3 ms·
> So it's just some late 19th century hipsters… That's a pretty caustic way of putting it. English pronunciation is known to be a mess, and applying "inapplica
by klodolph 9y ago
> So it's just some late 19th century hipsters…
That's a pretty caustic way of putting it. English pronunciation is known to be a mess, and applying "inapplicable" phonetic or morphological rules to words is just the way it works everywhere.
Think about it this way: we have a limited budget for language complexity. It's too much to learn and remember that certain words conjugate according to certain rules of the word's original language, so instead we say "singular -us becomes plural -i". And then people judge each other poorly for getting it wrong.
> Given that about 50% of english vocabulary comes from french I guess these people should start using french grammar everywhere to be consistent.
Honestly I don't follow this argument. English already has irregular nouns, learning a few new ones or switching around the plural forms is not unusual.
- simias 9y agoI completely agree with your point but in this case it's not a simplification, it's yet an other exception. I can understand exceptions or odd pronunciations disappearing but that's the other way around. Normally words in english which have "ce" in them are not pronounced "ke". Similarly words whose singular ends with "~us" do not usually become "~i" in the plural. You don't say "one bus, two bi", "one fetus, two feti". Cherry-picking a few words that for some reason should follow latin grammar is more motivated by sounding "smart" than linguistic necessity IMO.
- klodolph 9y agoI can't help but feel that the "bus-bi" example is disingenuous. Surely you don't think I'm that stupid? Memorizing which words take Latin plurals and which ones don't is work that not everyone has done. So we guess that "virus" is a second-declension Latin noun, which is correct, but now we have to also remember that it's a mass noun and therefore doesn't take a plural in Latin, but since it's not a mass noun in English it has to take a plural anyway, and therefore we get "viruses". And when people get this wrong you can judge them poorly and accuse them of trying to sound smart.