9 ms·
Kids who grew up in an environment where anonymous interaction is the norm (such as kids who have anonymous social chats at school, or do in-game chats etc) hav
by alkonaut 9y ago
Kids who grew up in an environment where anonymous interaction is the norm (such as kids who have anonymous social chats at school, or do in-game chats etc) have grown so accustomed to it that I don't think they even see it as sexist, racist, bullying etc. Most would probably never say any of this to someones' face, not out of fear of consequences but simply because they know better. Yet in anonymous contact they don't think twice about it.
It also doesn't help that these interactions are ephemeral. Tomorrow you play against someone else, or chat with a different person. What you said yesterday doesn't matter, you may not even be the same persona. So as far as human relatoins go, they know that the chat interaction isn't a human relation, it's a short anonymous interaction.
So I think the important thing for us parents to convey is that being an asshat isn't ok just because you are anonymous. It might help to explain that everthing typed anywhere online is usually recorded forever, and that true anonymity doesn't exist either. That, and of course that real people deserved being treated like real people, even when anonymous.
- jsjohnst 9y agoI think you hit the nail on the head, anonymity can bring out the worst in someone, especially when they feel there is zero repercussions. It’s partly why I hate the throw away accounts here.
- rocqua 9y agoIt's not quite anonymity, its ephemerality. People know that their actions will never come back to them. An anonymous but long-standing account will see less of this than a throw-away account.
- BlackFly 9y agoExactly. There is no serious consequence for their actions. If it was more common to be permanently banned for such language, people would probably think twice. You are pretty anonymous if you walk into a bar and don't tell anyone your name. (Depending on the bar) They will kick you out and put your picture on the wall if you start talking aggressively to the civil regulars. More than that there is the immediate risk of a fist to the face. Just like bar owners ask themselves what kind of patronage they want, online operators should ask themselves the same question.
- eitland 9y agoDisagree strongly. And HN is proof that this isn't (entirely) true. In fact HN is a lot nicer than a number of verified name forums.
- Belphemur 9y agoWe need also to compare the user base ... The user's age on HN is in the ballpark of 25-40 years old, as it's a tech website. The website in OP is a meme generator, and I'm sure the ballpack would be 12-18 years. Now considering this, I agree with alkonaut.
- eitland 9y ago> The user's age on HN is in the ballpark of 25-40 years old, as it's a tech website. Exactly the target audience when we are discussing <topic> in tech, isn't it? Edit: I misread / didn't read. My broader point is there is a lot of talk about how bad tech is, and yet here we are on a very technical and at the same time reasonably civil forum.
- optimuspaul 9y ago> The user's age on HN is in the ballpark of 25-40 years old, as it's a tech website. Oh no, I'm aging out, I'm 41. I'm curious why you put 40 as the top end there. If I were going to guess at an age range for this site I go lower and much higher.
- lagadu 9y agoWoah there granddad, how did you get on the computer ;) I imagine he meant in the normal distribution sense, where 25-40 comprises ~70% of the userbase; entirely anecdotal but I get the feeling that's a reasonable assessment.
- soundwave106 9y agoTo some degree I think it's more the nature of Internet style communication (text / typing oriented with no face to face interaction) in itself. Facebook after all is not anonymous and is not 100% free of this sort of thing. Honestly, though, there are some corners of real life (especially in those early teen years as you allude to, but even among full grown adults that should know better) where you will find people with this sort of personality. These type of reactions are not surprising in that context. Social media does seem to do something to amplify raw vulgarity and classless behavior though.
- Slansitartop 9y ago> I think you hit the nail on the head, anonymity can bring out the worst in someone, especially when they feel there is zero repercussions. It’s partly why I hate the throw away accounts here. It's a tradeoff. There are both good and bad things with anonymity and real name policies: 1. Anonymity: people can express themselves without anxiety, but that gives space to assholes to be assholes (barring other control mechanisms). 2. Real names: lots of people will hold back due to anxiety that what they say may come back to haunt them years later [1]. The more timid assholes will inhibit themselves as well, but not all assholes are timid. The main people who will participate (asshole and non-asshole) will have the personality types that DGAF. In short: anonymity is somewhat more favorable to assholes, but also more favorable to good discussion. I also prefer it, because I'm the kind of person who will just shut up in a deanonymized space. [1] In ways they may have never even imagined at the time.
- jsjohnst 9y agoPlease reread what I posted. I didn't mention/propose/condone "real name" policies. Folks using "handles" are perfectly fine, but I am tired of seeing more and more brand new users with the name "throwaway####" making comments with little to no value.
- nukeop 9y ago>and that true anonymity doesn't exist either Yes it does, you are mistaken. An IP does not identify you if it's a proxy server or a VPN or a Tor node. All existing tracking methods can be fooled.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoOnly for as long as nobody really cares. OPSEC is hard. Even people for whom it's a matter of life and death fail at it routinely. Angry trolls even more so. Your first message may be anonymous, but by your third message there's a good chance someone dedicated could find you if they cared enough.
- nukeop 9y agoAnd how exactly?
- talaketu 9y agotransference
- mnx 9y agoVPN providers keep logs even when they say they don't, your browser transmits an often unique fingerprint, vulnerabilities allow disclosing real ip, and so on. Even darknet market operators with all the reasons for trying to be anonymous and paranoid get outed. It's just a matter of how much resources it takes.
- notyourday 9y agoIt used to be said that a drunk person would tell you exactly what he or she thinks about you or about any topic. Internet anonymity ( or semi-anonymity ) does not affect the character. It exposes the character.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoThis is exactly right.
- coryfklein 9y agoI don't think that changing the environment inherently reveals someone's "true" character. You're just revealing how they behave in that environment. We are just too complex to be reduced to such a simple experiment as "anonymity" to discover our true nature.
- HedgeSparrow 9y agoA facet of their character, expressed in a specific environment, is still a part of their character. Your behavior, wherever you are, is who you are.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoThe added wrinkle to this is that the internet hides age.... So if you go to The_Donald, a bunch of the views expressed are just teenagers being awful (or normal teenagers basically), but the adults who line up with their views don't realize they how many of their peers are children. It can definitely normalize that viewpoint and spread into the wider adult conversations. I also have noticed a few times on Reddit when someone says something insanely terrible, I will check their history to see if they are a White Nationalist or what else they are interested in, and dozens of times every post in their history is about video games. And the only time the venture out of the video game bubble it is with bizarrely hateful political commentary. Maybe its an anomaly and if I clicked all the good posters history's they would be about video games too.... but it's starting to feel like there may be a genuine and unique culture developing around gaming that is distinctly racist, homophobic and celebrates almost any form of cruelty. And I say that as someone who is in their 30's and still LOVES video games.
- kohanz 9y agoI partly agree, but it's also a bit of a cop out, to be honest. Anyone who has been in such an anonymous chat environment (game or otherwise) and has dished out such abuse has undoubtedly received it too and know how it feels. They do it because it illicits a reaction on the other end and they too have felt that reaction and decided they would rather be on the other end of it.
- Hello71 9y agoelicit
- moomin 9y agoThey eliminated anonymity in large chunks of South Korea’s social media. People didn’t behave better. (With that said, there are certain behaviours e.g. support for fascism that seem to be associated with having large numbers of anon accounts.)
- pshc 9y agoSource?
- kalleboo 9y agoI also see some pretty terrible behavior in Facebook comments on news sites/blogs right next to people's names, employer and a photo of them with their kid.
- coryfklein 9y agoYea, this is pretty useless information unless you can provide a source for these claims. I find it very hard to believe that the complete elimination of anonymity on a social media platform resulted in exactly 0 improvement in measurable behavior. I Googled both your anonymity and your fascism claims and couldn't find anything, but I'd love to learn more.
- gspetr 9y agohttps://splinternews.com/black-twitter-has-a-flawless-clap-back-for-trolls-posin-1793864290 https://splinternews.com/black-twitter-has-a-flawless-clap-b... The closest thing my google-fu got me.
- staticelf 9y agoWhen I play online games, in this example PUBG, I think a part of the fun is to be rude and aggressive before the match starts. You're about to virtually shoot them in the head so saying something rude to random online gamers doesn't feel at all bad. Other people often respond back, just as rudely and I think it's hilarious. It can't be just me who thinks and acts like this? Context matters a lot in my opinion. Although, I am never rude to someone IRL or even on a more serious note outside of online gaming. It's nice to vent and I don't think other players in PUBG care at all.
- alkonaut 9y agoI think its a delicate balance of one wants to be cocky and trashtalk before a game in a fun way, and vs being an obnoxious troll. I see quite a lot of the latter, but I try to play on well moderated servers and servers with votebans.
- staticelf 9y agoSure, but almost all games have the possibility to turn off voice chat for example so you can stop people from simply screaming in the microphone.
- alkonaut 9y agoI'd never accept anyone being even mildly trashtalking or rude in voice. Being mildly trashtalking in chat is fine. I wouldnt' even switch someone off, I'd voteban immediately (and if the game/community/server is ok more people would). In the game I play when someone joins who is annoying they are generally called out as "whoa did you just arrive from CoD?"...
- adbachman 9y agoIf part of the fun for you is acting like a jerk to other people online, then it means you enjoy acting like a jerk to other people. Context is interesting, but it just means that overall, you’re only sometimes acting like a jerk. You might just be a jerk.
- username223 9y ago> Kids who grew up in an environment where anonymous interaction is the norm... I generally agree that the kids should get off my lawn, but the G.I.F.T. meme was created in 2004, and Usenet was a rough neighborhood even back before most posters here were born: http://www.faqs.org/faqs/net-abuse-faq/troll-faq/ http://www.faqs.org/faqs/net-abuse-faq/troll-faq/ Actually, the a.s.t trolls were probably more vicious and effective than today's variety. That's just how people are.
- sincerely 9y agoI think it may be relevant that more and more people are growing up with easy access to computers and pseudoanonymous social networks today, even if the trolls of yesteryear were crueler.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoYou're being way too light on these people. This is how they'd act if allowed IRL. The anonymity just gives them more protection than they'd enjoy IRL. These are, at best, sick people, who need need.
- dpark 9y agoThey aren’t “sick people”. They’re just assholes. This behavior does not indicate a mental illness. It’s just generic asshole behavior.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoI said, at best.
- curiousgeorgio 9y agoAgreed. This problem is closer to "online graffiti" (every text box is the canvas) than sexism, racism, etc. The assumption that a bot may be on the receiving end further encourages the behavior. These kids know better, though I do think a healthy "fear of consequences" or reality check can help. I'd expect the rate of abuse to decline fairly significantly with the simple addition of the text "This conversation is being monitored by a supervisor", appearing a few moments after the first message is sent.
- alkonaut 9y agoThat isn't my point - I wasn't trying to be dismissive. My point is that anonymity amplifies and reveals genuine beliefs.
- hodl 9y agoIt isn't necessarily young people making those rude comments.
- muse900 9y agoAs a kid I grew up playing video games. Around the age of 13 I switched on to online video games. I spent too much time on games like w3/wow etc. As a kid being exposed to such an environment wasn't good at all. After years, now being in my 30's I can totally understand how online gaming changed me and my interactions vs people that haven't played online games etc are completely different. I used to have a complete disregard about anything in life, I wouldn't mind saying to someone 'get cancer', which is quite awful. Only now that I grew up and reduced my online presence by a lot, also understood that life is life and games are games, I understand how awful of a thing is to wish cancer to someone or even joke about that. People losing families and friends over that thing and I used to just have it as a word. I can't blame it on my parents either. They tried their best and they gave me everything they could. If it wasn't for them I would be a total loss I guess. Its just that they couldn't stop me from playing videogames or convert my life into videogames. That thing was like a junk during my teens. That said online games definitely helped me mature as well, I mean its not all bad, I definitely got some good values out of interacting in online video games, and some bad. Just wanted to bring my personal experience on the matter and what you commented.
- Consultant32452 9y agoI think a plurality of kids in middle and high school go through this phase whether they play video games or not. It's a normal part of growing up. You've got lots of new hormones and frustrations in life. It's a time of testing all sorts of social boundaries. I wonder to what extent gaming increases this phenomenon from the norm, or whether it's just a different avenue through which these things are expressed.
- Bartweiss 9y agoI have a rather vivid memory from age 15 of someone tossing off a "your mom" joke to someone whose mother had just died. It was, obviously, a terrible moment. And it was far from the only thing of that sort that happened. I remember really upsetting people on a couple of occasions because I thought about the likely, harmless consequence of what I was saying, and didn't consider whether it could cut some people much deeper. None of us were taught to do this by gaming online. Honestly, I'm doubtful that gaming teaches cruelty any more than team sports or school cafeterias do. I get that it's depersonalizing and people say cruel things, but it feels like a boogeyman given how much actual violence gets ignored at that age.
- matt4077 9y agoIt’s sad to see that the top-voted comment is one of those bemoaning general uncivilized behavior, when the story convincingly shows that we’ve created a world where women’s lives are made impossibly difficult, and men are treated with respect.
- alkonaut 9y agoThat wasn’t my intention, I think most of the asshattery I refer to definitely end up as sexism, and is directed towards women. And I have no idea why that is so. But it’s a problem, most definitely. My point is merely that anonymity simply magnifies the same things we would see in non-anonymous settings.
- Jean-Philipe 9y agoThe female identity has been harassed while the male identity was treated with respect. I don't see how anonymity has anything to do with it, the visitors were equally anonymous in both cases.
- alkonaut 9y agoI was more trying to make a general remark around e.g what kids do in social media when anonymous. The reason only the female is harassed I think has a very simple explanation, only men behave this way. Why the same men don’t behave e.g racist or otherwise harassing the male identity can’t say. Best guess there is that these men are simply threatened by women, especially those that are attractive or successful. But I’m way out of my comfort zone of even man-guessing now. I didn’t intend to detract from the fact that these men are assholes or say sexism isn’t the issue here.
- eevilspock 9y agoI was as amazed as Jakob[1] how much the overwhelming HN response to this story is self-serving defensiveness and rationalization, and very little acknowledgement. But I took solace in the fact that his comment was voted to the top. When I came back 20 minutes later it had dropped to #3. Three hours later it is #4, with the top-two trivializing this as just trolls not misogyny, and the third in support of women but in a way that doesn't offend the HN community's collective ego. The #1 comment, the one I'm replying to, expresses the belief that what someone does anonymously does not reflect their character or their underlying attitudes towards women. It's just an "asshat" "short anonymous interaction". Boys will be boys. This isn't real. Don't read too much into it! Women, a bit too sensitive are we? I looked through the 101 sub-comments to #1, and nearly all trivialize this as issues of "anonymity", "kids", "jokes", "gaming" "trash talk". One even said "It's worth noting that all of this behavior is normal and healthy." He (I think I can safely assume he is a he) also added "Additionally, this is a part of establishing or figuring out your position in the social dominance hierarchy." Yes. Male social dominance. I did find four sub-replies (out of the 101) that focused on what this meant for women[2]. > Most would probably never say any of this to someones' face, not out of fear of consequences but simply because they know better. Yet in anonymous contact they don't think twice about it. What you do when you don't think twice is a reflection of some truth about you (your character, your biases, your raw attitudes, your inner values, your insecurities and inadequacies) or about the culture you are a part of. It's usually both. The comments Julia received are not random insults. They are misogynist. Misogyny doesn't appear out of thin air. > It might help to explain that everthing typed anywhere* online is usually recorded forever, and that true anonymity doesn't exist either.* It might be more helpful to explain that it is deeply oppressive, injurious and misogynist. As with police killings of black men, it is important that all this is recorded forever. Because without records, the oppressed are never believed by those in the same class as the oppressors. But as HN is proving right now, they are still not believed. Many comments claim that Julia's experience is the result of some small number of trolls, not reflective of the vast majority of men, or of male tech culture. The volume of HN comments coming to the defense of men rather than women doesn't do much to bolster the "just trolls" theory. The comments here are a reflection of HN readership, and it is a good thing that this and all the other overwhelmingly dismissive comments on many other similar posts are recorded forever. They are the perfect example of what women have to live with. Trivialization. Dismissal. Ridicule. Sexism. Misogyny. - [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16390796 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16390796 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16394063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16394063 , https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16394187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16394187 , https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16393947 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16393947 (down-voted to gray) and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16392373 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16392373