4 ms·
His influence on robotics has been mostly negative, although the mechanism has been mostly journalistic stupidity. The "three laws" could never be implemented i
by ncmncm 9y ago
His influence on robotics has been mostly negative, although the mechanism has been mostly journalistic stupidity. The "three laws" could never be implemented in hardware, they were just rules about how to make stories. "Suppose robots followed these. What would happen?" His answer was that they would quietly take over the world and keep us as pets. Because nothing like them could be implemented, there was no predictive value.
The actual outcome, without laws and with corporations standing in for the robots, is that we are livestock and vermin, according to individual usefulness and accidents of birth.
- madengr 9y agoWhy couldn't they be implemented in hardware? Through the whole Robot series he describes them as "potentials" summing to force a decision, and even the self-conceived 0th law takes precedence, though not for G.R. It's obvious the positronic brain isn't based on logic, rather an analog brain with trillions of "pathways" that can be "frozen" and never re-started (as you would a program). There isn't even a concept of finite data storage. D.O. doesn't know how long it will take to fill up his brain, though he records everything and can't forget it. SPOILER: Though in the end of the Foundation series, we have some clues.
- mrob 9y agoThe laws don't have any objective interpretation. What exactly is "harm" from a mathematical point of view? This is good for storytelling, because it let Asimov write stories about robots behaving in strange ways, and the protagonists struggling to figure out how it made sense as a possible interpretation of the laws, but it's no good for actually building robots.
- krapp 9y agoYes, people who take Asimov's laws seriously seem to forget that they didn't even work in-universe, which was kind of the point.
- the_af 9y ago> His answer was that they would quietly take over the world and keep us as pets That wasn't Asimov's answer, outside a few atypical robots-as-a-menace stories. Even the Zeroth Law cannot be misconstrued as "keeping humans as pets" :)
- osteele 9y agoThe stories were inspirations and conversation-starters for many of the people I know in AI.
- rcxdude 9y agoA few of his stories were explicitly exploring how these three laws were simplifications used to explain the system to a layperson, and exploring the cases where this difference was important.