3 ms·
When you start comparing the $20B cost for ITER versus "big" projects like the human genome, which took $1B over a similar time scale, ITER really does seem lik
by epistasis 9y ago
When you start comparing the $20B cost for ITER versus "big" projects like the human genome, which took $1B over a similar time scale, ITER really does seem like a boondoggle. It's sucking up massive amounts of research dollars and attention on scientific/engineering goals that don't necessarily even move in the right direction! Suppose they succeed; then what? What has been learned that can spur the next $20B? Will the next tokamok take an order of magnitude less money to produce, like the next genome did the day after the first was released?
Big projects always use ridiculous and deceptive hype, but "unlimited energy" takes that to a new level, IMHO.
- Jedd 9y agoIt's possible that your assessment is predicated on the idea that all advancement can be reduced to $-values, normalised over large time spans. My feeling -- undeniably hard to substantiate -- is that this is a difficult position to defend or attack.
- epistasis 9y agoI'm certainly not reducing the advancement to dollar values. In contrast, the expenditure necessarily must be evaluated in money and time, and it's an age old problem: who gets the research allocations? The advancements are often unknown, but even if the genome project hadn't had the side effect of spinning off a massive amount of technology, the end product would be a significant advancement that would have accelerated all manner of biological research. This was biology's biggest project ever, and it is massively dwarfed by the boondoggles of physics. In contrast, what can we learn form ITER? The opportunity for learning seems awfully minimal, and if it does complete its goal, as the article points out, it's not terribly desirable. And if the end goal isn't desirable, where's the side-effects of tech development? There appears to be none. However many contractors get rich. Potential for advancements can be difficult to judge, and the biggest advancements are almost never expected. But when judging must be done about potential, it's typically best done by those close to the field rather than by political means. ITER seems to be more of a political beast [1] than a scientific one. A political beast that has now robbed the field of fusion of $20B of dollars that could have gone to other research projects. (There's significant intra-science politics of course, that greatly steer the course of research as much as scientific goals. However I'd much rather go with those political winds than the politics of nations when deciding research.) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16380390 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16380390
- Jedd 9y ago> In contrast, the expenditure necessarily must be evaluated in money and time, and it's an age old problem: who gets the research allocations? Sure, but a) when does the evaluation occur (after one year, after two years, after ten years, or after a new or accidental technology has been demonstrated to save humanity from certain destruction)? > In contrast [to genome projects], what can we learn form ITER? Experimental physics experiments have always suffered this comparison. I can't address your question, sorry. Your suggestion that it may all be about the end goal (as if there's always and only a single end goal for research) is perhaps intentionally misguided - as you then hint at in your subsequent paragraph.
- epistasis 9y agoI don't mean specifically to compare to biology, but even within physics, is ITER a good place to put research money? Though I'm not a physicist, it seems that even many other fusion projects would be better bets.
- cornholio 9y agoITER does not do fundamental research like the LHC, they focus on very specific technical problems in the field of fusion power - as if it's already a given that their particular approach to power generation is desirable and workable. The author's concern is that even is the problems are solved, tokamak fusion power is still a prohibitively expensive and unsustainable idea; it's only natural to question why those research resources funds aren't devoted to other areas that at least make an attempt to obtain directly useful results. The tritium economy issue is particularly wexing, any commercial D-T reactor will need outside, fission produced tritium.
- KarenSatantsby 9y agoDont forget War.. we spend a lot of mindshare on murder.. What about Entertainment.. 20B is like how much we spend on movies last year.. so.. ok.. I will say boondoggle yeah..
- Retric 9y agoHuman genome cost well over 3 billion dollars and was mostly a pointless waste of funds. Now days we could do the same thing for under 1/100th the cost, but the focus was on making a useless 'map' rather than improving sequencing or finding out what DNA was actually doing.
- epistasis 9y agoThat's the most preposterous assessment I've heard of the genome project. The reason it costs so little now is because of the tech development that happened to make the genome come together. Not sure how you are going to sequence to find out what things do without having that map. And I sat that as someone who is entirely interested in what things do and is not so interested in the map itself (check my profile)
- XorNot 9y agoDoesn't this then refute your original point? ITER is expensive because we're developing the tech to build fusion power. The underscoring point of people talking about cost is simply: do you have a better way? Before the LHC came online there were people claiming that after the magnet quench event it cost too much and we should cancel the project.
- Retric 9y agoFirst off DNA does not just sit around on it's own. You get computation from all the things wrapping around DNA. Making a the specific sequence less important than generally assumed. Anyway, location is almost meaningless. It's the actual sequence that's important and the genome project did not provide a full sequence of an actual human genome. So again, useless on it's own with a completely arbitrary end date for 'success' that again did not actually mark the accomplishment of anything. Worse, to be useful as a map you need to use much faster sequencing techniques to verify in what way some specific population is different from the average sequence. And then correlate that population with some difference to try and find out what that does. But, once you can do that you can do the entire sequence more cheaply. At best it provided funding for biotech, at worst it was 100% political in both motivation and execution. PS: ITER is more than 30 year old design at this point, we have several designs that should be vastly cheaper that are simply less verified. What ITER tests is not about cheap it's about verifying what's going on when you get more power from fusion than you get from external heating. That's critical for any form of sustained magnetic confinement. It also let's you test things like Tritium breeding that again required for D-T fusion at scale as we simply don't have enough Tritium to use it as fuel at scale but we have plenty of Lithium and Deuterium. It also tests remote handling of the containment vessel which is again required for any useful design etc. And to do all that and more you want to take the lowest risk path not just high risk high reward.