3 ms·
Finland now has a government program for doing such studies, called Kokeilun Paikka ("Place to Experiment"). They are using it to do a random trial of basic in
by gumby 9y ago
Finland now has a government program for doing such studies, called Kokeilun Paikka ("Place to Experiment").
They are using it to do a random trial of basic income. The results to date are ambiguous, showing both that it's hard to get a large n and hard to pick the measurement criteria.
Also: although I agree with the thrust of the book, there are additional issues for programs like Head Start: 1> it's hard sometimes to find or identify the kids who need it most, so by making it broader you improve your chances of reaching those most at need, at the cost of "helping" others who may not really need it 2> when you make programs universal, you get broader support than when you only extend it to those most in need. Look at the additional restrictions just placed last month on those in the US getting public assistance -- restrictions which make it hard for those most in need to actually get the benefit! This is why the New Deal extended social security to everyone and dressed it up it so that it appeared to be an insurance scheme you paid into: everyone would feel they "earned it" so nobody would want to cut it.
Thus in the US school meals are not universal or free, which stigmatizes the kids who get them. In most developed countries the kids all get lunch in school, which helps the nutrition of the poorer kids. Likewise, making public transport free would pull cars off the road, making drivers happier...but when they feel they are paying for "those people", voters typically hate using road taxes to pay for streetcars and subways. Perhaps the ability to tax self-driving vehicle fleets will change that.
This sort of goes back to the Finnish observation of the difficulty of making measurements.