3 ms·
I salute your motivation in researching this question, and thanks for sharing. I tried to phrase my original appeal carefully, because I didn't want to entirel
by jerf 9y ago
I salute your motivation in researching this question, and thanks for sharing.
I tried to phrase my original appeal carefully, because I didn't want to entirely discount the possibility that it was all just people chasing bullshit. But there's a lot of things in life that look that way, but the people doing it actually have what they think are good reasons. But, yeah, that doesn't sound good.
It seems to me that from a strictly engineering perspective, once you have a corporation involved that the pressures involved would, or at least should, inevitably turn any putative "blockchain" solution into a centralized database owned and administered by the corporation. To be concrete about it, how would WoW gold be improved by a blockchain? The answer is not only that it would have no additionally-useful features, but that it would take numerous hits.
For $100, I'll share with anyone my clever plan for taking a centralized database for tokens and just calling it a blockchain. Oops, I may have given my game plan away. Well, in the spirit of things, perhaps you should still throw money at me. ("In the interests of customer convenience, we just run the blockchain for them... and our engineers have also optimized blockchains quite a bit, eliminating all the Proof of X problems... And from there we were able to optimize turnaround times and responsiveness in the system... OK, basically, it's just a Cassandra installation... but we forked Cassandra and called it Cassandra - Blockchain Edition.")
- Moodles 9y agoThanks. I actually don't think blockchains are all that interesting a technology, but the hysterical mania around them is interesting from an economic and psychological perspective. When will the bubble burst? I'm serious that I would actually consider working in this field for awhile to understand exactly how insane it is. You're absolutely right that some people are honest-but-confused. In fact, I think particularly with large firms, they're all just shit scared about this newfangled blockchain thing and they all know their competitors are investigating it so they desperately want to get in on it before they're destroyed by it. Unfortunately, I think their manic pivot towards blockchain is a very bad move long-term. It would actually take more bravery on their part not to waste resources investigating it. And again, you are right. It's hilarious to watch them reinvent the wheel. Often, the penny drops that they don't want to really have a bitcoin-like blockchain, so they accidentally reinvent either a Wikipedia or a Github. Github in particular you could (and they do) argue is a chain of blocks of data, so a blockchain. It's like cutting off the hump of a camel and then calling it a next generation horse: it kinda works, but it's not originally designed for that, so why not just use a horse?