5 ms·
And techers are trying to teach how to make change? I understand “anchoring to fives and tens” but I don’t understand why anyone thinks it’s a good way to do a
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
And techers are trying to teach how to make change?
I understand “anchoring to fives and tens” but I don’t understand why anyone thinks it’s a good way to do anything except confuse kids.
Does independent research prove these approaches increase numeracy?
- ColinWright 9y ago> And teachers are trying to teach how to make change? No, the "making change" comment is an example of how these techniques of thinking about numbers do turn up in real life. > I understand “anchoring to fives and tens” but I don’t understand why anyone thinks it’s a good way to do anything except confuse kids. It's a part of a broader strategy to talk about the structure of numbers and the operations on them. > Does independent research prove these approaches increase numeracy? Yes. I don't have access to it and can't give you any links, but there has been a lot of research about how to move away from the rote learning of algorithms and move towards understanding what numbers are and how they work. I've seen some of the research as a peripheral part of some of the projects I've been involved with, and it seems that these sorts of exercises really do serve to help students see more about what's really going on. The problem is the parents pushing back because they don't understand it, and don't believe it can be useful or helpful. For me, it seems obvious that this is a better way to think about things.
- garmaine 9y agoI’m a parent and I object not because I don’t understand it — it’s not too difficult to pick up — but because it completely misses the why of math. Being able to mentally estimate numbers or do simple arithmetic is a good skill, but having universal algorithms for solving problems and describing the universe is really what math is more about. I can trace my trajectory into computer science all the way back to practicing multiplication tables and discovering that I could multiply numbers in long form too large to fit in my head and yet get the exact result. It is the power of the algorithm. My kids are entirely missing that in their common core education...
- JeremyBanks 9y agoTraditional elementary math teaches you algorithms without discussing why they work or the cases where they break down. They seemed arbitrary and untrustworthy. I'm glad that worked out for you, but I don't think many students get the same value.
- dorchadas 9y agoPart of the problem with this is that I feel elementary school teachers often lack understanding of why the math works. I remember hearing horror stories of people taking the Praxis and all the elementary teachers freaking out about the math -- one even said she had failed that section three times! It doesn't bode well that these are the people teaching our kids how basic math works. And it does show when they get to secondary schools.
- dahart 9y ago> having universal algorithms for solving problems and describing the universe is really what math is more about. I'm not sure I understand what you mean. What universal algorithms are there currently for solving problems and describing the universe? And why are these universal algorithms more important than estimation skill in practice? Are you suggesting that there's always only one true way to do things in math, and that the quest for the one true way is the only noble pursuit? FWIW, to me that sentence somewhat reads like a pre-conceived idea about math that could possibly impede your appreciation for valid alternative approaches. It's worth considering that in computing, the algorithms that have been used for math in processors and standard libraries have been changing dramatically ever since the first transistor. And it's not because the newer algorithms are more universal, it's often because we're simply making different tradeoffs over time. Sometimes it's because better algorithms are being invented, because the algorithms we thought were great turn out to be not universal. Sometimes it's because a new fast approximation formula is discovered that is accurate to the precision of the machine. There's very little in computing today that is "universal", despite the pedagogical emphasis on this abstract idea. There are, however, lots of algorithms that are canonized. Math constructs that seem universal because everyone knows them and they're popular, and alternatives aren't well known, enough that it becomes hard to imagine the alternatives. > My kids are entirely missing that in their common core education... Are you absolutely certain that's true? Common core, as the author pointed out, is still required to teach the old algorithms. Are you sure you're not having an emotional reaction to not quite understanding why some of the new methods are there and/or being unfamiliar with them? Your reaction here is exactly what this entire post was addressing.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I understand “anchoring to fives and tens” but I don’t understand why anyone thinks it’s a good way to do anything except confuse kids. I found it a huge boost to my ability to do computations without paper or other tools when I learned it in elementary school; I think it's valuable, but I'm not certain that the manner in which it is often being taught now is helpful (which, AFAICT, is not so much a matter of the Common Core standards as poor curriculum attempting to implement the standards.)
- ghaff 9y agoThere are systems for doing rapid mental arithmetic. The Trachtenberg system is one that I played around with at one time. [1] I'm not sure how useful they are though outside of needing/wanting to do more rapid calculations in your head. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trachtenberg_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trachtenberg_system
- b1daly 9y agoI think the problem with how these new concepts are presented, is that they are taking these ad hoc methods of doing arithmetic and trying to turn them into algorithms. My guess is that this is driven by the need children have to know how to get the “the right answer.” The traditional algorithms aren’t very intuitive, but they work. Trying to make an algorithm out of the various ways you can break up a problem, ad hoc, seems bananas.