4 ms·

> Openstreetmap is better for some things already Such as?

detaro 9y ago
Display flexibility: I can pick a rendering that works best for what I want (e.g. optimized for high contrast or print, prioritizing/de-prioritizing specific types of paths, or public transport). If you consider derived maps, there is even more choice, e.g. I can get a topographic map based on it. Usefulness while on foot. In well-mapped areas, OpenStreetMap has every little footpath between buildings, through parks and forests, ..., with information if it is publicly accessible or not. Google Maps is missing tons of them. Offline functionality. (Google could change this, but I somehow don't see them allowing to download entire countries at once)
- ptrott2017 9y ago
  Another: dynamic updates - in case of emergencies and disasters OSM data has often been updated by volunteers faster than other sources to reflect the on ground situation. For current examples See: https://www.hotosm.org/projects/hot_activates_for_multiple_disasters_hurricane_irma_and_maria_mexico_earthquakes_and https://www.hotosm.org/projects/hot_activates_for_multiple_d... For historic example see: http://blogs.worldbank.org/latinamerica/4-years-looking-back-openstreetmap-response-haiti-earthquake http://blogs.worldbank.org/latinamerica/4-years-looking-back...
bluGill 9y ago
Getting to my house. I got tired of people ending with a "you have arrived" more than a mile from my house so I went to open street maps and fixed it. (the automatically imported data for my street had the street name wrong - I'm guessing google imported the same data instead of actually driving the back road). While I was at it marked a few of the roads as requiring 4 wheel drive (legal roads, but only used by farmers going to the fields along it), thus preventing people from getting directed to a road they can't drive on. I checked the "I consider my work public domain" box, 6 months latter google started giving better directions around my neighborhood. I doubt this is coincidence. However the ability to fix directions to your personal house is something OSM does better than google today.
Doctor_Fegg 9y ago
Anything involving walking or cycling.
bckygldstn 9y ago
Small-scale things like drinking fountains, public toilets, unpaved trails. It's amazing for travelling on foot in new cities.
rmc 9y ago
Do you like trains? Train nerds have made a detailed map ( https://www.openrailwaymap.org/ https://www.openrailwaymap.org/ ) There are a few local specific maps ( Here's one in Welsh https://openstreetmap.cymru/ https://openstreetmap.cymru/ ) Interested in what shops/venues are wheelchair accessible? Wheelmap has you covered https://wheelmap.org/map#/?zoom=14 https://wheelmap.org/map#/?zoom=14 Kurviger is a routing service for motorcyclists. Pick a point, select a direction, and a distance, and it'll generate a round trip that doesn't go on the same road twice, you can go direct, or sorta curvy, or very curvy roads. https://kurviger.de/en https://kurviger.de/en
- wst_ 9y ago
  You mean few small (relatively) communities did this for themselves, because it was obvious no one will think about them and in most cases ordinary user doesn't care much about their input. I am talking about an average map user, globally. If you want global coverage and relying on people to input data, then good luck. I do really like the idea and I wish with all my heart that people would be that generous with their time and effort but we have to face the truth - people don't care, people want a working and complete service. Unless there is some automation in place and free data exchange OSM will never be first choice for general public. Idea is beautiful, execution... Well, Tokyo city, population goes in millions, buildings and addresses not available farther than few blocks away from the train stations. You can see roads but roads in Japan have no meaning. And yes, I could input my house (just 10 minutes from station, blank point on map) but sad truth is, I am unable to input all of them and as you can see - people don't care. They just use Google Maps.
  - fludlight 9y ago
    > roads in Japan have no meaning. I've never been to Japan. Can you elaborate?
    - rmc 9y ago
      I suspect they're referring to the Japanese addressing schem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_addressing_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_addressing_system

Display flexibility: I can pick a rendering that works best for what I want (e.g. optimized for high contrast or print, prioritizing/de-prioritizing specific types of paths, or public transport). If you consider derived maps, there is even more choice, e.g. I can get a topographic map based on it. Usefulness while on foot. In well-mapped areas, OpenStreetMap has every little footpath between buildings, through parks and forests, ..., with information if it is publicly accessible or not. Google Maps is missing tons of them. Offline functionality. (Google could change this, but I somehow don't see them allowing to download entire countries at once)

ptrott2017 9y ago
Another: dynamic updates - in case of emergencies and disasters OSM data has often been updated by volunteers faster than other sources to reflect the on ground situation. For current examples See: https://www.hotosm.org/projects/hot_activates_for_multiple_disasters_hurricane_irma_and_maria_mexico_earthquakes_and https://www.hotosm.org/projects/hot_activates_for_multiple_d... For historic example see: http://blogs.worldbank.org/latinamerica/4-years-looking-back-openstreetmap-response-haiti-earthquake http://blogs.worldbank.org/latinamerica/4-years-looking-back...

bluGill 9y ago

Getting to my house. I got tired of people ending with a "you have arrived" more than a mile from my house so I went to open street maps and fixed it. (the automatically imported data for my street had the street name wrong - I'm guessing google imported the same data instead of actually driving the back road). While I was at it marked a few of the roads as requiring 4 wheel drive (legal roads, but only used by farmers going to the fields along it), thus preventing people from getting directed to a road they can't drive on. I checked the "I consider my work public domain" box, 6 months latter google started giving better directions around my neighborhood. I doubt this is coincidence. However the ability to fix directions to your personal house is something OSM does better than google today.

Doctor_Fegg 9y ago

Anything involving walking or cycling.

bckygldstn 9y ago

Small-scale things like drinking fountains, public toilets, unpaved trails. It's amazing for travelling on foot in new cities.

rmc 9y ago

Do you like trains? Train nerds have made a detailed map ( https://www.openrailwaymap.org/ https://www.openrailwaymap.org/ ) There are a few local specific maps ( Here's one in Welsh https://openstreetmap.cymru/ https://openstreetmap.cymru/ ) Interested in what shops/venues are wheelchair accessible? Wheelmap has you covered https://wheelmap.org/map#/?zoom=14 https://wheelmap.org/map#/?zoom=14 Kurviger is a routing service for motorcyclists. Pick a point, select a direction, and a distance, and it'll generate a round trip that doesn't go on the same road twice, you can go direct, or sorta curvy, or very curvy roads. https://kurviger.de/en https://kurviger.de/en

wst_ 9y ago
You mean few small (relatively) communities did this for themselves, because it was obvious no one will think about them and in most cases ordinary user doesn't care much about their input. I am talking about an average map user, globally. If you want global coverage and relying on people to input data, then good luck. I do really like the idea and I wish with all my heart that people would be that generous with their time and effort but we have to face the truth - people don't care, people want a working and complete service. Unless there is some automation in place and free data exchange OSM will never be first choice for general public. Idea is beautiful, execution... Well, Tokyo city, population goes in millions, buildings and addresses not available farther than few blocks away from the train stations. You can see roads but roads in Japan have no meaning. And yes, I could input my house (just 10 minutes from station, blank point on map) but sad truth is, I am unable to input all of them and as you can see - people don't care. They just use Google Maps.
- fludlight 9y ago
  > roads in Japan have no meaning. I've never been to Japan. Can you elaborate?
  - rmc 9y ago
    I suspect they're referring to the Japanese addressing schem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_addressing_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_addressing_system