4 ms·
Some points (from a "farmer") - Brazil is a third world country. - labor is dirt cheap - on visits to Brazil, the level of human labor in agriculture is stun
by pragmatic 16y ago
Some points (from a "farmer")
- Brazil is a third world country.
- labor is dirt cheap
- on visits to Brazil, the level of human labor in agriculture is stunning. (Not possible in US at current wages). Compare Japanese automated factories to Chinese factories.
- subsidies (perhaps) not needed because some inputs (labor) is so cheap
- This is fantastic for Brazil.
I can't defend subsidies, and I don't know very many who can. However, it's part of the game now in the US, so you'd be a fool not to take advantage of them.
- corn prices (adjusted for inflation) are half of what they were in the 70's (http://inflationdata.com/inflation/inflation_Articles/Corn_Inflation.asp http://inflationdata.com/inflation/inflation_Articles/Corn_I...), while oil (a huge input to agriculture) is 3x as expensive (http://inflationdata.com/inflation/inflation_rate/historical_oil_prices_table.asp http://inflationdata.com/inflation/inflation_rate/historical...)
- Dry land agriculture is going to explode.
- drought resistance corn is going to increase the area of arable land in the US. (The west is relatively dry, we have a lot of "less productive" range land that could be used for agriculture. (Our land is right in that margin, all land is currently in soybeans and it is no-till.) Previous years (80's/90's) it was a mix of corn, oats, barley, sunflowers, wheat, sorghum, flax and some soybeans.
- The last few years have seen record harvests. A combination of good weather and excellent crop varieties is probably the cause.
- Ag Input prices have soared recently.
- Improvements in chemicals have made no-till a viable option.
- The main problem is weed control. Canada Thistle, etc, roundup ready crops are an amazing feat of engineering.
On being green.
- Our farm hasn't seen so much wildlife since the 70's/80's.
- Verdant fields support way more wildlife than native prairie. However, there is still plenty of land that for other reasons, terrain, etc is used for grazing, hay production.
- We had our land in the conversation reserve program (http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/programs/crp/ http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/programs/crp/) for quite some time. Now, crop prices make that ridiculous.
- Suburban chemical runoff is a faster growing problem then farm runoff. Chemicals are extremely expensive, so with new high tech methods, each part of the field gets the precise amount of chemical needed. Contrast this to urban/suburban runoff: http://www.chesapeakebay.net/landuse_urbansuburban.aspx?menuitem=19557 http://www.chesapeakebay.net/landuse_urbansuburban.aspx?menu... "Unlike many farmers using nutrient management plans, suburban residents often over-apply fertilizer to their lawns and gardens."
- yequalsx 16y agoIt's my impression that the genetically modified crops lack in taste. It's true that we can end up producing more food per acre with them but it seems that one price is on the taste. My anecdotal experience in Germany is that organic food there tastes better than organic food in the U.S. and is much better than the standard supermarket food in the U.S. As a farmer, what are your thoughts on this? Also, I wonder if we are getting into a chemical arms race with nature. Roundup resistant weeds now exist. Now there is a new Roundup. Does the ecology suffer and us from this arms race?
- sp332 16y agoGM crops only lack taste if they are designed with other goals in mind. For example, the McGregor tomatoes are infamous for looking great, having a long shelf life, and tasting like cardboard. I think it's possible to have a high-yield crop that tastes good, if the market can convince the growers (who convince the labs) that it's important.
- yequalsx 16y agoUnfortunately in the U.S. looks matter more than taste. I guess it's the wonders of advertising. Thanks for your answer.
- carnevalem 16y agoI am always fascinated by agriculture, but know very little about it. Do you know any books or other media that would be a good introduction to agriculture? I'm looking for something that explains what crops are good where, how many times you can plant a year, etc.
- muhfuhkuh 16y ago"- Brazil is a third world country. - labor is dirt cheap" Land is as well, which is why Americans are moving down there, buying up land, and going for it: http://politics.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2008/06/25/american-farmers-try-their-luck-in-brazil.html http://politics.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2008/06/25/am...