7 ms·
About 25 years ago in California, Orange Country went bankrupt and public employees had to do "give backs" of (if I remember correctly) about 1/2 of their retir
by mark_l_watson 16y ago
About 25 years ago in California, Orange Country went bankrupt and public employees had to do "give backs" of (if I remember correctly) about 1/2 of their retirement funds and other concessions.
I think that this will be the model for the future, but a state levels.
It may not seem fair to change the rules on public employees, but effectively the rules have changed for private employees because the economy at federal, state, local, and personal levels will keep getting worse.
When I was younger, I worked with techs working for the federal government and they received much lower salary, but a retirement. Now, they tend to make equivalent salaries and have more job security. I am as disgusted with unions lobbying Congress as I am with corporate lobbyists.
- pragmatic 16y agoThat was before federal workers earned twice as much as their private counterparts. "Federal civil servants earned average pay and benefits of $123,049 in 2009 while private workers made $61,051 in total compensation, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. The data are the latest available." http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/federal-workers-earning-double-private-counterparts/story?id=11394757 http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/federal-workers-earning-doubl...
- CWuestefeld 16y agoI'm sympathetic to your point, but you can't really make this comparison, because it's apples-to-oranges. The set of jobs in each set is quite different. For example, there are few farmers in the government employ. However, we can still reach interesting conclusions from the data. For example, I would expect that regardless of the salary of the job, benefits such as healthcare insurance would be fairly constant for employees anywhere, and that in the private sector, healthcare is probably the single largest chunk of benefits. With this observation, we'd have to conclude that whatever salary you're making, the government is throwing in a pretty significant amount of extra value into their employee's benefits, whatever that employee's job might be.
- ryanwaggoner 16y agoFor example, there are few farmers in the government employ. If only. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_subsidy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_subsidy
- _delirium 16y agoThe low-paid immigrant farm workers effectively being paid by the government via subsidies count as "private-sector" employees for statistical purposes, though.
- dpifke 16y agoEven when broken down by industry group and job type (apples-to-apples), public-sector employees make significantly more than their private-sector counterparts, see this Department of Labor press release: http://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/ecec.pdf http://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/ecec.pdf (On page 3 is a comparison of % spent on different benefits for public- vs. private-sector; not sure what conclusions can be drawn from it.)
- richieb 16y agoReally it is the private sector employees that make much less than public employees. Except of course the CEOs and other way over paid executives.....
- nkassis 16y agoThis varies very much depending on the state or department you work in. I work for the Government in Florida and the average IT pay was much lower than comparable jobs in the private sector. In IT I saw differences of about 20K in pay. I was looking at the salary scales and comparing them to the average for things like DBA/Sys Admin/Programmer.
- Anechoic 16y agoPage 4: "Compensation cost levels in State and local government should not be directly compared with levels in private industry. Differences between these sectors stem from factors such as variation in work activities and occupational structures. Manufacturing and sales, for example, make up a large part of private industry work activities but are rare in State and local government. Professional and administrative support occupations (including teachers) account for two-thirds of the State and local government workforce, compared with one-half of private industry."
- jordanb 16y agoIt's worth observing that: 1) Orange County went bankrupt by cooking the books. After the scandal broke, their treasurer went to jail. 2) The Republican administration turned a blind eye to the Democratic treasurer's malfeasance because it was allowing them to keep taxes very low, which was making their government very popular. 3) The government refused to raise even a temporary tax to avoid bankruptcy, as that position was highly unpopular among the wealthy residents of the county. At various points the county insisted that it should receive bailouts from the California state and federal government, which drew anger from across the nation as Orange County is among the wealthiest places in the nation. 4) In bankruptcy, Orange County cut $200 million from its budget by clawing back commitments to its low level employees who had no part in the high level corruption, as well as through layoffs and reduced services. The OC bankruptcy, from the perspective of the average person, is like a minified version of the bank bailouts. It was a "heads I win, tails you lose" bargain between the wealthy people of OC and the average people who were hurt most by the layoffs and reduced services.
- yummyfajitas 16y ago...low level employees who had no part in the high level corruption,... The low level employees didn't vote for and join unions which helped that Dem treasurer to get elected? They didn't push for overly generous pensions and non-transparent accounting? They must have behaved very differently than contemporary unions.
- jbooth 16y agoGive me a break. Those low level employees do a job under a contract which was supposedly negotiated in good faith. Now because you don't like "unions" or "government" it's ok to stiff people who perform a public service for a previously agreed upon wage and benefits? What, because highway workers weren't doing financial due diligence on the multi-hundred-million dollar county's books? It was their responsibility to do this? I thought that was the responsibility of the guy who got thrown in jail for cooking the books. This is what that professor was talking about when he was apologizing. Everybody wants to cut taxes and make public servants work for free, whether it's out of simple selfishness or a more highly evolved ideology (aka fancy selfishness).
- _delirium 16y ago> It may not seem fair to change the rules on public employees, but effectively the rules have changed for private employees It's possible this has happened some places, but not at any major companies I know about. Companies that have phased out defined-benefit pensions have generally not done so retroactively, but only closed them to new hires. Phasing them out retroactively would be a breach of contract, since the employee performed work for you under the expectation that you'd honor the employment contract they signed, including the pension terms. Pension is a kind of remuneration, so you can't decide not to pay it after receiving the work. Much easier legally to simply stop making those pension promises to new employees, but not breach the ones you already made.
- learner4life 16y agoActually, IBM did retroactively change the pension eligibility criteria as well as the payoff during its restructuring under Lou Gerstner(This is the late 90s). There is still a pending lawsuit if I remember correctly. It makes no sense to me as to why it is OK to underfund pension accounts. One major reason IBM was able to make the change is because it had no unions(FWIW I am no fan of unions as they encourage sloth in organisations).
- camiller 16y agoAlso some of the old phone company (AT&T prior to the 1974 breakup) employees had their retirement benefits whittled away over the years, my father-in-law included. Additionally most private sector employees are not under any sort of contract. I didn't sign a contract at any of the three corporations I've ever worked for (over the past 22 years). Fortunately my retirement was all 401k and as I changed jobs I rolled those into a rollover IRA under my control so I don't have to worry about under-funded pensions, I only have to worry about how bad I suck at picking stocks.
- _delirium 16y agoInteresting re: the contracts. I don't think I've worked any job, even relatively minor summer jobs, without signing a contract of some sort. It usually covers both obligations to me (salary, termination conditions, benefits, etc.) as well as my obligations to the company (intellectual property ownership, non-solicitation if I leave to start a competitor, etc.).
- kenjackson 16y agoI knows probably more than 100 private tech employees that regularly make more than $1M/year (salary plus stock/bonus). I don't know any federal tech employees that make more than $150k/year. Either you only know private tech code monkeys or have found the highest paying federal agency that no one has ever heard of.
- illumin8 16y agoYes, but those private employees making more than $1M are probably some of the best talent in the industry, where as the federal employees could have any range of talent from "breathes, and has a pulse" to "rockstar developer." Also, the private employees when they retire get no health benefits and have to fund their own retirement from a 401k, whereas the federal employees have guaranteed health care for life and a guaranteed pension. The health care and pension alone are worth at least a few million if you live to a decent age.
- _delirium 16y agoI don't think that assumption is usually true. Knowing a lot of people in finance, it doesn't seem hard to me to conclude that the employees making over $1M can have any range of talent from "breathes, and has a pulse" to "rockstar finance guru". To the extent talent is required, it's often bureaucratic ladder-climbing talent.
- kenjackson 16y agoYou're right on most counts. But this is the tradeoff. Private: Can make it rich. Really rich, And on average probably make more money while working, assuming the same type of work. OTOH, if you don't make it rich your retirement may not be as nice as you'd like. Public: Will never be rich. You can solve P=NP, factor large numbers in constant time, and create a revolutionary new UI that every loves, and you'll still get paid as a GS-13, but you'll get a level bump next time your promotion comes up. But when you retire, you'll be comfortable. It's kind of like the same deal judges get. Almost all federal judges would make a boatload more money as attorneys. But they take the lower pay with job security, salary for life, and a different kind of prestige.
- irons 16y agoYou're right: voiding other people's contracts because they (collectively) negotiated better deals than you did doesn't seem fair at all. Arnold knows exactly how to push your buttons.
- anamax 16y ago> You're right: voiding other people's contracts because they (collectively) negotiated better deals than you did doesn't seem fair at all. You're forgetting that govt is a monopoly. GM can promise anything it wants to its retirees, but if its customers decide to buy Toyota, GM won't honor those promises (unless the govt bails them out). If San Jose makes promises, folks who had nothing to do with those promises are forced to make good. That's why public employees and public works projects (SJ Arena, light rail, pro-sports facilities) should be on a pay-as-you go or collateral basis. That way, the stadium failure won't be a burden on future tax payers. If you think that such things are a great idea, buy the bonds. If you're correct, great. If you're wrong, you get to foreclose.