3 ms·
Wasn't Turkey, well, Anatolia, mostly Greek/Hellenistic in nature, especially along the significant coastline, and wasn't till the ottomen and their "conquista"
by mc32 9y ago
Wasn't Turkey, well, Anatolia, mostly Greek/Hellenistic in nature, especially along the significant coastline, and wasn't till the ottomen and their "conquista" of the peninsula drove out the Greek and Roman vestiges?
- richardknop 9y agoThe crucial point was the sacking of Constantinople. Basically Western Christians sacking the city and raping and destroying center of Eastern Christianity. If Christians would have instead united history could have been quite different. The era of crusades is very interesting and complex. Lots of very important historical events that shaped the world history afterwards happened during those times. Lots of parallels could be drawn even to our current time we are living (hint hint).
- tboyd47 9y agoThe most significant demographic change for the city was actually not the Ottoman conquest, but its destruction and rule by the Western Christians ~200 years prior. These events took the population down from about 400,000 to about 35,000. It never recovered. By the time Mehmed II came along, it was only 50,000.
- ng12 9y agoConstantinople was just one city though. Antioch, Edessa, Trebizond were all major Greek cities which were conquered by the Turks.
- richardknop 9y agoIt’s pure speculation but if instead of sacking Constantinople and killing all of those people West made an alliance with East, Byzantine Empire could have survived, albeit losing substantial territories in the East. The situation of Eastern Romans was bad with them losing a lot of their eastern provinces but they still had some fight left in them.
- ng12 9y agoI've thought about that a lot too. It's possible, but I think that thread failed when the re-conquered cities were turned into the Crusader States rather than being returned to Greek control. If anything, I feel like the Siege if Vienna would have happened at the walls of Constantinople instead and history would be more or less unchanged.
- jcranmer 9y agoThe Byzantine Empire was faced with a conundrum. It needed political allies and military support to be able to see off the threats of the Seljuks, then the Mongols, and finally the Ottomans. The major Latin Christendom powers were hesitant to give that kind of consistent alliance to the heretical Orthodox/Catholic split, and many Byzantine emperors did seriously consider the idea of giving up the Orthodox to obtain that support. However, the emperors who did so faced the severe wrath of their core population, driving rebellions instead. The Byzantines were effectively forced into a mode where they had to choose between internal and external security, which is a large factor of their terminal decline. By the Fourth Crusade, the Empire was pretty much in a state where the surrounding powers had more reason to wait to pick at its corpse than to help it survive.
- richardknop 9y agoI can’t reply to your reply for some reason :P You mentioned Siege of Vienna. Remember that it eventually failed and it culminated with Battle of Vienna when Ottomans were completely defeated and soon after driven out of Europe. I would have thought that had the battle happened outside Constantinople instead of Vienna the history would have been changed completely. Vast parts of Ottoman Empire would probably be part of EU now.
- jcranmer 9y agoThe Anatolian and Thracian lands were part of the Greek cultural sphere historically (well, at least since Alexander's conquests peeling them off of Persia). Alexander's conquests ensured that Egypt and Palestine would remain in Mediterranean-centric empires--these were part of the Roman Empire and then the Byzantine Empire. The Arab conquests quickly removed Egypt and Palestine from the Byzantine world. The Seljuk Turks moved into central Anatolia (this is what prompted the Crusades), and did seek to take Constantinople, although they were done in by the Mongols instead. The Fourth Crusade resulted in the sack of Constantinople by Western Christendom. The Latin Empire didn't last terribly long, and the remnants of the Byzantine Empire took it back within a century, but the Byzantine Empire was at this point in a fatal cycle of internal rebellion. At this time, the Ottomans, who start out as a minor Beylik in western Anatolia, take advantage of Byzantine distraction to peel off the lands of Thrace and move their capital to Edirne and solidify themselves as the dominant power in the Balkans. It's from this base that they ultimately defeat the European powers (Battle of Varna) and put the Byzantine Empire out of its misery (conquest of Constantinople). By and large, the Ottomans actually brought back stability to Thrace and Anatolia, at least for 300 years or so. Anatolia was lost to the Seljuks long before, and the Ottomans were the first power to be able to unify it under a polity since the collapse of the Sultanate of Rum. Christian infighting caused the political instability in the Balkans that the Ottomans were most able to take advantage of. Note that the change in political control doesn't necessarily correspond to change in the general inclinations of the population. Greeks and Armenians still remained a major part of the Seljuk and Ottomans (although they did decline over the centuries), and the Ottomans were generally quite tolerant of this heritage for the first few centuries (much less so after around 1700).
- alsetmusic 9y agoGreat summary. I’ve been working through a lot of this on Wikipedia for a while. Do you have any recommendations for books related to the above events?
- jcranmer 9y agoThe best book to recommend about the history of the Ottoman Empire is "Osman's Dream", which covers the history from its origins in the 14th century to the deposing of the last sultan as caliph in 1923.