2 ms·
Right, you must have missed the part where I said: > Cumulative exposure effects like you're describing are something that SpaceX is addressing by replacing th
by Robotbeat 9y ago
Right, you must have missed the part where I said:
> Cumulative exposure effects like you're describing are something that SpaceX is addressing by replacing the satellites very frequently, up to every 4 years. Given the need to upgrade frequently anyway to keep abreast of technology improvements, the extra cost of this is minimal considering the insane price (and low performance) of traditional rad-hard electronics.
By my calculation, at 1000km altitude and 45 degrees inclination, the satellites should see about 1kRad/year of cumulative radiation dose (given only the satellite casing for shielding). So replacing them every 4 years is easily enough to avoid the 15-20kRad your devices failed at.
It's also possible to shield the electronics (SpaceX has reusable rockets with performance to spare, so might as well use it!). With 10g/cm^2 of aluminum shielding (vs 1g/cm^2 for just the casing, etc), the dose is reduced to about 330rad/year.
In any case, replacing the satellites frequently or adding shielding are both valid strategies for addressing this.
- _qcgl 9y ago> Right, you must have missed the part where I said I saw that part. My post was responding to your statement where you incorrectly and condescendingly said that redundancy helps with ionizing radiation. It doesn't, as I outlined above.