4 ms·
I see nothing in wrong with this as long as the checkbox is prominently presented, preferably on it's own "page" of the installer, it can be easily updated post
by koolba 9y ago
I see nothing in wrong with this as long as the checkbox is prominently presented, preferably on it's own "page" of the installer, it can be easily updated post-installation, and the scope of agreed upon data collection isn't increased for a given installation after agreement.
> Any user can simply opt out by unchecking the box, which triggers one
simple POST stating, “diagnostics=false”. There will be a corresponding
checkbox in the Privacy panel of GNOME Settings to toggle the state of this.
By POST do they mean a POST to the same web endpoint? Why would opting out requiring notifying them of your installation. I get that they'd want to track installation counts but would expect opting out to be entirely silent. Or do they mean that opting out once you've opted in would notify them of such?
> And to reiterate, the service which stores this data would never store IP
addresses.
Any idea what country / jurisdiction they plan to host this data and service?
- Faaak 9y agoI suppose it to have a "total number of installs" statistic.
- jstanley 9y agoBut the point is that's none of their business.
- mrob 9y agoThey can already get an approximate number by counting downloads of package updates. It's deceptive to send any information if the user opted out.
- lovelearning 9y agoI doubt it's possible since many systems update from closest mirrors, most of which are not Canonical's servers.
- lloeki 9y agoThe only potentially dangerous step I see is: > Apport would be configured to automatically send anonymous crash reports without user interruption. I'm unfamiliar with apport, but crash reports may contain partial memory dumps with information you don't want collected. Also, > Popcon would be installed. This will allow us to spot trends in package usage and help us to focus on the packages which are of most value to our users. Far less worrying, but I can see some people cringing on that one. Barring those two this is the kind of checkbox presented on install I'd definitely encourage people to leave checked.