4 ms·
Zelle is basically a thin wrapper over ACH transactions. In fact, my understanding is that Zelle is basically just "One-day ACH". I never really considered the
by dragontamer 9y ago
Zelle is basically a thin wrapper over ACH transactions. In fact, my understanding is that Zelle is basically just "One-day ACH". I never really considered the fraud aspects, but clearly a modern payment processor needs to have a proper escrow involved somehow. ACH and Zelle don't look like they'd do the trick.
Dwolla was a good middleman for this sort of thing, but it seems like Dwolla pivoted to different services unfortunately.
Overall, this is why the USA has credit cards. A Credit Card company is the middle-man that you trust to handle these issues.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- loeg 9y agoEven ACH has a clawback mechanism for fraudulent transactions. It's ridiculous Zelle does not provide the same protections.
- dragontamer 9y agoI don't think its "ridiculous". Cash, Wire-transfers and Checks (especially Cashier's Checks) do not really have a reversal mechanism IIRC. Once a Cashier's check goes into someone's account, there's basically no way for it to come out. But the thing is: we all know these details already. When working with Cashier's checks, we know its insanely dangerous and to keep track of those little paper-slips. It seems like the general public doesn't know that about Zelle yet.
- ianburrell 9y agoChecks and cashier's checks can be reversed. It is common scam to send forged cashier's check, have victim deposit, and send some of the money by irreversible wire transfer. When the bank, or account holder, discovers the fraud, it will be reversed and the victim is out the money.
- djrogers 9y agoA forged check yes, but not a valid one. That is not a direct comparison as these stories are not about forged Zelle transfers.
- ianburrell 9y agoZelle has similar protections as ACH. There are different kinds of "fraudulent transactions". It protects against account compromise but not fraudulent sellers. Same difference as between checks and credit cards. Shouldn't use Zelle as the seller because could be from stolen account and reversed.
- donarb 9y agoDwolla sold their consumer business to Current. Unfortunately, Current is geared toward teens and debit cards funded by parents.