3 ms·
He's not wrong. OSM is too complex for the majority of businesses. I know two that chose to pay Google for their mapping needs rather than jump through OSM's
by reaperducer 9y ago
He's not wrong.
OSM is too complex for the majority of businesses. I know two that chose to pay Google for their mapping needs rather than jump through OSM's hoops.
Imagine if the only way to get Linux on your computer was to download and compile the whole thing from source yourself, instead of buying or downloading a distro.
If OSM had a mapping solution like Google's, it would thrive. And just for fun, it should undercut Google's pricing.
- spectre256 9y agoIn that sense, perhaps the linux distro model actually makes more sense than centralizing power into one entity? Ubuntu, Redhat, and many others produce their own polished, supported products, sell it, and then give back to the central parts of the community in the process. Mapbox and others certainly seem like they essentially play the part of "OSM Distro" in that regard. And maybe its okay for multiple entities to be able to contribute in different ways.
- Doctor_Fegg 9y ago> If OSM had a mapping solution like Google's, it would thrive. It does, it’s called Mapbox. Plus a number of excellent smaller providers - Thunderforest, Geofabrik, Graphhopper etc.
- beering 9y agoAnd kind of like Linux, you have a patchwork of unsatisfying solutions. Mapbox isn't always cheaper than Google. They have not lowered their tile prices in years, for example. And on geocoding and some other APIs they give out poor results compared to Google. Do they have competition? Cloudmade went in some car-related direction. Mapzen never managed to have a real business plan. And your "excellent small providers"? Yeah, Andy may be able to create some bespoke solution for you if he has time, and Geofabrik can wrangle some host-it-yourself setup onto AWS, but it's still very true that OSM themselves don't have a good story on a lot of mapping needs. You can either browse their web map with unusable search or download the 38GB database, and that's about it. No wonder many businesses just pay Google rather than dive into the rabbit hole of OSM.