18 ms·
I get that the tulip thing it's over-blown, but... "When the crash came, it was not because of naive and uninformed people entering the market, but probably th
by mcguire 9y ago
I get that the tulip thing it's over-blown, but...
"When the crash came, it was not because of naive and uninformed people entering the market, but probably through fears of oversupply and the unsustainability of the great price rise in the first five weeks of 1637."
So, what happened in January, 1637?
"So those who lost money in the February crash did so only notionally: they might not get paid later. Anyone who had both bought and sold a tulip on paper since the summer of 1636 had lost nothing. Only those waiting for payment were in trouble, and they were people able to bear the loss."
Does the author know how debts work?
- skookum 9y agoEven a small amount of time spent perusing Bitcoin fora reveals an endemic belief that if one doesn't sell, one has incurred no loss. Any conversations discussing a realized loss will quickly surface the "weak hands" meme wherein the loser simply didn't have sufficient will or presence of mind to keep HODLing and selling their Bitcoins served to benefit the better investors who were able to buy them at a discount. Perhaps the author is simply playing to the zeitgeist?
- cgmg 9y agoDo you have any evidence to back up your claim that the author believes “if one doesn't sell, one has incurred no loss”?
- skookum 9y agoI made no such claim about the author's beliefs. I posited that the author was pandering to an audience with such beliefs, an audience who loves these "tulip mania didn't happen" stories because in their logic they somehow serve as rebuttal to the possibility that crypto-currencies are experiencing a speculative mania of their own.
- cgmg 9y ago> I posited that the author was pandering to an audience with such beliefs Why did you posit that?