4 ms·
The real difference is that the jail system is privatized in the US, so that it has become a profiting system not that different from hotels and resorts. Hotels
by squarefoot 9y ago
The real difference is that the jail system is privatized in the US, so that it has become a profiting system not that different from hotels and resorts. Hotels and resorts need to get a constant influx of customers to be kept in business, so do private prisons, and harsh punitive laws help to get that goal. Make prisons public and the sudden need to save taxpayers money will force them to keep only real criminals behind bars.
- maxxxxx 9y agoPrivate prisons are a small percentage of all jails. That's not the reason for long sentences.
- fwsgonzo 9y agoI used to say that for a long time too, and its still technically correct, but so much in the prison system is part of a business (like phone calls and "work" and other necessities). A small introduction: https://www.globalresearch.ca/the-prison-industry-in-the-united-states-big-business-or-a-new-form-of-slavery/8289 https://www.globalresearch.ca/the-prison-industry-in-the-uni...
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoIt's not just the prison system either, it's the whole justice system. Make the penalties for everything unreasonably harsh you escalate what criminals are willing to do to avoid their people going to jail. They're more likely to carry weapons and murder witnesses and the whole works. Which allows the police to justify more SWAT teams and military hardware and surveillance gear that all come from private for-profit corporations. Arms dealers love an arms race.
- barry-cotter 9y agoPrison guard unions have exactly the same incentives, whether in the EU, Canada or the US.
- jernfrost 9y agoPrison guards are completely different kinds of people in these countries. In the US a prison guard is a guy that gets a week training on how to hit people with a stick. In Norway it is a 2-3 year college education with exams. It is a completely different kind of people who join this profession. You don’t spend 2-3 years getting this education unles you really believe in chaning people. It is not just some job to make a buck.
- justaguyhere 9y agoHysteria whipped up by media/politicians, private prison industry etc all contribute to the problem, but the attitude of the general public towards crime/punishment is very different here. This is true even after someone gets released from prison - it is so hard to find jobs, apartments etc once you've been to prison. I don't know of any other country that has elections for judges!
- madengr 9y agoThat’s a safeguard to prevent the executive branch (president, governor, mayor) from installing judges. I vote them out every election. They should have term limits.
- stordoff 9y agoIs blinding voting to remove not counter-productive? I feel like it would incentivise judges to act even more in line with popular opinion to swing the needle back the other way.
- CaptSpify 9y agoI'm curious as to why you think elections for judges is a bad thing? I'm not advocating for that system (I'm the first to say the US system is completely fucked), but the only other way I know of is by getting appointed, which also seems like a terribly corrupt system to me.
- isostatic 9y agoDo you think we should elect doctors? Surely doctors should be experts in medicene, and judges should be experts on law. If you're elected you are an expert in being elected.
- iforgotpassword 9y agoYes but if a doctor sucks, nobody will consult him anymore after a while but with judges you don't get to pick one ...
- ballenf 9y agoGiven that jails don't charge the inmates to stay there, your analogy is quite broken. Taxpayers foot the bill either way.
- squarefoot 9y agoBut where does the money come from then? Or better, where the incentive to put minor offenders in jail comes from? Especially taking into account how this makes much harder for them to have a normal life (job, friends, familiy etc.) afterwards. It seems things are arranged to get more people behind bars and make easier for them to return there; that way people who enter a jail for something trivial are more likely to become real criminals. Some other users corrected me about the number of private jails so I'm genuinely interested to know. There are businesses involved with procuring guards, firearms, clothing, meals etc, but that would not change much in state owned prisons; in many countries it's perfectly normal to have public entities subcontracting services to the private sector.
- FireBeyond 9y agoUmmm, in many places in the US, absolutely does the jail charge inmates to stay there. Find yourself locked up in Macomb Co, MI? You will receive a bill for $60/day for your incarceration as you are released. Florida State Prison? Be prepared for a "cost of incarceration lien" to be levied by the state at the rate of $50/day for often multi-year sentences. Such fees are authorized (though not always enforced) in 43 states. So the analogy is not at all broken. 1. http://money.cnn.com/2015/09/18/news/economy/prison-fees-inmates-debt/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2015/09/18/news/economy/prison-fees-inm... 2. http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-34705968 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-34705968 3. https://www.brennancenter.org/analysis/paying-your-time-how-charging-inmates-fees-behind-bars-may-violate-excessive-fines-clause https://www.brennancenter.org/analysis/paying-your-time-how-...
- drharby 9y agoWait - Really? Cruel and unusual?
- grkvlt 9y agoI think the US had this 'retribution' aspect of imprisonment already. Even before the prison-industrial complex, which admittedly is doing its best to perpetrate long sentences to maintain profits...