2 ms·
It's a nice idea, but he's using data that is waaaay too abstracted from anything he'd need for comparison. For starters, he did mention that at that level, th
by toss1 9y ago
It's a nice idea, but he's using data that is waaaay too abstracted from anything he'd need for comparison.
For starters, he did mention that at that level, the courses are set differently and/or on different trails, so the speed numbers are meaningless, even in aggregate. (if the data are meaningless, don't do the analysis)
Even tho the aggregate speeds may be similar in Slalom and Giant Slalom, it doesn't remotely reveal relevant data.
At the lower levels, women and men do compete on the same course, women skiing first, so the course is in better shape. Their times are consistently slower than the men who run the same course later when it is more chewed up.
Similarly, when women racers occasionally ski as forerunners on the same course, although they're skiing as a course & systems check and not supposed to go flat-out, so might not squeeze out the last few tenths of a second, it's still the same results.
If it were down to only skills, mental toughness, preparation, I'd expect the women to ski as fast, but I'm pretty sure that there are some biomechanical factors in ski racing that will still be critical, e.g., muscle/bone leverage and similar factors that keep women's weightlifting below the men's results.
A lot of it is strength and flexibility, as you have to hold your edge in the ice (most race-courses are deliberately iced so they don't get so chewed up) against some serious forces and vibrations/chatter/bumps. Oversimplifying a bit, more strength allows you to hold the edge in better contact with the ice and generate higher turning forces, while simultaneously maintaining a supple feel for the surface and how your ski is working.
Source: Former USST alpine racer,(mostly DH, also SL/GS/SG).