4 ms·
>> The 55-country study he cited has effectively one of the highest P-values in social science of recent years. It's widely considered in psychology to be an im
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> The 55-country study he cited has effectively one of the highest P-values in
social science of recent years. It's widely considered in psychology to be an
important result. Denying this is basically parroting intellectual dishonesty
on the level of Global Warming denialism.
Of course it is not and I take umbrage at the offensive undertone of your
comment ("parroting"? Really?). Psychology is not climate science, it's
currently going through a widely publicised reproducibility crisis and in any
case, the reliance on p-values has been criticised widely by experts in
fields as varied as economics, medicine and of course the humanities. The big-5 model itself has been the subject of much criticism, from inside the field (and the wikipedia article you reference has a big section devoted to that criticism).
More improtantly however, Damore did a lot more than name-drop the big-5 in
his memo. The memo is peppered with references to sources from varied fields,
from psychology and sociology, to biology, evolutionary psychology,
anthropology, economics, statistics and so on.
The problem of course is that Damore is not an expert in any of those fields-
much less an expert in all of them. Which tells us that, most of the time,
when he says that some paper he's referencing is backing his views, he simply
hasn't got a clue what he's talking about and the paper may very well be
claiming exactly the opposite than what Damore is saying.
Damore's memo is indulging in cargo-cult science. He references stuff he
half-understands in the hopes to do what scientists do. Except he doesn't even
understand what scientists do and why they reference others' work: which is to
say, not to win a debate and show you're right on the internets, but to
contribute new knowledge by building on the knowledge already contributed by
others.
To have any respect for science and consider Damore's memo anything else than
pseudo-scientific claptrap is a contradiction. To call that garbage "science"
is offensive to the work of scientists. That is an even bigger reason to be
angry at an idiot like that, without even going to what he was trying to say
with his "sai-ent-tifickal" way.
- stcredzero 9y agoOf course it is not and I take umbrage at the offensive undertone of your comment ("parroting"? Really?). Psychology is not climate science, it's currently going through a widely publicised reproducibility crisis and in any case, the reliance on p-values has been criticised widely by experts in fields as varied as economics, medicine and of course the humanities. The big-5 model itself has been the subject of much criticism, from inside the field (and the wikipedia article you reference has a big section devoted to that criticism). So you're admitting that James Damore is referencing legitimate scientific sources. It's just that you're claiming the whole field isn't valid. Then you go on to make unsubstantiated claims that his interpretations are wrong, but you produce no specifics. That sounds a lot like what climate science deniers do.
- tptacek 9y agoI don't think that is a very fair summary of that comment, which was considerably more detailed than the one that preceded it.
- stcredzero 9y agoI re-read the comment several times. What I get out of it, is that he notes that Big-5 has been criticized. That's what's supposed to happen in science. Bringing up that something is criticized in science is a classic climate denier tactic! (Also, given the controversial subject matter, one would expect that.) He also mentions his credentials. Then he engages in name calling. ("cargo-cult.") I'm sorry, but exactly where in that comment does he actually substantiate anything? After several readings, it still looks like he doesn't.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoHe's citing "legitimate scientific sources" but he doesn't understand them, so his citations are meaningless. Where am I claiming that "the whole field isn't valid"? I said there's a reproducibility crisis and that the reliance on p-values has been criticised in various fields. I made no claim that his interpretations are "wrong". I said that his interpretations are most likely wrong because he's not a psychologist and he doesn't understand the field. That's what you expect from non-experts who pretend to know what they're talking about, to be talking nonsense. >> That sounds a lot like what climate science deniers do. You keep insulting me.
- stcredzero 9y agoHe's citing "legitimate scientific sources" but he doesn't understand them, so his citations are meaningless. You seemingly refuse to substantiate this. I made no claim that his interpretations are "wrong". I said that his interpretations are most likely wrong because he's not a psychologist What would you say if a prominent and widely cited academic and clinical Psychologist corroborated his interpretations? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEDuVF7kiPU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEDuVF7kiPU I think your response would be to again be intellectually dishonest and tar him by association. However, in doing so, you abandon your former position. You keep insulting me. No, what you are doing semantically parallels what climate science deniers do. You are using the same techniques and tactics, seemingly counting on the audience to be too lazy to read the actual sources for themselves. My comparison is functional. If you wish to prevent me from making that point, then please start substantive responses, using facts, reasoning, and references. Otherwise you are just using the climate denier tactic of repeated assertion.