that doesn't seem representative of the average experience and wouldn't even be a problem if it actually was happening. But none of that is unpacked. It's left there as a vague allusion to a criticism, in a form you can't respond to because the criticism isn't clear.