6 ms·
I'm a PhD student at a UK university. From what I've seen in my department (Engineering) there are about 3 women for every 5 men, both in staff and students, a
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
I'm a PhD student at a UK university. From what I've seen in my department
(Engineering) there are about 3 women for every 5 men, both in staff and
students, a not unreasonable ratio. However, I struggle to remember more than
a couple of women who are British or from an English-speaking country. The
majority come from India, China, the rest of Europe, the Middle East etc.
I've also seen this in the six years I worked in the UK as a developer, before
starting my PhD. Of the women developers I worked with, (in this case, not so
many) the majority were Indian or Eastern or Southern European. The same goes
for the students in my data science Masters (also in a UK university).
Other women I've discussed this with, have similar experiences. In particular
Greek women (like myself) don't remember any perception of a strong bias in
numbers against women in STEM subjects. I have a fair few Greek women friends
who have bachelors or master's degrees in computer science.
All this is of course anecdotal but it makes me think there is some sort of
bias that is not explained by "interest in things" vs "interest in people", or
any such difference between the sexes, because it is particular to specific
cultures, rather than to the sexes around the globe.
In any case "gendered interest" sounds like a convenient oversimplification
that seeks to confirm cultural bias as natural and spontaneous, rather than
an attempt to understand it. Instead of answering any questions it passes the
buck; it leaves someone else to wonder why girls and boys are interested in
different things (e.g. fire trucks vs barbie dolls). The same goes for
academic performance in school: that is also an observation that requires an
explanation- not an explanation in and of itself.
- donkeyd 9y agoI'd never really paid attention to this, but now that you mention it, the Dutch company I work for has 4 female developers, 3 of which are Indian.
- bloak 9y agoI would expect immigrants to more frequently choose careers that require fewer linguistic skills, such as engineering or music, rather than law or advertising, say. Some of my engineer colleagues are very hard to understand on the phone because of their language. It's hard to imagine them getting anywhere as a lawyer, for example.
- dominotw 9y ago> I would expect immigrants to more frequently choose careers that require fewer linguistic skills Thats not correct theory. Visas (h1b) are only granted where there is perceived shortage like computer programmers ect. An indian woman cannot come to "choose" to be an english teacher in usa.
- bloak 9y agoThat may be true in the USA but I don't think we were talking about the USA specifically. In the EU we have lots of immigrants who didn't have or need a job-specific visa. Even in the USA, don't you have immigrants who were refugees or family members who are allowed to work?
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoIn the UK, a large number of doctors and medical staff are foreign, particularly Indian or EU citizens. For Indians I'm guessing English is not a problem because they learn it at school, especially the ones from the poshest backgrounds. EU citizens will have similar command of English. For those who have studied in British institutions, foreign language courses are mandatory if they can't prove a level of English that allows them to participate in the courses.
- bloak 9y agoNot contradicting, but adding to that: Some Indians speak English fluently, but in a way that most British people find incomprehensible. In contrast, and somewhat ironically, a German speaking bad English is often easier to understand than a random British person (as opposed to a British person from one's own social class and locality). The level of English knowledge you need to study maths or engineering at a British university is obviously very much lower than the level required for studying law or working as a lawyer. Some otherwise intelligent people are bad at languages and will realistically never achieve knowledge of another language to a level sufficient to successfully work as a lawyer. In fact, I have been reliably informed that some Germans give up on physics as a career because they realise that they will never manage to learn English well enough to succeed in academia, which is a bit sad, really.
- MistahKoala 9y agoCasual lay observer here (i.e., don't treat this as coming from a position of being deeply informed). The phenomenon you describe sounds similar to the 'Nordic gender paradox' (or variations of the term). It's been a while since I last touched on it and I can't easily find a source worth pointing to - at least, one that hasn't been presented through a political lens - and academic names on the subject don't come to mind just now. Essentially, despite various attempts to get to 'equal' gender outcomes in the most 'equitable' societies in the world, participation in jobs and industries associated with men and women remains stubbornly unmoved towards 50:50 (or whatever proportion is considered desirable). The suggestion is that it's precisely the relatively equitable and liberal norms of those societies that have provided the conditions for women to make use of their agency and choose roles according to their preferences. Whereas women in societies less predisposed towards liberal norms may be motivated by other considerations, such as the need to maximise their earning potential, familial expectations of success or a stronger sense of needing to prove one's potential and achievement (including perceptions of gender in their own societies). In the instance of the anecdote about your Greek colleagues, I wondered if the financial crisis was a catalyst for greater participation, along with the current trend of Greeks' tendency towards staying in HE for longer? I've probably made mistakes or mischaracterised aspects of this idea, but that's broadly how I understand it. It doesn't answer the why of 'systems/things' vs 'people' (which has more accessible academic discourse than this does), although I think it offers a different perspective on biases that may be in play.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoWhat you mention is also referred to in the article itself, and it does make sense - true emancipation and gender equality is IMO more about equal opportunity, and the freedom to choose. The push towards getting more women in STEM and specifically CS feels like it tries to take that freedom away in a sense; you SHOULD pick CS, here's all the money we're investing in getting women to work for us.
- MistahKoala 9y ago> What you mention is also referred to in the article itself Admittedly, I'm yet to read it (Pocketed it for later). I assume I agree with your sentiment about what equality means and what its relationships with freedom and liberty are - it's just not something that can easily be said in the open without running the risk of having to defend it or attracting pariah status. I don't really want to say much more on the matter here beyond that (it's mostly a draining experience).
- fastball 9y agoDo you not think this could be because immigrants are looking for economic prosperity and have fewer connections? For example, a British woman that graduates from a British university with a history degree and wants to work in the UK probably met a couple people during the course of her degree (or at any other point) that can help her move forward with a career. Because let's face it, you're not going to get a high-paying job with high marks in your History BA and nothing else. As such, her prospects will be better in her field of study or in a reasonably related field (or any field where having contacts strongly helps and where she has made such contacts). Meanwhile, an immigrant will be much, much less likely to have such local connections/contacts. Presumably then, immigrants will gravitate towards fields where getting into them / your pay grade is more closely based on competency and not "who you know". In other words, fields like STEM or (in your case) anything which requires a PhD. Could that not be an explanation for your experience?
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoIt's an explanation but not a very simple one. It requires the immigrant to have chosen a career while in their country that would offer them more prospects once they emigrated. But then, why immigate instead of choosing a career that would be profitable and respectable in their country in the first place? I think a simpler explanation is that people choose a career in their countries for whatever reason (that I don't know and can't speculate about) then when demand for their skills rises, they may find that emigrating is a better choice than staying at home- for instance, because salaries are better abroad. That would be a simpler explanation for why more women in IT professions are immigrants to the UK (and possibly the US, though I'm not sure): they got the skills, there's job offers, they go abroad and take the offers.
- ghostwriter 9y agoThe difference in preferences is consistent across nations (and their cultures) - https://youtu.be/p5LRdW8xw70?t=15m36s https://youtu.be/p5LRdW8xw70?t=15m36s
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Double_a_92 9y agoFrom what I've seen in my department (Engineering) there are about 3 women. Exactly 3 women. It was a smaller Uni with maybe ~150 Students.
- dominotw 9y agoVisas are overwhelmingly only granted to technical fields. So people who can immigrate to america are the ones in technical fields. You won't see lots of indian students studying philosophy because once you are done you have to go back. Bad monetary investment. Want a better life = study engineering. The explanation is as simple as that.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoIn Cal, 90% of the women I’ve worked with are south or east asian, and all locals.
- dominotw 9y agoIts just social inertia. I am willing to bet most of their parents are engineers.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoI would agree but call it "cultural," and less stigma to being a geek.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> Visas are overwhelmingly only granted to technical fields. So people who can immigrate to america are the ones in technical fields. Even so, why are there more of those technical immigrants female than the locals? That the majority of visas granted are for technical fields doesn't tell us anything about the gender of those who obtain them. There's nothing stopping 100% of immigrant IT workers from, e.g. India from being male. Why are they not? Also, I'm not sure the assumption that visas are only granted to technical workers is correct. My experience is from the UK and I don't know what happens in the US, but over here, immigrants do all sorts of jobs. For example, many doctors and nurses in the NHS (the National Health Service) are from India or the EU; the majority of agricultural workers are from the EU; plumbers, famously, are all Polish; catering workers are from the EU; etc etc.
- 9y ago