3 ms·
You pay $x, with a chance to receive items worth between $0.1x and $10x. It's true that x might not be able to converted to fiat or resold. That makes it effe
by shakna 9y ago
You pay $x, with a chance to receive items worth between $0.1x and $10x.
It's true that x might not be able to converted to fiat or resold.
That makes it effectively equivalent to a raffle, which often put restrictions on reselling similar to these cases.
Raffles are considered a form of gambling, and are heavily regulated, in the UK[0] and Australia [1].
[0] http://www.gamblingcommission.gov.uk/for-the-public/Fundraising-and-promotions/Fundraising/Lotteries-at-events.aspx http://www.gamblingcommission.gov.uk/for-the-public/Fundrais...
[1] https://www.vcglr.vic.gov.au/gambling/raffle/licensee-resources/faqs https://www.vcglr.vic.gov.au/gambling/raffle/licensee-resour...
- nkrisc 9y agoFair point.
- ubernostrum 9y agoIs Mario Kart regulated as a gambling game in the UK? Sure, you can't convert its items into money, but you can convert them into wins in the game. And it has a "random" item drop system that's known to be rigged.
- andrepd 9y agoYou do not pay to open a Mario Kart item box.
- shakna 9y agoThat's a disingenuous comparison at best. No exchange takes place. No fiat is given for a chance to open a box.
- ubernostrum 9y agoIs the game sold for free? If I buy a video game and play it and occasionally get loot boxes that may have ultra-powerful items or may not, that's gambling. But if I buy a video game and play it and occasionally get items that aren't called loot boxes but may be ultra-powerful or may not, that's not gambling?
- shakna 9y ago> If I buy a video game and play it and occasionally get loot boxes Why do you hide the repeated purchase? The game is bought, once. Loot-boxes require another purchase - an uninformed one. You purchase an item for a chance at something else, a chance that you don't actually know. Mario Kart would be gambling, if you had to buy every crate as you hit it. As it is, with no additional purchase, it is simply a randomised strategic feature. Currency of some form needs to be exchanged to create gambling.
- stonemetal 9y agoIf you can't sell it, and it can't be paid for directly how can it be worth "between $0.1x and $10x" Some items might be more desirable but you can't pay more or less for them. That is rather different than a raffle where the prize is usually something easy to put a price on.
- shakna 9y agoWe also raffle off dates with celebrities, and other things where value isn't clear-cut. It still usually falls under the same rules.
- technion 9y agoRaffle regulation in Australia is commonly treated as a joke though. Everyone just calls them "guessing competitions", where you buy a raffle to "guess the name of the three letter easter chocolate that starts with e and ends in g". Even schools - noting you can't promote gambling to children - get away with that regularly. With those loopholes, you could probably get away with a lot.
- shakna 9y agoGuessing games still fall under regs in Australia [0]. Schools can run them fine, as most schools fall under "charitable organisation", so they just need written consent from the board, and a prize less than the state's maximum unlicensed game competition amount. ($5000 in Victoria, $2000 in Queensland). [0 PDF] https://publications.qld.gov.au/dataset/fc2f9cdd-8799-45bf-977b-0f157ee75024/resource/6d34128b-22ed-47b1-be76-d16c739d10e3/download/category1games.pdf https://publications.qld.gov.au/dataset/fc2f9cdd-8799-45bf-9...