3 ms·
> If we really want to know whether prevention saves money, maybe we should take a wider perspective. Does spending on prevention save the country money over al
by crazygringo 9y ago
> If we really want to know whether prevention saves money, maybe we should take a wider perspective. Does spending on prevention save the country money over all? A recent report from the Congressional Budget Office in the New England Journal of Medicine suggests the answer is no. The budget office modeled how a policy to reduce smoking through higher cigarette taxes might affect federal spending... In the long run, all of those people living longer would lead to increases in spending in many programs, including health care. The more people who quit smoking, the higher the deficit from health care — barely offset by the revenue from taxing cigarettes.
What about those peoples' economic productivity as they work for another decade? What about the other jobs they help maintain by spending the money they make from their productivity? What about the care they provide to their grandkids?
This article takes an incredibly myopic view. If we're sticking to pure economics, the metric shouldn't be to decrease lifetime health care costs... the metric should be to decrease the ratio of lifetime health care costs to lifetime economic productivity, broadly measured.
- boxed 9y agoEven if they did take economic activity into accounting that seems besides the point. The same argument would make it a really good idea to introduce the death penalty for reaching retirement age! If you optimize for something stupid you get stupid results.
- gutnor 9y agoThere is a bit of a nihilist nature to it too. Current modern society only achievement is making people live better, longer. There is no scientific, objective reason to do that. It is only the arbitrary (slightly helped by biology) value we put on human life that makes us do that. You can look at about everything, be it healthcare, government, defence, or even economy and money and the only cold logical conclusion is that it serves no purpose. Makes me think we better be careful with AI. Overly survivalist AI can kill all humans, the opposite is one that eventually find out that killing all human now is the fastest way to help humanity reach its natural conclusion.