8 ms·
Just teach my kid the math
- noir_lord 9y agoI did A-level maths, I've programmed computers for 30 years since I was a kid. Ive implanted algorithms to calculate solar irradiance varying by orientation, inclination and latitude. I don't understand what my 7yo stepsons maths homework is asking him to do/learn. It's just weird and I'm not sure he always does either, it teaches the how (weirdly) but never the why, I've started teaching him how to understand the practical uses for maths. We play games now like "how many bricks in the wall" when we are out and about. I struggled with maths as a child because I never saw what it was for, once you realise that it's the language of the universe things click why it is important, I'm not a mathematician nor do I need to be but I still appreciate those who are.
- ColinWright 9y agoMy (very limited) experience of more recent homework is that it makes perfect sense in the context of what the teachers are trying to teach, but no sense out of context to people who learned their maths decades ago. If you'd care to send me a photo of an example of the homework then I can try to give you some context and understanding. My contact details can be derived from my HN profile. I might be a little slow to reply at the moment as I'm in the middle of other things and only surfacing occasionally.
- jonsen 9y ago... makes perfect sense in the context of what the teachers are trying to teach ... What's the point with homework then? School takes the best part of a childs day, and when they don't make it through, the parents can finish with a tired child.
- ColinWright 9y ago"Homework" is supposed to be practising skills they have already learned so they can make it more fluent, and have to concentrate on it less when they come to the next thing to learn. Learning things is done with the teacher there to help anticipate, identify, and correct misconceptions. If you want the parent to help with the homework, the parent will have to know the material they want to help with. In maths, that's rarely the case unless it's the same thing they learned. And that's now out-of-date. Parents say they want their students to learn new, modern maths, and then insist that they are taught exactly what they were taught. And hated. Having said that, I'm really not going to defend anything about the existing setup and system. This is a huge mess, and while I have my own ideas, there's no way a discussion here will change anything, and it's likely that things I do say will be taken out of context, twisted, and mis-understood.
- boblivion 9y agoAs someone not from the U.S. I wonder, what does "outdated" mean? Can you give a simple example - e.g. comparison - what would be "math back then" and "math nowadays". Because to me math was always just math especially if it comes to numbers.
- throwawaybbqed 9y agoI wanted to echo the parent poster. I'm in my 30s and math made no sense as a kid - precisely because the problems were all artificial and uninteresting. I had to fight major math phobia in undergrad. For me personally, the most interesting application of math was figuring out orbits/positions of stars, etc. I have a 2 year old so if you have another favorite example like this, I'd love to hear about it.
- noir_lord 9y ago> the most interesting application of math was figuring out orbits/positions of stars. For me math started to click when I started writing simple games for the spectrum, I realized quite quickly that what I needed was trigonometry and once I knew the name I could go to the library and get out books. I was implementing a text based destroyer game (similar to mtrek/jtre though I didn't know those existed) and I had to implement handling bearings from the ship to the enemy ships, handle firing guns and missiles all that stuff, I made lots of horrible simplifications (shells experienced no air resistance so flew in perfect parabola's, the surface of the sea was a perfectly flat plane, no curvature (non-euclidean geometry would have been a step too far at 10-11) etc) but fundamentally it worked and was playable as a game, you could issue orders, fire shells (and later missiles though that made the game a lot more brutal and short) with bracketing and taking into time of flight - I was a strange child. I got the original idea from a ZX81 kids book on game programming that implemented a simple side projection game where you set the elevation and velocity of your shot and aimed for the opponents ship, it was simple (couple of pages of code) and I wanted to do something a bit more realistic - as a side benefit I ended up reading up on naval warfare in quite a lot of depth, again a strange child.
- michaelchisari 9y agoI don't mind this new way of teaching math, but on this note, I liked what Sal Khan had to say about flipping the process for school and homework. He proposed that students should watch lectures at home with a few problems for familiarity, and that classroom time should be spent working through problems in a guided environment. This allows students to pause, rewind, rewatch, etc. the lectures and move at their own pace, while getting expert guidance on the problems in person (and not relying on parents who may not have even looked at the source material in decades).
- dorchadas 9y agoAs a math teacher (Algebra II), I think this would be great. The problem is that most of my students won't go home and watch the videos. Either because they can't (lack of internet access, have to work to help support family, etc.) or are just lazy and won't. I've had to quit giving homework, even to the upper level classes, because nobody would do it. They'd just come in the next day and make excuses and have nothing done. This includes when they're homework was just to watch videos explaining problems they missed on a standardized test they took. Most just refused to watch the videos at home. It'd be great if they would watch the lectures and then be able to practice in the hour I see them daily, asking questions to clarify and such. But I can guarantee you it won't happen without a huge shift in the culture of education.
- sethammons 9y agoAs a former inner city math teacher, I feel you. Getting students to do _anything_ outside the classroom was practically impossible. What worked for me for homework for a little while was having the students do 5 push ups for each day they missed homework in a row. I suddenly was getting 90%+ participation on students completing their homework! It was fantastic until someone told the VP, and the VP asked me if I was actually doing that, whereby they informed me that it was corporal punishment and absolutely against the rules. I could rant about that for a bit, but I'm sure you can guess what happened after the pushups stopped: homework stopped. As for the shift needed in the culture of education, I totally agree. There needs to be a shift in accountability for the students, their families, and for schools. While there were parents who hoped their kids would do well at the school where I taught, there was a pervasive home attitude of school will get you nowhere. Many of the kids had no role models in their life where they could see any value to education. One VP I knew, in a neighboring district, married into a poorer latino family. They valued hard work, but only really understood hard manual labor type efforts. He was constantly hounded as he was going through schooling by them. "Why are you wasting this time at school? Why are you not doing more to provide for my daughter? Go get a real job." After finally becoming a teacher and then a VP and making more money than any other member of the family he married into, they started to see how education could be an investment. I don't know how you do that on a scale where the majority of socio-economically depressed families and communities can be exposed to the value of education.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoAnd techers are trying to teach how to make change? I understand “anchoring to fives and tens” but I don’t understand why anyone thinks it’s a good way to do anything except confuse kids. Does independent research prove these approaches increase numeracy?
- ColinWright 9y ago> And teachers are trying to teach how to make change? No, the "making change" comment is an example of how these techniques of thinking about numbers do turn up in real life. > I understand “anchoring to fives and tens” but I don’t understand why anyone thinks it’s a good way to do anything except confuse kids. It's a part of a broader strategy to talk about the structure of numbers and the operations on them. > Does independent research prove these approaches increase numeracy? Yes. I don't have access to it and can't give you any links, but there has been a lot of research about how to move away from the rote learning of algorithms and move towards understanding what numbers are and how they work. I've seen some of the research as a peripheral part of some of the projects I've been involved with, and it seems that these sorts of exercises really do serve to help students see more about what's really going on. The problem is the parents pushing back because they don't understand it, and don't believe it can be useful or helpful. For me, it seems obvious that this is a better way to think about things.
- garmaine 9y agoI’m a parent and I object not because I don’t understand it — it’s not too difficult to pick up — but because it completely misses the why of math. Being able to mentally estimate numbers or do simple arithmetic is a good skill, but having universal algorithms for solving problems and describing the universe is really what math is more about. I can trace my trajectory into computer science all the way back to practicing multiplication tables and discovering that I could multiply numbers in long form too large to fit in my head and yet get the exact result. It is the power of the algorithm. My kids are entirely missing that in their common core education...
- 9y ago
- contravariant 9y agoIt's a bit weird when your mathematics education enables you to understand a book written several millennia ago, but not homework written several decades later.
- ThomPete 9y agoUnderstanding why has always been my primary way to learn things. Do you have any suggestions for books or courses I could dig into to better understand this approach. My oldest who is 8 is quite good at math and on the math team and his school does do a lot to teach them but I want to help him how to think. In almost every other field I can but I am not good enough at math to understand which "games" to play.
- ColinWright 9y agoEveryone has a balance of these things, but in my experience there are two extrema to approaching maths. Some people are happy to be solving the puzzles, and simply enjoy the thrill of the chase. Others insist on knowing why they should be learning this, and what it's good for. Both are valid, but if there is A and B and you're naturally good at A, the natural tendency is to ignore or avoid B. But that then limits your box of tricks, and makes you one-dimensional. By all means take advantage of what you're good at, but work hard on the other aspects to enrich your abilities. Also, they cross-fertilise, so you get more than you might expect. With regards your oldest, it's worth trying a bunch of stuff to see if you can work out what they prefer. Then do both, but be prepared for having to work harder on one aspect than the other. Your oldest might like puzzles for their own sake, or might insist on knowing what it's for. Explore both. Find maths in strange places, work through puzzles just for their own sake. The critical key is to be doing stuff all the time. Caveat: I don't have children, I have no formal training, but I do a lot of outreach, enrichment, and enhancement.
- lsc 9y agoI personally find Serge Lang's "Basic Mathematics" to be super useful in explaining the "why" of a particular formula in pre-college level math, as most books at my current level just seem to say "memorize this" He has an explanation of why x^0 is 1 and not 0 that doesn't involve calculus, for instance.
- yorwba 9y agoWhat would be an explanation that involves calculus? The only one I know is that x^(a+b) = x^a * x^b holds for positive a and b, and to uphold that pattern, it's necessary that x^0 = 1, x^-1 = 1/x and so on. For me, all of that was covered long before calculus.
- scotty79 9y agoI think the key thing for making math worth knowing for a kid is making him realize that world is full of numbers. One way I intend to do that is providing kids with a lot of measuring devices as toys. Rulers, calipers, pirometers, timers, you name it. If it can give you number for something real then it's a good toy.
- lsc 9y agoSo, I know a lot less about math than you do. However, I have been studying lately myself, and reading a lot of Martin Gardner and Serge Lang; Both of those (and many of the other math types I read) seem to hold that making math practical can be useful... but it's not the point of learning math any more than learning how to spell correctly is the point of studying literature.
- DanBC 9y agoMost teachers are happy if you want to make an appointment to talk to them. Or the book "Maths for mums and dads" is useful. https://www.amazon.co.uk/Maths-Mums-Dads-Mike-Askew/dp/0224086359/ https://www.amazon.co.uk/Maths-Mums-Dads-Mike-Askew/dp/02240... https://www.amazon.co.uk/More-Maths-Mums-Dads-Askew/dp/0224095315/ https://www.amazon.co.uk/More-Maths-Mums-Dads-Askew/dp/02240...
- verylittlemeat 9y agoI don't know if this is useful but Richard Feynman used to play a game with his son where they would try to guess and compare the size differences between things as a way of learning units.
- dazc 9y agoThe original source you linked to in the article is a lot easier to read. sorry/ https://medium.com/q-e-d/just-teach-my-kid-the-expletive-math-fb6f495be906 https://medium.com/q-e-d/just-teach-my-kid-the-expletive-mat...
- ColinWright 9y agoThat's fine - I'm hosting the copy (with permission) because medium is blocked from some locations. Personally, I hate medium's default settings - I just feel like my face is being pushed through mush. But that's a personal thing, and I've certainly lost that battle. <fx: shrug />
- katet 9y agoThank you for that - Medium is blocked in Malaysia, for example, which I can bypass by using Google DNS on WiFi, but not on 4G...
- zbentley 9y agoInteresting. Is it blocked for content reasons (i.e. it hosts political material that is offensive to the censors of the local internet infrastructure) or techno-political reasons (Medium-the-hosting company is banned from providing content in the area due to the company itself)?
- thanatropism 9y agoIt has horrible always-there headers and footers that take a third of my 12" screen. Web designers really need to get their act together. Nothing of such bad quality gets out of the door in any other real industry.
- sctb 9y agoThanks, we've updated the link.
- ColinWright 9y ago
- credit_guy 9y agoMy problem with the "new math" is the lack of volume. Developing a sense for the numbers is best done by working more with numbers; in the "old math" kids had to do thousands of additions in the first and second grade, and developed ten times the sense of numbers compared to kids today. Theory is theory, but practice is practice. Just get over the addition and multiplication, please. That's not where the true math is. Don't spend so much time on finding the true meaning of addition by carry, you won't have time to teach kids logarithms and integrals later.
- empath75 9y agoLearning by rote doesn’t teach you anything.
- yorwba 9y agoSpending lots of time on the treadmill won't make you a great soccer player, but still trains a basic skill useful for the game. Similarly, doing lots of arithmetic by hand isn't enough to solve all kinds of real-world problems, but it does help develop an intuition for numbers, which then helps with the problem-solving part.
- zaphar 9y agoRote arithmetic may help you develop an intuition for numbers. It's hit or miss though and there are more effective and efficient methods than just doing a large volume of arithmetic. I believe the current trend in Math education is intended to take advantage of the more effective and efficient methods. Your treadmill is a good example actually. Much of the exercise world has realized that just jogging for a long period of time while effective is also not the most efficient way to exercise. Instead mixing periods of hi intensity workout with periods of lower pace workout can allow you to get more value with less time from you routine.
- credit_guy 9y agoAre you sure that it doesn't teach you anything? Somehow the students of "old math" were able to put a man on the Moon.
- maximexx 9y agoThere is a reason why most people hate math. IMAO the current system of teaching math is ancient and above all deprecated. We should not punish our kids with it. I mean, what's the point of drilling stupid sums if you'll hardly ever need it in your life? I think it is totally stupid and irresponsible if anyone does calculations without a calculator for almost any application, not excluding: store checkout, health care, aviation, etc.. The current educational methods are way pre-computer era, it desperately needs an upgrade. So why not start teaching kids concepts and let them use the technologies we create to solve problems that our minds are not wired for? Ever seen a teacher without a cheat sheet checking the answers? Guess why? Because their own calculations are too slow and above all not to be trusted! And should I not use a debugger because theoretically we can write proper code without it? Come on.. Please stop teaching our kids deprecated workflows. Teach them the best practice, the best way we know and can do now, because: "As the twig is bent the tree is inclined".
- merraksh 9y agoI mean, what's the point of drilling stupid sums if you'll hardly ever need it in your life? "Hardly ever"? So when checking the restaurant bill, the change at the grocery shop, the tax return, a bank investment proposal, the costs of building/renovating a house, the time left for a mortgage, do you always use a calculator?
- dorchadas 9y agoYou want us to teach them best practice? Then we need to teach them maths, without relying on calculators. I teach secondary maths (specifically Algebra II), and they can't understand what I'm supposed to be teaching them because they have no clue how numbers work. Why don't they know this, if they're 15/16? Because they were given calculators at too young of an age and know "just push the button". What you're arguing is for a complete removal of teaching math, period. Also, why would you want to pull out a calculator every time when it's often quicker to do some mental calculations in your head? For instance, I've seen my students multiply by two in the calculator. Then be amazed when I can just say it. Over-reliance on the calculators is already a huge issue, and we don't need to make it worse.
- nitwit005 9y agoWhat seems to happen in practice is the parents end up asking the teachers why they're teaching that way, and the teachers can't actually explain it. Obviously, the parents don't walk away impressed.
- sethammons 9y agoWhen I got my teaching credential for high school math, it became apparent and was openly recognized that many grade school level teachers choose that level of certification because they are, themselves, afraid of "math expected at the high school level." We expect many teachers who are math-phobic to lay down the foundational layers of mathematics with our kids. They cling to whatever the pre-made material and lessons are in the texts and often don't know why things are to be taught the way the texts want. Scary stuff.
- bfung 9y agoIs there a common core method to teach arithmetic in different a different base, like 8 or 16? The "old way" algorithm still works with different bases, you just change extend or truncate the rule for when to carry. Easy to teach your kid hexadecimal arithmetic using old way, like how my parents taught me in like grade 4 or 5 - and now I program for a living, haha
- gus_massa 9y agoIf you ignore the "anchor to 5s" part that is ridiculous, the other parts work in other bases too. D3-A7 = (D3-B0) + (B0-A7) = (D3-B0) + 9 = (D3-D0) + (D0-B0) + 9 = (D3-D0) + 20 + 9 = (D3-D0) + 20 + 9 = 3 + 20 + 9 = 2C (I swear that I didn't cheat to make the calculation and I made it in the "string" representation of the hexadecimal form, without looking at the decimal form.) In hexadecimal can try to anchor to 8s, it should work. Perhaps anchoring to 4s may be better? [Disclaimer: I don't like it, but the method to do the calculation works in other bases.]
- toomanybeersies 9y agoThis is a really good essay on what's wrong with how we teach mathematics to children: A Mathematicians Lament https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf https://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.... It's rather long, at 25 pages, but it's a very good and entertaining read. It was written in 2002 but it still holds water today.
- alphabettsy 9y agoIs the issue that parents don’t understand because it’s different from how they were taught or the teaching method does not work?
- mratzloff 9y agoWhen calculating in my head or on paper, I value quick estimations moving to greater refinement. Common Core math seems somewhat similar to this. I never subtract, only add up from low to high. If the two numbers have the same number of differing digits, I move from most significant digit to least: 73-57=10+6. If they cross a round number threshold greater than 10s, I get to a convenient base first: 2018-1995=5+18; 173-57=43+73=110+6. For multiplication, I do something similar: 6x57=300+42; 42x23=(42x20=800+40)+(42x3=120+6). For division in my head, I use a kind of binary search to get a quick estimate and then refine it. 846/42=42x10? 42x20+6. 20r6. 6/42=1/7. 0.15x7>1, 0.14x7<1. 20.14. From my understanding, the Common Core approach to math is much closer to this approach I developed intuitively than the traditional methods. I'm sure many others developed similar approaches. If I want an answer accurate to more than two decimal places, or if the math gets too complicated to keep in my head, I just use a calculator.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoThis is why I'm not opposed to the Common Core approach. It seems that they really emphasize math conceptualization and chunking instead of a formulaic process list that was used when I was a kid. Given the poor math scores in the US compared to other advanced countries, I really hope that this helps more younger people understand math.
- ghaff 9y agoThese things all go in cycles though. People were complaining about the "new math" back in the 1960s. As Tom Lehrer put it "Understanding what you're doing is the important thing, rather than to get the right answer." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wIWaJ0sy03g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wIWaJ0sy03g https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Math https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Math
- decasteve 9y agoI grew up being taught ‘borrow and carry’ methods. They are really methods of ‘apply the algorithm and success’. Common Core can be a better way of getting an intuitive sense of the numbers and quantities. Some examples are over the top, like the 32-20 in the article. But one of the common criticisms my parents and grandparents used to level at people my age (when I was a teenager) was that we couldn’t run a cash register—-we didn’t know how to make change. Kids won’t start out adding and subtracting as quickly. The ramp-up to learning may be a little slower but they’ll come out with a more intuitive sense of numbers. All of this is just my opinion. I studied Math and have a couple of young kids going through these methods in school now.
- tomxor 9y ago> We need to be sure not to insist on one approach when analyzing a problem It's encouraging to hear from educators out there who understand communicating the value of problem solving and comprehension is more important than rigid adherence to methodology and procedure. I remember the most useful aspect of my secondary school education (12-16yr) was learning how much I liked problem solving. However I came to this realisation through solving various simple math homework problems without following procedure (procedures which I remember finding particularly irritating for not explaining themselves) only to be lectured on how I had not followed the rules in spite of arriving at the correct solution and understanding the problem (albeit not well enough to figure out how the procedures worked). My teachers did exactly the opposite of what the above quote is saying - they insisted on one approach, without explanation, and it totally alienated me from math at the time. Thankfully I was never a very "good student" and it didn't dissuade me from enjoying the problem solving aspect, but it did leave a lasting impression of "i'm not good at math".
- autokad 9y agoits my understanding that common core math is of the theology that its more important to learn how to think than to solve the question. its also important to understand that if a kid uses 'the old way' to solve a question, they do not get points for it. remember, this is coming from an ideology that being taught how to think is priority number one, and priority number two is to not deviate from that thinking. it was always frustrating in hs, especially calculus when I would get 0 points for questions i had right because i used a shortcut, trick, or simply solved it more efficiently. then I got to college and the professor encouraged that. on the first major exam I scored a 96, far above anyone else, and the professor asked to shake my hand, because no one ever solved equations so efficiently before. i attack and do problems differently, sometimes out of necessity. dyslexia is an adversary of mine, and i find it better not to fight it on its home ground. i also read slow, and take much longer to absorb a problem into my head than other people. but once i do, i own it. unless people make me do it their way in the process. its like running 100m hurdles with 30 hurdles. im sure you love how you solve problems. you can do it fine your way, i cant. once you start forcing everyone to think one way and evaluating them, your measuring each animal how well they climb a tree.
- hprotagonist 9y agohttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UIKGV2cTgqA https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UIKGV2cTgqA “remember, base 8 is just like base 10, really, if you’re missing two fingers. Now, anyone who gets this right can stay after class and help clean the erasers...”
- ghaff 9y agoThe funny thing is that New Math's considerable focus on non-base 10 arithmetic and boolean logic was an academic exercise largely divorced from practical application for the vast majority of people at the time. While that may still be true in terms of the overall population, of course they're highly relevant to both programming and digital circuits.
- hprotagonist 9y agoIndeed. I’m post new math, but I had Boolean logic in 10th grade and it was a very helpful step up.
- darkkindness 9y ago> The 21st-century is not looking for humans who serve as calculating machines, but instead it seeks problem-solvers and innovative thinkers. I distinctly recall how one of my grade school teachers justified learning maths: "In the future, you aren't going to be walking around with calculators in your pocket!" Yet today I routinely check even simple calculations with the calculator in my pocket. I've found that error-checking is the key to doing 'well' in maths, yet that's something humans are bad at and something machines are great at. Given this, I'd love to see a future where learning to do math strongly emphasized learning how to best leverage computers for error-checking. That's a skill I wish I had developed earlier...
- dictum 9y ago> For instance, our standard arithmetic algorithms are somewhat bizarre - they are the end result of a human process of codifying arithmetical thinking, designed with the extra goal of using as little of precious 17th-century ink as possible I've long thought that this is partly why Mathematics are, paradoxically, at once terrifying and tedious for students. To learn a second language, you must immerse in it, using it as much as you can. Math has been attached to a language that is not used in daily life (except in a few situations, mostly very basic usage) and where the parallels to real usage feel contrived. If they weren't contrived, the question "what's the point of learning this" would get much clearer answers. When I was a student, I found it curious how I had trouble expressing certain concepts in that language, but when working with the same concepts in a programming language, things were much clearer. I can't offer a solution, but I think learning programming at a young age can help, though I'm personally against requiring it in classrooms, increasing the pressure on kids who are already exhausted with the rest of the curriculum.
- walshemj 9y agoThat's <adjective> Arithmetic not Mathematics
- dahart 9y ago> We need to communicate the true goal of given exercises to parents. This is spot-on, and can't be emphasized enough. The goals also need to be communicated multiple times, more clearly to the students, in writing in the homework. So much of the homework asks what seems like trick questions when I look at it. Whenever they weren't paying 100% attention in class, it seems like trick questions to them too. The exercises feel like they intentionally withhold stating the goals clearly for fear that it would give away the answer or fail to make the students struggle enough on their own. > Make showing/explaining your work interesting. This is true, but tough. Not every exercise should be an essay answer or story problem. The homework my kids get has lots of variations on exactly the example the author gave, and it doesn't feel like it's helping generate any appreciation for showing the work or for coming up with alternatives. It usually just feels like forced busywork. My real appreciation for showing my work only came in college physics when I finally realized that I make too many mistakes when I try to think my way through steps. Writing down every minor step was finally more efficient and accurate than not doing it.
- patja 9y agoI thought Hacker News preferred original source material rather than reblogging. Or is the original source not preferred in this case for some reason, for example being hosted on Medium? Original source: https://medium.com/q-e-d/just-teach-my-kid-the-expletive-math-fb6f495be906 https://medium.com/q-e-d/just-teach-my-kid-the-expletive-mat...
- sctb 9y agoThanks! We've updated the link from http://www.solipsys.co.uk/new/JustTeachMyChildTheMaths.html http://www.solipsys.co.uk/new/JustTeachMyChildTheMaths.html.
- ColinWright 9y agoAnd just for completeness ... now reverted because there is a good reason for re-hosting the article - Medium is blocked in some countries, and the re-hosting is to make it more widely available.
- zaroth 9y agoI’ve watched my daughter do her 3rd grade math homework both ways. She’s an ardent rule-follower at her age (and can’t quite understand why the boys in her class can’t stay out of trouble) and really enjoys doing her math homework. Watching her work on the extra credit math assignments and her get so exited when the multiplication problems extend into 8 digits is a lot of fun. Often she will do the problem the “new” way taking up maybe 10 minutes and a whole sheet of paper which looks more like an art project, and then when she’s done check her work the “old” way in a few seconds, and then go back and find the mistake in the drawings. She’s happy to do it “because that’s the way [my teacher] wants us to” but she’s faster and better at doing it the traditional way. My personal opinion is that CC is perhaps better at teaching basic math skills to the bottom 50% and is less likely to lose students along the way, but at the cost of holding back the top 50% of students approximately 1 full grade-level by the time they graduate high school. From my limited sample sized poll students see the new methods as being just as ridiculous as parents see them. And parents are generally pretty frustrated about this whole fiasco: https://youtu.be/wZEGijN_8R0 https://youtu.be/wZEGijN_8R0
- dorchadas 9y ago> My personal opinion is that CC is perhaps better at teaching basic math skills to the bottom 50% and is less likely to lose students along the way, but at the cost of holding back the top 50% of students approximately 1 full grade-level by the time they graduate high school. From my limited sample sized poll students see the new methods as being just as ridiculous as parents see them. This is an issue that would occur regardless of CC, I believe. Unless you can differentiate them into separate classes fairly early, and are constantly checking to see if everyone is in the correct group (for instance, I have several students who are labeled as gifted in math who can't do simple addition without a calculator... they were listed as gifted in third grade, and then never tested again), one of the two is always going to suffer. Either you help the higher level kids at the expense of the lower, or the lower at the expense of the higher. As for 'students see the new methods as being...' it's because they just mimic how their parents see them. Now, I don't teach elementary school so I don't know what they do, but reading comments here it seems they basically teach students how numbers work. And that's a good thing. I have high school students who didn't know that to multiply a number by 15, you could multiply it by 10 and by 5 then add the results. Along the same lines, they didn't know you could multiply by 10 then divide by 2 (or divide by 2 then multiply by 10) to get multiplication by 5. And this impacts them a lot more when we discuss variables and polynomials (which is mostly what Algebra II should be). They have no concept of how numbers work, so they don't understand why x^3/x = x^2.
- geebee 9y agoI don’t have any problem with common core or “new math”. I was a math major myself and have two kids in public school in SFUSD, and I think it’s valuable to develop ease and fluency in problem solving. An example in another thread, 2015 - 1985, is a good example. I like the idea that kids learning arithmetic would see how to solve this without a plug and chug approach. Here’s why I don’t find it promising: this is mimicry. The US found that other countries that teach math well don’t rely excessively on plug and chug. But these countries draw math teachers from the top math students. These teachers teach this way not because there is a new set of standards to adhere to but because this is how people who are good at math do math. Until the US draws math teachers from top math students, the new math will just be a new set of plug and chug steps. This is why the parent in the blog entry is frustrated- to them, new path is just more steps than old math. It may feel that way to the teachers as well, if they aren’t understanding what they’re doing. If we want to mimic Finland, we need to start by drawing teachers from the upper echelons of math students. And once you do this, much of this “new math” will happen organically. That may in fact be the only way it can happen.
- dorchadas 9y agoThe problem comes with how elementary schools are structured here (at least the ones in the district where I teach). If you even have enough teachers for each teacher to only have one grade (i.e. no split classes), they've got one teacher teaching each class until 4th or 5th grade. So you have the same teacher teaching history, science, math and language arts. This person probably struggled with math and often shuddered at the thought of the math portion of the Praxis test to become certified. They don't know how to do the math, but, because of how elementary schools are taught, you can't just hire a math teacher to teach math to all the students. Personally, I could easily see the benefits of shifting the students to a schedule where you went to a math class, taught by someone who knows math (i.e. the best math students), at the very beginning. It would also help because you could then make it where someone who is good at teaching, say, history, doesn't have to worry about passing a math content exam. Or at least one as in-depth as the math teacher. But, you also have to attract people to teaching. It's a thankless job, and, in my state, they're currently under attack on pension reform and pay and such. Our governor wants to remove mandatory sick days, for instance. And he wants to guy the pension. Or, he'll keep it all and gut all these other programs and then blame it on the teachers. Public education in the US as a whole is under attack, and that's part of the problem of getting the best math teachers. I'd be willing to bet Finland doesn't have to deal with the issue of charter schools like is currently happening in the US, either.
- jonsen 9y agoI just asked my stepdaughter "What is 33 minus 18?" "Because ... 18 plus 18 is 36 ..... it's 18 minus 3 ... 15!"
- bfung 9y agoIsn't it suppose to be: 18 to 20 is 2 20 to 30 is 10 30 to 33 is 3 2 + 10 + 3 = 15 ? Also, how does she know it's 18, plus an additional 18? Why not 18 + 20? What happens if it's 33 minus 21? 21 + 21 is 42... Just curious - but at least she's got her own system that works!
- jonsen 9y ago"If it's 33 minus 21, I'd probably do 3 minus 1 and 30 minus 20, because it's easy numbers."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mocopoco 9y agoThis is like the things you develop yourself as a child although broken down and over simplified. Maybe this should just be for the less intelligent children who do not have the skills to learn their own more efficient method. I can see this wasting too much of an able pupils time. Do you have streaming in America where you filter off children by ability like in Europe?, If so then maybe this is good for the lower streams to gain them insight into what more able pupils do anyway. (Though maybe not so convoluted).