8 ms·
So it’s ok for google to scrape and save images and display them without compensating photographers (which I’m cool with), but not users? This is bizarre, anti
by prepend 9y ago
So it’s ok for google to scrape and save images and display them without compensating photographers (which I’m cool with), but not users? This is bizarre, anti user functionality.
By default if the image is available on the web, it is meant to be seen. This is going to make high school PowerPoint users spend more time, and result in zero extra revenue and zero drop in copyright infringement.
The more interesting question is why google is doing this.
- tyingq 9y ago"The goals of the advertising business model do not always correspond to providing quality search to users." Google for that exact phrase and see who made that observation.
- dingo_bat 9y agoI binged it, and it took me to this zdnet article: http://www.zdnet.com/article/google-advertising-and-search-engine-bias/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/google-advertising-and-search-e... So the author of that observation is Sergey Brin himself. Lel.
- tyingq 9y agoI try not to overuse the reference, but "Anatomy of a Search Engine" [1] is so deliciously prescient and ironic that it's hard to avoid. It's funny how hard Sergey and Larry shifted once personal fortunes changed their motivation. [1] http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html
- blub 9y ago"For example, a search engine could add a small factor to search results from "friendly" companies, and subtract a factor from results from competitors" That's basically what Google got sued for in the EU and they lost. The friendly companies were other Google properties.
- Buge 9y agoThe shopping fine? That wasn't a case of results being secretly promoted like the paper was worried about. The shopping ads were labeled as sponsored.
- dredmorbius 9y agoIt is rather delicious. (Not to be confused with del.icio.us, which is now ... Pinboard.)
- veidr 9y agoThat's the first time I've ever heard somebody use "bing" as a verb, outside of a Microsoft ad. (Assuming that your post isn't a new form of Microsoft ad, that is.)
- lolive 9y agoI definitely look forward to a search engine called bang.com Comments such as "yesterday I banged Scarlett Johansson" would be hilarious. [OK OK, -1 me, I deserve it ;)]
- sundvor 9y agohttps://duckduckgo.com/ https://duckduckgo.com/ also had this link as its #1 result. I much prefer DDG - have converted across all my devices now in the past month and I'm really, really liking it. (Sorry off topic, but it's contextual.) What's that then, I ducked it? :-)
- Brendinooo 9y agoAnecdata: I use Bing regularly. Sometimes I'll say I've binged something, but I have a hard time doing so without a little hint of sarcasm or self-awareness in my voice. It gets weirder when people are using the term "Google-fu" - gotta say "search-fu" if you can't stomach "Bing-fu"; neither option is great. But hey, the rewards points are redeemable for Amazon cards...
- Iv 9y agoUsers are the goods, not the clients, of Google. Remember: if you get a service for free, then you are the merchandise.
- dx034 9y agoThe content of 3rd party websites is the merchandise. Users are users. Just because it's financed by ads doesn't mean they're not interested in your experience. Facebook currently experiences how problematic declining user engagement can be. If Google search quality ever drops below that of others (Bing, Yandex), they'd be in real trouble. Their superior search is the only reason they make all that money. I get that some are dissatisfied by "paying" with ads. But the alternative would be a paid-for search engine. Not only would that potentially exclude some, it would also make it harder to access search for people from low-income countries. Currently, US and Europe subsidise operations for money other areas, allowing them to get the same search experience. That'd change with a paid-for model.
- madshiva 9y agoit's easy to repeat, hard to understand. Next time I give you water for free, are you my merchandise?
- wutbrodo 9y ago> Remember: if you get a service for free, then you are the merchandise. Like Wikipedia, right?
- Sacho 9y agoExactly. The number of wikipedia users is used when soliciting for donations. Donators and wikipedia users probably have some overlap, but that's also true of Google Search users and advertisers..
- wutbrodo 9y agoRight, which shows that the notion that "you're the product" is stretched so far to fit this idiotic platitude that it's more or less meaningless.
- kalleboo 9y ago> The more interesting question is why google is doing this. They got sued. "These changes came about in part due to our settlement with Getty Images this week."
- ghostcluster 9y agoThe feature is still available on Bing Images, for now: http://www.bing.com/images/ http://www.bing.com/images/
- kalleboo 9y agoLooks like Getty and Microsoft have had an agreement for a couple of years now https://searchengineland.com/microsoft-getty-images-announce-partnership-drop-infringement-lawsuit-over-bing-images-218207 https://searchengineland.com/microsoft-getty-images-announce...
- MikkoFinell 9y agoWhy not just remove the feature for pictures from Getty then, or simply not show their pictures at all? Surely that is within the technical capability of Google.
- owaislone 9y agoBecause then every other company would file similar suite and Google would have to deal with all of them.
- pedrogpimenta 9y agoDo you think every image company would want to be removed from Google Search results instead of building their services without the ability to scrape the big resolution images? How would users get on their websites?
- owaislone 9y ago
- bitmapbrother 9y agoIt's right there in the article >Google has long been under fire from photographers and publishers who felt that image search allowed people to steal their pictures, and the removal of the view image button is one of many changes being made in response. A deal to show copyright information and improve attribution of Getty photos was announced last week and included these changes. Using the context menu to "Open Image in New Tab" essentially does the same thing so the functionality is still there.
- ComputerGuru 9y ago> using the context menu to “Open Image in New tab” essentially dos the same thing so the functionality is still there. No, actually “view image” loaded the source image at source resolution while viewing the image loaded into the DOM would show you the re-encoded, lower resolution, smaller Google thumbnail version. Edit: actually it seems that Google has simultaneously deployed an update that makes the actual source image open so that might actually work.
- Zak 9y agoWhat I'm seeing on the current site is that the large preview seen on clicking a thumbnail is the original image, loaded from the original server and scaled in CSS. Nothing's really changed in terms of capability; the UI is just a bit more awkward.
- akvadrako 9y agoThat can't be true - or it would be very taxing to browse a page of 20MP+ images.
- yAnonymous 9y agoJust fucking look for yourself? You could have done that in the time it took you to write that comment.
- 9y ago
- fbdjskajxb 9y agoThe way you find out whether a change like this afffects revenue is by testing it, not speculating.
- bonesss 9y ago> This is going to make high school PowerPoint users spend more time This is going to make Senior Architect PowerPoint users spend more time... When I show my PHB why kubernetes is "the shit" and something we "really need", as I do with all my technical presentations: I get my propaganda directly from the suppliers. Am I gonna spend time visually describing how Oracles product suite hangs together? No, that's the job of someone who works at Oracle. The sites themselves often have lower res versions in their articles, so 'view image' has repeatedly saved my bacon getting high res, clean, versions for reuse. Google Image search historically cut through the noise and got relevant images out in a highly usable format, while saving oooooodles of time digging out the appropriate graphic. Boo!
- prepend 9y agoWhile it would be cool to cut down on such presentations as you describe, I would hope that even PHB style architects can right click, or use the dev console, or pull from cache.
- bonesss 9y agoRight click is blocked, natch, and dev console on google images trying to get sources is nowhere close to being as fast as visiting the source site and right clicking. Pulling from cache is also more time intensive, and therefore irrelevant. Also, I said architect reporting to a PHB, not a PHB architect, and that the time was used creating presentations, not that the volume of presentations themselves could be 'cut down'... -2/3
- petagonoral 9y ago> By default if the image is available on the web, it is meant to be seen Some might argue the image is meant to be seen...in the context of the web page it's on.
- prepend 9y agoHose would argue with the http protocol and standard then. Some would argue that speech in public between two people should not be overheard. But so what, the fact that some argue has limited value without lots of qualifiers.
- prepend 9y agoc/Hose/Some
- petagonoral 9y ago> Hose would argue with the http protocol and standard then. Which part of any version of the http protocol spec covers this?
- jug 9y agoYes, I don't see the problem either. Paywalled photos as from news agencies are already published in severely reduced resolution and often with huge watermarks plastered over the entire photo, if they are even on the public web! If you're publishing paywalled photos in public, high resolution, and perfectly usable for stealing, you are doing something wrong already. Actually, for _any_ case of content in websites, if you rely on a search engine of all things (designed to spider your website) to protect it you are doing something terribly wrong. I wish Google would just have removed the Getty Images from their search index altogether and be done with it. If they don't want them there, just remove them all already. I hate this sort of collective punishment for the entire web just because of someone's "special interests" that honestly seem to boil down to webmasters with "special needs"!
- bshacklett 9y agoSeems fitting to me, but Getty Images obviously had a lot of say in the matter, and I doubt they wanted their images delisted completely.
- bitL 9y agoPhotographers should meticulously watermark their photos and offer non-watermarked via paid portals or with whatever ugly DRM there is. Unless they want to do it for free, which many want.