4 ms·
(Edit: My comment is about the fear-mongering part, not the racist part). >What if these were Russians and the title was "FBI Says Russian Operatives..." would
by BeetleB 9y ago
(Edit: My comment is about the fear-mongering part, not the racist part).
>What if these were Russians and the title was "FBI Says Russian Operatives..." would you have said it's straight up racist fear-mongering?
Yes, I would call it fear mongering. What exactly have these operatives done? What can these operatives do?
International students are required to be registered full time, or they'll be in violation of their visa, and since 2001, universities are proactive in flagging these people down. They are only allowed to work 20 hours a week, and only on campus. Internships are allowed if part of their degree program. So it's not as if they are coming in and then running around doing heavy subversive stuff.
As foreign students, they do not have accessive to anything any other student has access to. If a professor is doing anything classified, they need to get clearance for their students, and likely are not allowed Chinese/Russian students at all.
In terms of their promoting their values/culture aggressively: Well join the club! They're doing exactly what every other group on campus is doing (many with support from their embassies).
But to get to the original statement: Yes, it is fear mongering because the article failed to indicate any kind of damage being caused that is beyond the norm for groups on campus. Industrial espionage? Show me some proof or examples. This is pretty much the same as saying "Beware! Commies on campus!" Or "Beware! Muslims on campus!" or "Beware! Abortionists on campus!"
- walshemj 9y agoYou know spies generally don't fill in tax returns - though one Russian illegal in the UK ran a very successful one armed bandit / pinball company as part of his cover.
- BeetleB 9y agoFailing to see the relevance of tax returns not being filled. I'll ask my original question. Have these "operatives" done anything that is not particularly unusual compared to other student groups? Until they have, this fits the very description of fear mongering. You don't magically have access to anything just by entering the US.
- walshemj 9y agoEconomic and other open source info is much easier to get at and also interesting research in universities. Spying on expat groups is another favorite.