4 ms·
When people say life has generally gotten better in the last several decades, this is the kind of thing I think of. Gotten better for who? Not the Orangutans.
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
When people say life has generally gotten better in the last several decades, this is the kind of thing I think of. Gotten better for who? Not the Orangutans.
- paulcole 9y agoGiven the choice between a better life for myself or Orangutans, I'm picking myself every time.
- Balero 9y agoI agree to an extent. I think I would happily trade my second Lambo or private jet for them, probably even a couple of cups of coffee a week. I don't blame anyone to choosing to send their kids to school or fix their roof though.
- hackeraccount 9y agoWho exactly is making the choice about palm oil? The dude who owns the plantation? The guy who works on it? The guy running the company buying the palm oil to make Nuetella? The person buying the Nuetella? Someone is deciding it's better to have palm oil then orangutans. It's hard to value something that you'll only ever see on a screen or in a zoo. How can you even say you'll miss it? Compare that to your second lambo. Even if you never drive it you see it in driveway every day.
- nimrod0 9y agoNo one person is making the choice, that's the problem. The decision is distributed over many people and each step is only a tiny bit "rapacious" on average (meaning some steps may even be conserving), but over all, the collective decision is to kill 100k orangutans for tastier Nütella. Secondly, it's not about difficulty in valuing something that's hard to see; our markets do plenty of that and are very good at it. It's that there is no value placed on orangutans. Even if you get to see one every day, that may affect your personal decisions but it has no effect collectively because orangutans, like anything else that exists freely in nature such as unclaimed resources, are priced close to $0 in the markets. Only if someone "owned" all the orangutans, for example, then you can talk about value.
- ComputerGuru 9y agoDon’t be silly, there’s no point in making absolute statements like that. Everything needs to be qualified. If you could become an imaginary micro unit more happier but it would cost 14 orangutans their lives, does it still hold? And for people on the opposite side, if saving one orangutan was guaranteed to cost a human their life - or perhaps their eyesight or a limb - would it still be worth it? We’re not living in a 20s silent film, there are shades of gray in this world.
- paulcole 9y ago>If you could become an imaginary micro unit more happier but it would cost 14 orangutans their lives, does it still hold? And for people on the opposite side, if saving one orangutan was guaranteed to cost a human their life - or perhaps their eyesight or a limb - would it still be worth it? Neither of those situations exist.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoNeither does your false premise. We do not have to choose between the well being of orangutans and the well being of people.
- ajmurmann 9y agoActually it does. I can buy cheaper food because Palm oil and orangutans die. I'd rather pay extra and leave them alone.
- mc32 9y agoIn that vein, it's definitely gotten harder for pathogens. When people talk about life getting better they generally mean human welfare, not wildlife welfare. Never the less, without progress in science and industry, I'm sure wildlife would be even worse off. Imagine if most people still burnt non petroleum resources for cooking and heating.... Trivia: Orang orang = people, orang utan = forest people.
- goatlover 9y agoThere probably wouldn't be 7.4 billion people either. People burnt non petroleum resources in that part of the world for a very long time.
- mc32 9y agoI'll give you that but I think it likely without advances, we'd've exhausted forests with 3bill subsistence level humans.
- pishpash 9y agoSubsistence level humans don't get to 3 billion. They'll get periodically wiped out by idiosyncratic events.
- mc32 9y agoDepends what you mean by subsistence. I meant like the farming we had in America in the 1900s, or Rural Mexico, rural Kenya in the 70s, Russia 1920s. You can sustain a lot of people --but it requires clearcutting, and burning. Lots of inefficiency and waste.
- CalRobert 9y agoWithout progress in science and industry, there wouldn't be 7.4 billion people - those pathogens you refer to, and all that.