>Gundersen says the culture needs to change. "It's not about shaming," he says. "It's just about being honest." I think that it should be about shaming. If you

>Gundersen says the culture needs to change. "It's not about shaming," he says. "It's just about being honest." I think that it should be about shaming. If you shame those that don't provide enough information to replicate you might create an incentive to publish properly. Replication problems create so much noise for further research that I would classify a researcher who doesn't publish replicable results as hostile to the research community.