3 ms·
> But then they seize up when they see the bill. But that's the thing. We do pay for it in a very non transparent way. It's very convenient to never see the bi
by alkonaut 9y ago
> But then they seize up when they see the bill.
But that's the thing. We do pay for it in a very non transparent way. It's very convenient to never see the bill, but imagine a situation where you actually were shown your "Facebook bill". You could see exactly every nugget of information about you, traded in the financing of your facebook account. How many would seize up? How many would leave the product?
Perhaps a better question is: assume that users would be able to edit that bill - and say exactly what would be acceptable in terms of tracking/targeting/information sale. How much would people actually be paying after that? That's the "fair" price.
> I still sometimes think twice about paying for all these things.
I think we all do. But I still think I'd think twice about using Facebook too, if it was more transparent.
> How much would you pay for Facebook? $20 a month?
Around $5-10 per year I'd say.
Now: I'm not saying I believe Facebook could exist in their current form such a scheme with billions of users. But there could exist a Facebook that charged users $10 per year. Perhaps they would have 1/10th the number of users they have today, and 1/10 the number of services. And that's fine.
> I suspect you and I both have very little insight into how much it actually costs to run Facebook
Well we can only see the public numbers and extrapolate from there. The public figures are their total revenues, user numbers etc. So we have a vague guesstimation. But if users, employees and products were cut by 90%, the costs would likely be cut nearly proportionally. It's a lot of infrastructure costs.
I think my bottom line is this: I have no doubts that stricter laws and better technological defenses could and would kill many of these "internet giants". And it doesn't bother me one bit. We'll look back on the first decades of the internet as that time when we had "free" maps and "free" social networks, and I'm not so sure many will miss it.