5 ms·
> The more interesting question is why google is doing this. They got sued. "These changes came about in part due to our settlement with Getty Images this wee
by kalleboo 9y ago
> The more interesting question is why google is doing this.
They got sued.
"These changes came about in part due to our settlement with Getty Images this week."
- ghostcluster 9y agoThe feature is still available on Bing Images, for now: http://www.bing.com/images/ http://www.bing.com/images/
- kalleboo 9y agoLooks like Getty and Microsoft have had an agreement for a couple of years now https://searchengineland.com/microsoft-getty-images-announce-partnership-drop-infringement-lawsuit-over-bing-images-218207 https://searchengineland.com/microsoft-getty-images-announce...
- MikkoFinell 9y agoWhy not just remove the feature for pictures from Getty then, or simply not show their pictures at all? Surely that is within the technical capability of Google.
- owaislone 9y agoBecause then every other company would file similar suite and Google would have to deal with all of them.
- pedrogpimenta 9y agoDo you think every image company would want to be removed from Google Search results instead of building their services without the ability to scrape the big resolution images? How would users get on their websites?
- owaislone 9y agoIt doesn't matter. Once one company wins in court, it sets a precedent. It attracts more companies to follow the same path as they'll think they have a better shot at winning. Google obviously wouldn't risk this.
- josteink 9y agoBut the question is what would they be winning? Fewer users because they are now off the search-grid. Why would they want that?
- murftown 9y ago> what would they be winning? Money from a successful lawsuit?
- Feniks 9y agoBelieve it or not there are people who just enjoy suing corporations or governments. Lawyers are not cheap and frankly Google would lose every case because they are in the wrong.
- cgmg 9y agoWhy are they in the wrong (on this issue)?
- marnett 9y agoIt was a settlement, there is no precedent.
- orbitur 9y agoUsers don't go to the websites at all if the images are scraped by Google.
- joosters 9y agoPresumably because others could now sue Google for the same reasons, and they would be even more likely to win given the Getty result.
- dumbfounder 9y agoThis. Otherwise known as "legal precedent".
- rory096 9y agoSettlements don't establish precedent.
- dumbfounder 9y agoAh, good point, it was a settlement...
- CobrastanJorji 9y agoBecause Getty wasn't suing to stop Google from sharing Getty images in image search. They were suing because they felt coerced into participating in image search. Forcing Getty not to participate would have been even worse for Getty.
- anonytrary 9y agoGoogle should have just delisted Getty images from all of their search.
- patrickaljord 9y agoThen Google would have been sued for monopoly abuse, in Europe at least.
- fny 9y agoEven if it was with Getty's blessing?
- prepend 9y agoI don’t believe that this is the sole motivator. As others have said, they could remove this for Getty images only (based on domain, based on reverse image search, lots of ways). But also, this seems like an absurd judgement, that if true they would want to highlight how the judgement had a very specific design fix as part of the settlement. Since Google isn’t highlighting any such absurd ruling’s specific language then there must be some other reason.
- simonh 9y ago>...there must be some other reason. If Getty can successful sue them, then any image rights holder can do so. Making an exception for Getty images doesn't resolve the underlying general liability or infringement. That means if another rights holder were to sue them for not addressing that liability for their images, now Google are infringing wilfully and subject to punitively increased sanctions or damages. That's reason enough to apply this remedy across the board.
- prepend 9y agoYouTube and many other sites have systems to work with rightsholders. It would be trivial for Google to allow Getty and others to manage their images that show up while still retaining functionality for the billions of images created by people who don’t care or who even explicitly allow Creative Commons usage. Thus my suspicion. What’s a little sad is 15 years ago I would give Google the benefit of the doubt, but this reminds me how times have changed.
- simonh 9y agoYouTube, where a user chooses to upload content and Google defines the platform features and standards, is pretty different to search. ‘Still retaining functionality’ would require assuming permissive access to images as the default, which is what has got a Google into this mess in the first place. The whole point of this is that, for sites and rights holders that don’t explicitly allow access, Google cannot assume they grant it. They have to assume the most restrictive grant of rights, and adoption of metadata to indicate more permissive access is so poorly adopted it’s just irrelevant in practice.