4 ms·
> AMP is obviously conceived, funded, and implemented by Google and its employees. If you squinted your eyes and tilted your head just right you could see a "go
by ravenstine 9y ago
> AMP is obviously conceived, funded, and implemented by Google and its employees. If you squinted your eyes and tilted your head just right you could see a "good for the web" angle with faster mobile pages.
An idea predicated on a lie can only go downhill. Engineers need to, as best they can, convince product owners that AMP in any form is a poison apple.
- tyingq 9y agoI wonder if Google's AMP team is truly drowning in the Kool aid or if they actually know what's going on, but keep quiet for job security reasons.
- jacquesm 9y agoYou should read back on some of the older threads here on HN where AMP is heralded as the best thing Google has done in a long time.
- tyingq 9y agoI have, but the comments I read were from the AMP lead, who I assume has fully drunk the Kool aid since they probably signed up for that job. I'm more curious about his/her team members. Google hires smart people. I assume they are free thinkers. Edit: I'm pretty vocal in those old threads calling out AMP as a walled garden play, FWIW. I remember AOL's early days.
- jacquesm 9y agoSmart people with mortgages at valley rates seem to get a lot less smart when they are looking at their own contributions.
- TrickyRick 9y agoDoesn't the valley work much like every other tech hub in the world, i.e. if you lose your job in the morning you can start a new job somewhere else sometime after lunch? Especially with a place like Google on your resumé.
- ravenstine 9y agoThat may be true, but the vast majority of people don't keep a stockpile of "fuck you" money in case of such situations. The path of least resistance is to lick boots and spend spend spend, not to be "insubordinate" or forego bad deals like rent-to-own from banks.
- sireat 9y agoUpton Sinclair - "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"
- JoshMnem 9y agoI like Google, but they are really losing their way with things like AMP and Material Design (accessibility). People need to speak up or we won't have a truly open WWW much longer.
- izacus 9y ago> An idea predicated on a lie can only go downhill. Engineers need to, as best they can, convince product owners that AMP in any form is a poison apple. Is that the same way as engineers convinced product owners to not turn pages into autoplaying video, malware javascript, popup ladden piles of garbage? Or is that ok for those engineers?
- ravenstine 9y agoMy experience is limited, but I doubt engineers ever speak up about those things. I've yet to witness it. And I'm no better; the best that I usually do is audibly groan at those things or share opinion pieces about them in Slack. Actually, there was one time I witnessed an engineer speak up about why a particular popular idea was a bad thing long-term. He left immediately after management squinted at him and tilted their heads like confused dogs. That doesn't mean that it's not worth the effort. I would rather try something than to never have. All I can say now is that I won't be working on any future AMP development. The people who employ me may have to have to decide if it's worth firing me over an insidious Google feature. I hold no malice to my employer, but there comes a point where I cannot take money to do damage to the technology that enabled my career. TLDR: Your point is well taken, but my point still stands that there should be some way for stakeholders to know that what they want may have long-term negative consequences.
- nailer 9y ago> Engineers need to, as best they can, convince product owners that AMP in any form is a poison apple. Sorry (as in: I apologize). As an engineer, I know AMP shows slow AMP sites before fast HTML ones and this disgusts me. As a product owner, I need to be in that carousel. It's sales and pays my rent. So product owner me even made engineer me write an AMP library for node. It doesn't feel great.
- ec109685 9y agoGoogle prefetches AMP Content. It can’t do that for HTML pages, so how is it possible that Google is showing slow amp pages before fast html? Is there an example of this that you can point to?
- nailer 9y agoHTML pages do not appear in the carousel or in the new desktop stories area at all. These are both placed before the old style results.
- rdtsc 9y ago> Engineers need to, as best they can, convince product owners that AMP in any form is a poison apple. Product owners will convince them right back with large 3 figure salaries, bonuses and RSUs. It won't be that hard either.
- ravenstine 9y agoOh I know full well what people's motivations are. Said motivations can contradict a principle without invalidating it. If people are fine playing into the erosion of the very technology that allows them to make money, that's on them. From now on, it won't be on me.