5 ms·
> In fact HN is a lot nicer than a number of verified name forums. HN is relatively niche, it's not mainstream. Even if a troll posts e.g. sexist or Nazi crap
by mschuster91 9y ago
> In fact HN is a lot nicer than a number of verified name forums.
HN is relatively niche, it's not mainstream. Even if a troll posts e.g. sexist or Nazi crap here, it will get no attention due to a lack of fellow Nazis to upvote and engage like on Twitter/FB/Reddit, and in addition both the userbase and the mods are quick in removing trolling, thus further reducing the "profit" that a troll can have from trolling.
Also, HN lacks notifications. No matter if upvotes, downvotes, replys, flags - you have to look yourself in your own thread history. This prevents the rapid heating up of discussions - and the lack of a character limit allows users to properly express what they're thinking, unlike Twitter, thus preventing misunderstandings.
Of course there is karma whoring, I won't deny that - but there's no way you get thousands of karma points/likes/rts/claps/whatever for a simple Fuck Trump/Fuck Clinton. For gobbling up karma on HN one has to write either high quality content or be the lucky one who first submits a link to a SpaceX success or a critical security issue.
edit: Oh, there is one other thing which explains "nicer" for me. HN definitely leans towards the leftie-libertarian side. Usually, hate speech, offensive insults, derogatory vocabulary, discrimination, pointless trolling and other aspects associated with "unpleasant environments" are found on the right-wing/authoritarian/alt-right/gamergate/masculist spectrum.
- newfoundglory 9y agoPerhaps we have different definitions of sexist - I think that HN is generally quite supportive of the “free-thinker” type of sexism and racism exemplified by James Damore.
- sincerely 9y agoI've found HN much less supportive of that mindset than, say, reddit.
- leadingthenet 9y agoI am genuinely curious what you mean by this. Why do you view James Damore-types as sexist and/or racist?
- dang 9y agoUgh. Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and don't take HN threads into off-topic flamewar hell. If you haven't had enough Damore flamewars, the search box at the bottom of this page will give you enough to last the rest of your life.
- leadingthenet 9y agoRight, so instead of poiting me to a discussion or an opinion piece, you linked me to the HN guidelines. How nice of you.
- newfoundglory 9y agoYou can lead a seal to the search box, but you can’t make them type in it.
- drharby 9y agoedit: Oh, there is one other thing which explains "nicer" for me. HN definitely leans towards the leftie-libertarian side. Usually, hate speech, offensive insults, derogatory vocabulary, discrimination, pointless trolling and other aspects associated with "unpleasant environments" are found on the right-wing/authoritarian/alt-right/gamergate/masculist spectrum. Reducing credibility of right minded folks by categorizing them all as authoritarian You can be right wing And an upstanding citizen