3 ms·
> We are just saying that what has been considered immoral and illegal should stay that way. But that doesn't seem like a reliable guiding principle on its own
by majormajor 9y ago
> We are just saying that what has been considered immoral and illegal should stay that way.
But that doesn't seem like a reliable guiding principle on its own, e.g. mixed race marriage.
This is one of those things where there is no compromise that satisfies both sides, so from a least-harm perspective, it seems better to, as far as the state goes, pick the people who probably don't have a choice in the matter (I'm inclined to believe that homosexuality is primarily an innate thing, because I never chose to be straight, and can't imagine choosing to be homosexual) versus the beliefs of certain religious groups.
And the history of racial discrimination in the US points the way towards the reasoning behind equal-service type requirements for businesses. Any problems caused seem much smaller than the (proven!) potential for abuse if the laws weren't there.
- Veelox 9y ago> This is one of those things where there is no compromise that satisfies both sides Agree completely on that point. As much as I don't like the outcome, I think you are right on what the legal outcome should be based on the cultural viewpoint that homosexuality is innate. A) Interracial Marriage is immoral. B) Homosexual Marriage is immoral. C) Remarriage (after divorce) is immoral. Part of my disagreement is that I see B and C as related while you (and most of America) see A and B related. Alas, it seems like there is no way to convince the country of my viewpoint so I am stuck putting up with it.