3 ms·
He says: >that these differences may [emphasis added] explain why we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership And he says one of the dif
by cma 9y ago
He says:
>that these differences may [emphasis added] explain why
we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership
And he says one of the differences is a higher drive for status. That is one way it could change without the 80's thing being counter-evidence, if the status of practitioners and/or leadership in the field changed for some reason (maybe Bill Gates becoming the richest man in the world).
I'm not saying that I agree with him, or that the status drive difference is true, or that it would actually be an explanation for the difference from the 80s to now (Bill Gates might have lowered the status of the field for being socially awkward). I'm only saying that your counter argument may not work because he couched his statement in "may" and he talks about meta-level factors around the field.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThis is well researched in the feminist sociology literature. When a "women's job" (like teaching or nursing) becomes more respected, pay goes up, and... The industry gets an influx of men working in it.
- gaius 9y agopay goes up, and... The industry gets an influx of men working in it. But isn’t the opposite true as well? I mean, it wasn't that long ago that the IT department was at the bottom of the organisational pecking order, sometimes literally at the bottom in a dingy, windowless basement, and jokes about nerds and geeks and personal hygiene and poor fashion choices and so on were totally mainstream and acceptable. In those days, no-one said it was problematic that these losers and social lepers tended to skew male. Obviously, everyone should be free to do any work that they want to and show an aptitude for. But you posit a one-way traffic that just isn't true.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kingofhdds 9y agoI'm not sure it's supported by a really wide research. Scandinavian countries boast high equality ratings, and feminism being a part of political mainstream, AND social/tax system, which significantly reduces gap between high-, and low-salaried positions as well as competition between employees. And still tech is essentially a male field, and nursing - female-dominated.
- burfog 9y agoCause: at the original wage, supply is low and demand is high Effect: wages rise Effects of that effect: men choose the job, and respect increases
- dzhiurgis 9y agoIf status hypothesis is right, it explains why women didn't change since 80s. What did indeed changed since then is popularity of tech. With more money floating around there are more people seeking for status.