3 ms·
Debian works best for languages that haven't standardized on their own easy-to-use package manager. Such as C and C++. Concentrate on that? If that's not ambit
by skybrian 9y ago
Debian works best for languages that haven't standardized on their own easy-to-use package manager. Such as C and C++. Concentrate on that?
If that's not ambitious enough, what would it take for the implementers of a new language to be convinced to just use Debian as their package manager? It seems like that would require a lot of changes.
- stevedonovan 9y agoConsider Rust - new _stable_ language release every six weeks. Debian would have puppies! However, having the 'rustup' tool available in the repos would work fine to bootstrap Rust environment. PS: plus, very explicit goal of Cargo is reproducible builds, which is a hard problem to generalize.
- pjmlp 9y agoEven those are trying to fix their lack of package managers, conan and vcpkg and the ones getting more love currently. OS level packages only work properly when developers just focus on a specific OS. The moment one wants to target as much OSes as possible, building OS specific packages becomes a pain and it is easier to outsource the problem to language specific package managers that abstract the OS layer.
- xg15 9y agoI understand this from the developer's perspective - but from a user's perspective, it's horrible UX. I usually don't care much which language the programs I use are written in - however I would very much like a single place where I can view, manage and update all installed packages. This does not work if each package manager keeps its own list. It also feels ridiculous to have to install another package manager if you only want to have a certain command line tool. Maybe this could be solved by a sort of meta-standard for package managers, so the OS has at least some way to aggregate all package managers and language-specific packages installed. Of course, as always with meta-standards, you might fall into the XKCD trap...
- weberc2 9y agoContainers solve this nicely; developers are free to use their language's package manager to build container images which the user can manage via a single interface. Of course, this means you often have more duplicate code on your disk and the update model changes, but that's alright for me.
- qznc 9y agoWhat are they supposed to do for Windows, Android, and other operating systems?