2 ms·
We're really drifting far off-topic here. My point is the Oracle lawsuit has nothing to do with Harmony (the library, which implements no part of the VM) or ASF
by pvg 16y ago
We're really drifting far off-topic here. My point is the Oracle lawsuit has nothing to do with Harmony (the library, which implements no part of the VM) or ASF, it is not a suit against 'open source'. I imagine that we're all in violent agreement here that what Oracle is doing is icky and lame. But it's also mildly distasteful, FUD-ish and insulting to intelligence for Google to be running around saying 'Oracle is suing open source'. I think bringing up Harmony (or OpenJDK, or Clojure, or a bit of Java you wrote in college, etc) is either being a worrywart or taking Google's verbiage at face value.
- davidw 16y agoYeah "open source" is not correct, but it's certainly accurate to say that Oracle is suing Google regarding open source code they produce. Also, I wouldn't be too sanguine: what do you think Oracle would have done had Google used the Harmony VM to produce a system like Android?
- pvg 16y agowhat do you think Oracle would have done had Google used the Harmony VM to produce a system like Android? I think probably the exact same thing, if the resulting VM was not a spec-compliant VM or otherwise did not fall under the various IP exemptions. Dalvik itself is a much bigger opening for someone to use software patents in a predatory way - if what Gosling's been saying lately is true, Oracle had that as a goal all along. But much of that has to do with the unique peculiarities of Dalvik - a VM that runs something that's like, but isn't quite Java-as-specified.
- ergo98 16y ago> think bringing up Harmony (or OpenJDK, or Clojure, or a bit of Java you wrote in college, etc) is either being a worrywart or taking Google's verbiage at face value. Oracle is suing based upon relatively general patents that it would be difficult to implement a modern VM without running afoul of. The Apache Harmony DRLVM absolutely and positively runs afoul of exactly the same patents. In fact I would wager that Ruby, python, and several other runtimes are subject to exactly the same patent liability. Saying "They didn't sue them" is preposterous. Patents don't require that you sue every subjective infringer. Instead, if you're a company like Oracle, you go after people with deep pockets.
- pvg 16y agoThe Harmony VM is a cleanroom VM and spec-compliant VM. http://en.swpat.org/wiki/Java_and_patents http://en.swpat.org/wiki/Java_and_patents ASF would be loudly crusading if they themselves thought they were actually directly affected by this lawsuit and the patents.
- ergo98 16y ago>The Harmony VM is a cleanroom VM and spec-compliant VM. Dalvik is a cleanroom VM. I'm not quite sure what you're saying with this? The OpenJDK comes with a patent grant. Cleanroom VMs have no such grant and it's impossible to make one without infringing on the patents.
- jfager 16y agoWhy is this getting upvoted? You're wrong. Spec-compliant jvms get a patent grant. Dalvik isn't spec-compliant, so it doesn't get the grant.
- koenigdavidmj 16y agoAnd his point was basically that any VM implementing any bytecode language might very well violate the patents in question. Anyway, Dalvik does not even claim to execute Java bytecode, but its own language. Does that not mean that it is in pretty much the same legal footing as, say, the Python bytecode interpreter? And there exists plenty of prior art on the VM, all the way back to 1966 ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-code_machine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-code_machine ), so I am not so easily convinced that the patent is going to survive the trial.
- ergo98 16y agohttp://www.apache.org/jcp/sunopenletter.html http://www.apache.org/jcp/sunopenletter.html To my knowledge Harmony has never been given a patent grant. When they tried to obtain the blessing, Sun responded by releasing the OpenJDK, which they bound (with conditions) their patent grants to. If something else happened that I am ignorant of, please tell me, but to my knowledge Harmony has zero patent protection. As an aside, the reason Sun refused to grant Harmony a patent grant was that there was the open possibility that it could cannibalize J2ME (at the time Sun was fairly successful in that space, so they were deeply protective, whereas they were failing on the desktop)