9 ms·
Man, this type of program sounds patronizing. "Here, let us rich people tell you poor people what you need to do so you can be successful like me" Making this
by cortesoft 9y ago
Man, this type of program sounds patronizing. "Here, let us rich people tell you poor people what you need to do so you can be successful like me"
Making this conditional is basically saying, "You don't know what you need, and we can't trust you to do what is best for yourself"
People know what they need. If we have money to give them, just give them the money.
- linkmotif 9y agoHuh? Let me get this straight: you expect people to accept patronage. But you then don’t want the patrons to be patronizing? How does that work? Generally speaking, aren’t poor people poor because either they don’t know how to be not poor or can’t execute being not poor? Yes, sometimes it’s impossible to execute being rich, like if there is a systematic bias against a certain cohort. But cases like that aside, isn’t it pretty obvious that poor people either cannot or do not know how to not be poor? Your perspective seems to suggest being poor just happens randomly to random people. But that’s not true. Being poor happens to people who fail to get and keep money from other people. Any time someone talks about patronizing poor people it’s like: yeah either we’re not going to talk about them being poor like that’s a bad thing, or we’re going to talk about it like it’s a bad thing and so maybe then we should figure out what they’re doing wrong when there are other people who are not poor. Pretending like everyone’s economic actions are equal is insensitive to people who get and keep money and patronizing to people who don’t. Not all economic actions are equally good. Setting money on fire is not a good economic action. It is offensive to the person whose labor created that value. Yet I see poor people doing all kinds of offensive economic actions with money given to them by the state. I see people using benefits cards to buy groceries that I would never buy because they are so expensive or unnecessary. If you don’t want to be judged, don’t take money from other people, because that is literally patronage, which is patronizing.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoBeing poor is buying a 2 pack of toilet paper for $2 rather than an 8 pack for $4 because even though the 8 pack is a much better deal, the extra $2 will buy the loaf of bread you also need.
- nothrabannosir 9y agoThis is something that’s easy to forget once you have money: lack of liquidity is expensive. The (ironic) gravity of cash means the more you have the more you get (interest), and the less you have the less you get (interest). Louis CK has a whole bit about this, back from when he was still broke: https://youtu.be/Y_-1l_SlA7c https://youtu.be/Y_-1l_SlA7c I guess time has done him well :)
- SilasX 9y agoThe problem with that theory is that it implies that you could have a self-funding charity that just makes loans that enable such long-term purchases: "Hey, don't buy the two pack. We'll buy you the 8 pack if you pay us $1/month for the next 5 months." Client saves $3. Charity gets >50% annualized ROR. Perpetual virtuous cycle that ends all poverty. Why do you think no one's been able to pull off such a charity? Probably because the bottleneck isn't getting the initial capital, but being unable to stick to a plan even when it could pay off long-term. It sounds like the program in the story is trying to close that gap and give more immediate rewards.
- learc83 9y ago>Why do you think no one's been able to pull off such a charity? It turns out there are numerous charities designed to provide liquidity to poor people through microloans. Many of them are very effective.
- SilasX 9y agoIn the third world, to self-starting entrepreneurs who already did the footwork of figuring out how the capital could quickly pay itself back, not the small-unit-buying clients in the American communities that the parent was diagnosing. (I was originally going to give a caveat about Kiva, etc.)
- linkmotif 9y agoIt's true. Not to mention all the other examples in books like Nickel and Dimed. It's hard and shitty to be poor, and people exploit you. But you don't end up in endless poverty by making the right decisions. The United States can be a pretty brutal place, but comparing to human history it's actually incredibly forgiving and full of opportunity.
- learc83 9y agoA huge part of "can’t execute being not poor" is a direct effect of lack of resources. There is also plenty of research that shows that poverty is detrimental to mental health in a way that reinforces poverty. The insecurity from not knowing where your next meal will come from or not knowing were to sleep is a direct cause of poor decision making.
- egwynn 9y agoYup, this is definitely a big part of it. I won't pretend like it's "the whole answer", but "poverty-induced executive dysfunction" is a real contributor to poor people staying poor.
- sp332 9y agoIt does seem kinda random to me. "Contrary to popular belief," he wrote over the weekend, "the percentage of the population that directly encounters poverty is exceedingly high." Between the ages of 25 and 60, Rank has found, almost 40 percent of Americans will live at least one year below the poverty line. Yet over time, most also pull themselves back above of it. https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/11/a-shockingly-high-number-of-americans-experience-poverty/281172/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/11/a-shock... Also the #1 reason people go into bankruptcy in this country is medical costs. That's not something that can be "executed".
- linkmotif 9y agoBeing poor happens to people who have failed to get and keep money. Sometimes that starts with you, sometimes your ancestors. Obviously it’s easier to get money if you already have it. But if you’re poor, someone didn’t get it. Could be for messed up, unfair reasons. But it’s that simple. It’s not random. Getting wiped out by a medical event means you didn’t have health insurance. Health insurance is generally affordable despite what the GOP says, especially if you’re in poverty then you can get some really good Obamacare for free. Not buying insurance is just about the poorest thing you can do. Yes, before the ACA there was the the whole preexisting condition thing. There’s all kind of whack ass stuff out there. But I’m not talking about corner cases. I’m talking big picture. Step one to not being poor is having insurance.
- sp332 9y agoYes, I was taking it as axiomatic that poor people have less money than rich people. But having more or less money seems to correlate surprisingly weakly with knowledge or behavior. Of course people can do really dumb things but we're not talking about corner cases. I'm talking about the tens of millions of people who get poorer and then less poor without changing their knowledge or behavior very dramatically.
- chatmasta 9y ago> sometimes your ancestors The sins of the father... > It’s not random But people cannot choose where, when, or to whom they are born.
- jellicle 9y ago> Generally speaking, aren’t poor people poor because either they don’t know how to be not poor or can’t execute being not poor? No. Generally speaking, people are poor because their parents were poor and because they are in a system which works to make and keep them poor.
- linkmotif 9y agoTrue, there is a system which works to make and keep them poor. That's undeniable. It's sort of this abusive relationship between the rich and poor, wherein the rich work really hard to keep the poor poor, but then blame them for it as well. But is there not a way that poor people could escape this system? Is there not some set of actions that the poor could take—and the poor are a strong majority of humanity, right?—that they would extricate themselves from the vice grip of the rich? Have they any agency? Or are they just so hopeless that it's impossible?
- pdabbadabba 9y ago> I see people using benefits cards to buy groceries that I would never buy because they are so expensive or unnecessary. I hear people make claims like this frequently and I always wonder if it could possibly be true. I can't remember the last time I paid any attention whatsoever to what other people were buying in the grocery store, much less their mode of payment. This sounds more like the repetition of a certain strain of conservative mythology (with a strong family resemblance to the infamously fictional "welfare queen") than actual anecdote. And if it is true: 1) Maybe consider giving your fellow shoppers a little privacy. And 2) I wonder: exactly what groceries are we talking about here that you can be so sure another person, whose life and preferences you know nothing about, is making not just a mistake, but being "economically offensive" by buying them? Voss bottled water is about the only thing I can think of that might fit the bill here.
- Ashcroft001 9y agoI need crack. Please send the requisite funds post-haste.
- ctrl-j 9y agoAs someone who grew up poor with parents who worked their asses off and didn't touch drugs or booze - your comment is both in poor taste, and ignorant. I'd happily give all the crack addicts assistance if it meant no children missed any meals.
- Para2016 9y agoIt better be non cash based assistance then. If you're happily giving money to cocaine addicts then you're not being helpful at all.
- ctrl-j 9y ago> If you're happily giving money to cocaine addicts then you're not being helpful at all. How about we don't conflate the two issues? People who have so little money they can't afford food, should get assistance. Full stop. Crack addicts who are so poor to require that same assistance probably need drug counseling and possible mental health assistance. In addition to the money for food. If you think throwing it on a card or whatever will stop the addicts from buying drugs - you're mistaken. Maybe we shouldn't treat people who are suffering as if they deserve their conditions. Maybe we should have more compassion for them, than we do for the corrupt wall street bankers who got massive bailouts in 2008.
- Para2016 9y agoYea, they should get assistance. Just not direct cash, I totally disagree with you in that regard. What they do need is drug counseling, psychiatric counseling, a safe place to stay, food provided for them, clothing, help finding a job and stable housing arrangement after they are sober. Giving a cocaine addict that is so poor they are living on the streets just cash, is unhelpful. Once they are sober and have proven they will responsibly use money for needed items, then you can give it to them. As a physician who sees plenty of county patients that are addicts - you know what happens when they get a bunch of money? They spend it on drugs, not on their neglected children or anything else in Maslow's hierarchy. Do-gooders who think handing cash to an addict is helpful, are wrong. You're just wrong and I completely disagree with you, I'm not conflating anything.
- ggchappell 9y ago> People know what they need. There is another way to view this. We might think of these programs as encouraging people to do things that society needs, instead of what they need. Then the payment is there to offset the personal cost. Note. I've thought about this for all of 10 seconds. I might be 'way off.
- chatmasta 9y agoI think the insulting part is the subtle insinuation that the money is more likely to be used to buy drugs/alcohol than for the purpose of feeding the recipient or otherwise helping them out of poverty. Even if 50% of recipients go buy drugs with the money, does it really matter? It probably costs more to enforce these conditions than the percent of funding that would go to drugs. It also creates bureaucratic overhead at the point of distribution. Further, it’s unlikely enforcing criteria even filters out more drug users than non-restricted payouts do. These criteria are unlikey to be mutually exclusive with drug use. Someone can take drugs and also check all the boxes to meet the “criteria.” Given this consideration, it is clear that attaching conditions to a payout contributes little to no marginal gain in savings or efficency of individual outcomes. But as other comments note, the conditions themselves are beneficial to both the recipient and those around them. If one person gets preventive healthcare who would not have otherwise, isn’t that a good outcome? Is it a better outcome than if one drug user does not seek or get access to disbursements? Perhaps a better solution would create tiered payouts that get higher the more conditions you meet. The lowest payout would have no strings attached, but higher payouts would be available to those who fulfill certain criteria.
- jstarfish 9y ago> I think the insulting part is the subtle insinuation that the money is more likely to be used to buy drugs/alcohol than for the purpose of feeding the recipient or otherwise helping them out of poverty. > Even if 50% of recipients go buy drugs with the money, does it really matter? The libertarian dream, however the unfortunate reality is that where the money is supposed to do things like feed your children, you instead squander it on drugs. If the presumption of drugs is too harsh, replace it with something equally stupid like cigarettes, lottery tickets, rent-to-own furniture or some other predatory service that the poor disproportionately participate in. This is not a behavior beneficial to anybody or worth enabling. This is why we have systems like food stamps (disbursements that can only be spent on food), WIC (disbursements that can only be spent on fresh vegetables, baby food/formula, etc) and so on. Handing cash to people who don't know how to use it responsibly does not spontaneously teach them otherwise.
- 9y ago
- torstenvl 9y agoA very large number of people absolutely do not know what they need, or - if they do - are not sufficiently motivated to pursue those needs. See, e.g., the obesity epidemic, smoking cessation, social security (in lieu of retirement savings), tax refunds (in lieu of adjusting withholding), etc. Willpower, knowledge, and just plain old wherewithal aren't free and can't just be assumed.
- Tarq0n 9y agoIt works both ways as well. Poverty causes stress and lowers self control and cognitive resources. This makes it harder for people in poverty to work their way back out, even if they may intrinsically have the necessary capabilities.
- bdcravens 9y agoI grew up dirt poor. Filthy home, no family car, head lice, "food or electricity this week?" poor. Poverty was a series of choices, not something forced upon my family. Of course you eventually get to a point where you can't "better choice" your way out of it, but I think the truth needs to be said, as that reality isn't very PC it seems. Every time my family had any money, they bought stuff. Not stuff we needed, but stupid crap. Definitely not calculated decisions to make progress to getting out of poverty. As a technology professional, I make good money, and my income has about quadrupled since I started in 1999. I still struggle with that same poor mentality even so. At best, it's a spray-and-pray approach. Many will fail. Maybe the few that use the money to improve will make it all worth, kind of like the "Just Say No" campaign. The real question is what level of efficiency do we demand?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoI think it's dangerous to take your situation and apply it to everyone in poverty. Most people are there because they don't have a way out even if in your specific circumstance that wasn't the case.
- bequanna 9y ago> Most people are there because they don't have a way out ... You're refuting an anecdotal example with an unsubstantiated claim.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoThen they should get equal weight. I know poor people who are there do to uncontrollable circumstance - bad schools, sick family members, take your pick. I think if you exist in a western country and you don't know a single person who is poor by virtue of circumstance and not by choice then you're not doing near enough to leave your bubble.
- linkmotif 9y ago> Most people are there because they don't have a way out even if in your specific circumstance that wasn't the case. That’s a huge statement. How would you back that up? “Most” people? Who? When? Why?
- jdoliner 9y ago> Man, this type of program sounds patronizing. This program is in a very literal sense patronizing. One of the definitions of that word is providing financial assistance to someone. Another one is treating someone with an air of superiority, which is the connotation I think you meant. These two things tend to go hand in hand though, that's why they use the same word. I have trouble seeing how we could have a UBI like system that wasn't patronizing though.
- djtriptych 9y agoWho gets to patronize if it's "universal"?
- stevenwoo 9y agoWe already have a UBI like system that isn't patronizing in the USA - it's the Alaska petroleum funds distribution to all state residents. changed link to cached since wired deleted original story http://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?q=study+of+alaska+comparing+ubi+low+income&d=4589526491005581&mkt=en-US&setlang=en-US&w=1jWxMsxg_dInExiY8XrJxHBEEuoy-pdM http://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?q=study+of+alaska+comparing+u...