6 ms·
> Both prongs absolutely carry power. Both carry current. But not power. Power is volts * amps, and the neutral is defined as zero volts (if you ignore the vol
by ars 9y ago
> Both prongs absolutely carry power.
Both carry current. But not power. Power is volts * amps, and the neutral is defined as zero volts (if you ignore the voltage drop).
> you can get shocked when working on junction boxes for the neutral line
Only from the voltage drop on that wire. It's not the full 120v. (Unless it's cut of course, but that's a whole different story.)
> Here you use voltages as a relative measure, which is correct.
First you introduce the concept, then later, explain other less important details. And that's how I wrote it.
> Walking on carpet in the winter, I can be at a potential of thousands of volts away from that though.
It's a good nitpick :)
- baking 9y agoHigh voltage transmission lines can carry power without a neutral wire because they use the earth as a neutral, but in your house you can be damn sure the neutral is carrying power. Cut off the neutral blade on your appliance if you want to check it out. "Electric power in watts produced by an electric current I consisting of a charge of Q coulombs every t seconds passing through an electric potential (voltage) difference of V is P = work done per unit time = VQ/t = VI Note that V is the "electric potential difference" and it take two conductors to supply power.
- m4x 9y agoIf you are going to take the view that the neutral does not carry power, then the phase wire does not either. Ignoring volt drop, both wires have a 0V difference between each end and so no power is dissipated in them. Power is only dissipated in the appliance (except in reality, where volt drop is responsible for significant losses between generator and consumer)
- ars 9y ago> both wires have a 0V difference between each end Obviously voltage is relative. So I'm measuring with respect to me. With respect to me the hot has power, and the neutral doesn't. i.e. If I attach a light bulb between me and either of the two electrical wires, will it light? But you're right "carrying power" is a poorly defined term. The problem is that it's hard to use a term that is both clear, and strictly correct.
- colanderman 9y agoI think it's incorrect to say that a single wire "transmits" power. Both a current and a voltage difference need to be transmitted to transmit power. So it's really the distribution system as a whole (in this case, neutral and hot together) which transmit power.
- MertsA 9y ago>Both carry current. But not power. Power is volts * amps, and the neutral is defined as zero volts (if you ignore the voltage drop). What he has already pointed out is that voltage is a relative unit. Zero volts by itself is meaningless. It would be just as correct to say that the hot wire is at zero volts and the neutral wire and the rest of the planet are at 120VAC. Also earlier you mentioned that from phase to phase inside a house was 240v but phase to ground was 208v. This isn't correct and it's simple trigonometry to prove why. You can visualize voltage potential in any polyphase AC system as the distance between points on a circle. Ground is the center of the circle and the individual phase is a point on the circle offset by the phase angle. For a split phase system there is 180 degrees between the two phases and cos(0) - cos(180) gives you the fairly obvious distance of 2x the radius. This means for 120v from phase to ground you get 240v phase to phase. In a three phase system there's 120 degrees between phases so if you have 120v from phase to ground you have (cos(0)-cos(120))*120v=208v. For what you're saying to be possible you would need 98.85 degrees between phases which is obviously not a nice integer division of 360 degrees.