4 ms·
I don't know why he writes so universally. >"digital technologies are training us to be more conscious of and more antagonistic toward delays of all sorts." I
by gumby 9y ago
I don't know why he writes so universally.
>"digital technologies are training us to be more conscious of and more antagonistic toward delays of all sorts."
Indeed and this is why I read: I just don't have the patience for video, much less (shudder) audio. With a book there's no gap between word and image, and the book flows at the speed I want (I can always skip ahead, or linger, or jump back to that previous spot). While a video is forcably linear (not to mention all the buffering, startup delays, and ads).
A tweetstorm requires so much cognitive overhead to follow (since each one is a discrete sentence or two with a large gap to move your eye down to the next one). You have to maintain so much context from the previous tweet while searching for the next one it's hard to actually absorb anything.
Frankly the biggest problem with reading is bingeing. You come up for air hours later with a crick in your neck and wonder where the day went.
- nixpulvis 9y agoUnless you're a slow reader ;)
- gumby 9y agoWell true, I wasn't claiming universality (was criticizing the original author) and was instead saying things are different for me. Sure, some people of course have physiological restrictions on their reading ability, even if they have 20/20 vision (e.g. dyslexia for reading systems that exhibit that). But it appears to be pretty well attested at this point that reading exploits properties of the early visual system as well as deep-rooted higher level functions like looking for regular convex forms (perhaps for seeking animal tracks). It also may be the case that interpretation of 3D scenes (including for people without stereoscopic vision in their early visual system -- about 15% of the population) is innate while interpretation of 2D images is learned, even (or perhaps especially) moving images. Which would seem to imply that the more you read the faster and more automatic it becomes. It's not at all clear that a slow reader is any faster at absorbing and integrating/using information picked up in video. Of course personal tastes come in here too. I'm not claiming one is inherently superior, just claiming there may be deeper integration between the brain and reading than your average third grade teacher is going to consider.
- nixpulvis 9y agoMy thoughts can be summarized as follows: You'd watch a video on how to build a fire before you read a book on the subject. And you'd be smart to read a book at your own pace. Like any art, the medium matters.
- khedoros1 9y agoI'd read written instructions first, possibly including clarifying diagrams. I'd continue to a video if the written instructions were insufficiently clear. Video is almost never my medium of first resort; it's intuitive, but inflexible.
- essayist 9y agoAgreed on all counts. I generally skip "it's all in the video" unless it's a very high quality production. For tweetstorms, threadreaderapp.com is a life-saver.
- oeuviz 9y agoWhat is it you are hoping to find in a tweetstorm that you would want to read through all of it? There is rarely any outcome worth digging.
- WaltPurvis 9y agoNot true. There are several people I follow who post long threads of 50 or more tweets and the cumulative content is often excellent. It's annoying, however, because the content would be better presented, more easily consumed, and far more permanent/substantial if they would just write it in essay form and post it to Medium or some other blog. I don't know why they persist in misusing Twitter.
- essayist 9y agoFair point. I mostly get to these because someone I trust has pointed to them. I don't go through my feed (ever, really), but certainly not to find worthwhile tweetstorms. Life is too short.
- scarface74 9y agoI spend between 4-7 hours commuting a week and around 5 hours a week exercising. That's up to 12 hours a week I can use to listen to podcasts or listen to audiobooks. I find the type of prolonged reading incredibly unproductive.
- mirimir 9y agoIndeed. I've been online for over 30 years, and I can still read. Admittedly, though, I've come to prefer Stover, Abercrombie, Morgan and other violence porn. But hey. And I also don't have the patience for audio and video. I'd maybe like audio if I commuted. But I don't. And hard music is better for that, in any case.
- waterhouse 9y agoIn case it helps—there are browser extensions, at least for Firefox and Chrome, that allow you to make videos play faster. I use "Video Speed Controller"; it has hotkeys to increase/decrease speed in units of 10%, to jump back and forth by 10 seconds (and all the above numbers and keys are customizable), and more; I think it works on any HTML5 video, including Youtube. The audio speedup is well done; I don't think it makes it harder to understand except insofar as I have less time to process it. I often view videos at 1.4x to 1.8x speed, and I have friends who say they go faster.
- reificator 9y agoYouTube itself already has speed controls, if I'm learning technical content I generally watch at 2.0x. Unless the presenter has an accent I don't hear often, in which case I usually need to slow down quite a bit. Or if they're not a very good presenter, with mumbling or odd pacing or issues like that. With text I don't have to slow down as much to correct bad spelling/grammar, since I've seen so much of it. You lose any emotion or emphasis but you gain resilience when communicating across cultures.
- mrob 9y agoAFAIK YouTube doesn't have single key shortcuts to jump to fixed speeds. You can speed up and slow down with '>' and '<', which I find less convenient because it's easier to set the wrong speed. You can also skip back and forward by 5 seconds with the left and right arrow keys, which is convenient when you're watching at 2x speed and you miss something.
- reificator 9y ago> YouTube doesn't have single key shortcuts to jump to fixed speeds. True, that would be nice to have. > You can speed up and slow down with '>' and '<', which I find less convenient because it's easier to set the wrong speed. Really? Given the two options I would rather have relative controls rather than absolute for playback speed. 2.0x with Speaker A might sound like 1.6x with Speaker B, due to their different cadences, accents and mannerisms. > You can also skip back and forward by 5 seconds with the left and right arrow keys, which is convenient when you're watching at 2x speed and you miss something. This is definitely available on YouTube by default. Don't know the skip length off the top of my head though, it might be higher or lower.
- Yetanfou 9y ago> Indeed and this is why I read: I just don't have the patience for video, much less (shudder) audio. Both video as well as audio can have a function but neither of them replaces written text. Video can be useful as an addition to written text in the same way that a practical demonstration adds to a lecture. Audio fills a niche all of its own since you can listen - or half-listen - to it while doing other things. As long as these sources are used in addition to a written original or base document nothing of value is lost. If video is the only source I tend to assume that the narrator does not have that much to say and skip it. If audio is the only source - as often is the case with lectures or panel discussions - I sometimes listen to it while I prepare food or build on the house or do something else which requires partial attention. I might skip back in the audio stream every now and then to catch something which went by half-heard the first time but as this is much more tedious than re-reading a paragraph in a written text the format is not a replacement for it.
- dtornabene 9y agothe quote was from Nicholas Carr though, from The Shallows. The point of that book was to be universal. It was to try and suss out the ways that digital technology is affecting us. He engages with quite a bit of neuroscience to do precisely that. I hate to be that guy....but you're kind of making his point for him here. The part specifically made about skimming and surface interpretation ( "His" being Carr's, and the point being from The Shallows).
- gumby 9y agoThere's nothing wrong with being "that guy" -- this is a discussion. Regardless of Carr's thesis, Harris quotes two of Carr's comments, without providing additional context, to make his own point. And that point is made through broad quotes from Eric Schmidt, McLuhan (a more hopeful quote actually though Harris doesn't expand on it), Shirkey et al. My point was simply that although his title was that he has stopped reading, and feels that he is now perhaps unable to read anything with any depth, his text tries to argue a more universal claim.