3 ms·
Being poor is buying a 2 pack of toilet paper for $2 rather than an 8 pack for $4 because even though the 8 pack is a much better deal, the extra $2 will buy th
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
Being poor is buying a 2 pack of toilet paper for $2 rather than an 8 pack for $4 because even though the 8 pack is a much better deal, the extra $2 will buy the loaf of bread you also need.
- nothrabannosir 9y agoThis is something that’s easy to forget once you have money: lack of liquidity is expensive. The (ironic) gravity of cash means the more you have the more you get (interest), and the less you have the less you get (interest). Louis CK has a whole bit about this, back from when he was still broke: https://youtu.be/Y_-1l_SlA7c https://youtu.be/Y_-1l_SlA7c I guess time has done him well :)
- SilasX 9y agoThe problem with that theory is that it implies that you could have a self-funding charity that just makes loans that enable such long-term purchases: "Hey, don't buy the two pack. We'll buy you the 8 pack if you pay us $1/month for the next 5 months." Client saves $3. Charity gets >50% annualized ROR. Perpetual virtuous cycle that ends all poverty. Why do you think no one's been able to pull off such a charity? Probably because the bottleneck isn't getting the initial capital, but being unable to stick to a plan even when it could pay off long-term. It sounds like the program in the story is trying to close that gap and give more immediate rewards.
- learc83 9y ago>Why do you think no one's been able to pull off such a charity? It turns out there are numerous charities designed to provide liquidity to poor people through microloans. Many of them are very effective.
- SilasX 9y agoIn the third world, to self-starting entrepreneurs who already did the footwork of figuring out how the capital could quickly pay itself back, not the small-unit-buying clients in the American communities that the parent was diagnosing. (I was originally going to give a caveat about Kiva, etc.)
- linkmotif 9y agoIt's true. Not to mention all the other examples in books like Nickel and Dimed. It's hard and shitty to be poor, and people exploit you. But you don't end up in endless poverty by making the right decisions. The United States can be a pretty brutal place, but comparing to human history it's actually incredibly forgiving and full of opportunity.