4 ms·
In context, that appears to be referring to voting or supporting a candidate in elections, not for discussing platforms or issues.
by gowld 9y ago
In context, that appears to be referring to voting or supporting a candidate in elections, not for discussing platforms or issues.
- bduerst 9y agoi.e. Promoting political viewpoints at work is not protected speech, especially when it's disruptive.
- randyrand 9y agoThe line between those seems quite thin. Showing support for a candidate is quite literally showing support for a certain set of platforms or political idea.
- gowld 9y agoYes, but the converse is less clear, which is why supporting ideas is more acceptable than campaigning for a candidate.
- finnthehuman 9y agoNo. You can't put the law "in context" while outright ignoring case law. Courts have consistently found 1101 and 1102 to offer broad protection. I'm not a lawyer, nor want to do the research. AIUI from learned legal commentary, the broadness has not been tested for exactly this sort of issue, but that doesn't make it slam-dunk unprotected either. You're claiming to put something "in context," but rather than clarify you're obscuring. This type of fake-smart comment is what makes me hate hacker news.
- gowld 9y agoIt's not "fake-smart" to read a document and try to understand it. Refusing to do research yet making uncited authoritative claims strikes me as far more "fake-smart" This type of arrogant hostile condescension makes me unhappy with with Hacker News.