4 ms·
> The original plan for 1000km orbits was a kinda red flag for anybody more space-competent. 1000km is the lower end of a lower radiation belt. Hardly. Things
by Robotbeat 9y ago
> The original plan for 1000km orbits was a kinda red flag for anybody more space-competent. 1000km is the lower end of a lower radiation belt.
Hardly. Things can and are made to tolerate a high radiation environment. In SpaceX's case, this is done via redundancy (and perhaps shielding, to some extent) and replacing the satellites at regular intervals.
> On 340km, they must have though of putting really big and expensive solar panels to provide enough thrust on ion engines. They will have to compensate for their own weight and, even more importantly, drag.
Weight is basically irrelevant for drag compensation. And the solar panels SpaceX uses are super cheap as they basically just use high-binned terestrial silicon solar cells from Sunpower, then integrate the panels themselves. Conventional space-rated cells are on the order of $100-1000/Watt, while terrestrial cells are less than $1/Watt. So even though terrestrial cells are only, say, 22% efficient vs 29% efficient and even though they degrade a bit faster in space (a lifetime of, say, 12 years vs 30 years), SpaceX can save a LOT of money and be able to throw around massive amounts of solar power on their satellites for a lot cheaper than their competitors who use typical space-rated components.
- _qcgl 9y ago> Hardly. Things can and are made to tolerate a high radiation environment. In SpaceX's case, this is done via redundancy (and perhaps shielding, to some extent) and replacing the satellites at regular intervals. Redundancy doesn't help you with ionizing radiation. Parts get exposure even when powered off. Running at this altitude was considered a fundamental flaw of the first generation of Globalstar: "Rusch said the "Achilles heel" of the spacecraft is their orbit at an altitude of about 1,414 kilometers (850 miles), which puts them at risk for radiation. "It was a fundamental flaw," he said. "At this altitude the radiation belts are extremely hazardous. Globalstar orbits experience radiation in the South Atlantic Anomaly where the Van Allen Belts nearly touch the atmosphere. Very few satellites are orbited in this region because of the radiation," which can irreparably damage satellite transistors." http://www.satellitetoday.com/telecom/2007/02/12/degradation-of-satellites-threatens-globalstars-service-business-plan/ http://www.satellitetoday.com/telecom/2007/02/12/degradation...
- Robotbeat 9y ago> Redundancy doesn't help you with ionizing radiation. It, in fact, does help. Voting mechanisms can help protect, detect, and/or recover from radiation-induced bit flips and outages. Early radiation-induced failures in systems can also be addressed in this way. SpaceX has significant experience with using redundancy to address space radiation problems via their Dragon program. And the Falcon 9/Heavy upper stage uses similar redundant avionics and travels through the radiation belts on its way to GTO. The Falcon Heavy launch demonstrated cruising through the very worst part of the Van Allen belts (thousands of kilometers higher than Starlink) for hours (multiple orbits, I believe) successfully using conventional electronics made tolerant to space radiation through redundancy. > Parts get exposure even when powered off. Cumulative exposure effects like you're describing are something that SpaceX is addressing by replacing the satellites very frequently, up to every 4 years. Given the need to upgrade frequently anyway to keep abreast of technology improvements, the extra cost of this is minimal considering the insane price (and low performance) of traditional rad-hard electronics.
- _qcgl 9y ago> It, in fact, does help. Voting mechanisms can help protect, detect, and/or recover from radiation-induced bit flips and outages. Early radiation-induced failures in systems can also be addressed in this way. You are describing mechanisms to overcome energetic particles causing single event efects (SEEs). There are two distinct classes of radiation to be concerned about in space: SEE and TID (total ionizing dose). Redundancy does not help with TID. I have done a TID test with commercial parts to prove out a CubeSat design. The parts were exposed to gamma rays emitted by a Cesium-137 source. There was not a single reset or unexplained event over the entire course of TID testing. Around 15-20 krad, the flash memory failed, which is a typical first TID effect. Charge pumps in flash ICs are especially sensitive to cumulative radiation effects. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hardening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hardening "Total ionizing dose effects: The cumulative damage of the semiconductor lattice (lattice displacement damage) caused by ionizing radiation over the exposition time. It is measured in rads and causes slow gradual degradation of the device's performance. A total dose greater than 5000 rads delivered to silicon-based devices in seconds to minutes will cause long-term degradation. In CMOS devices, the radiation creates electron–hole pairs in the gate insulation layers, which cause photocurrents during their recombination, and the holes trapped in the lattice defects in the insulator create a persistent gate biasing and influence the transistors' threshold voltage, making the N-type MOSFET transistors easier and the P-type ones more difficult to switch on. The accumulated charge can be high enough to keep the transistors permanently open (or closed), leading to device failure. Some self-healing takes place over time, but this effect is not too significant. This effect is the same as hot carrier degradation in high-integration high-speed electronics. Crystal oscillators are somewhat sensitive to radiation doses, which alter their frequency. The sensitivity can be greatly reduced by using swept quartz. Natural quartz crystals are especially sensitive. Radiation performance curves for TID testing may be generated for all resultant effects testing procedures. These curves show performance trends throughout the TID test process and are included in the radiation test report."
- philipkglass 9y agoAnd the solar panels SpaceX uses are super cheap as they basically just use high-binned terestrial silicon solar cells from Sunpower, then integrate the panels themselves. Conventional space-rated cells are on the order of $100-1000/Watt, while terrestrial cells are less than $1/Watt. So even though terrestrial cells are only, say, 22% efficient vs 29% efficient and even though they degrade a bit faster in space (a lifetime of, say, 12 years vs 30 years), SpaceX can save a LOT of money and be able to throw around massive amounts of solar power on their satellites for a lot cheaper than their competitors who use typical space-rated components. Do you have a link for that? I didn't find anything that looked relevant with a quick search for "spacex" "sunpower". The high efficiency n-type silicon solar cells that SunPower produces are great for terrestrial use, but significantly less radiation-tolerant than the more common p-type. (Which are in turn far less radiation-tolerant than the compound semiconductors that are preferred for space solar cells nowadays.) In such a low orbit and with such a short lifetime, maybe that fast degradation is fine.
- Robotbeat 9y agoSorry, but I only have unverified Reddit comments here: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/4me65s/how_much_electrical_power_on_mars_is_needed_to/d3v91pr/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/4me65s/how_much_ele... (Still, it sure looks like they're correct... they're definitely silicon cells, at very least.)
- philipkglass 9y agoOh, I see. That's for the Dragon capsule. It's in orbit for a much shorter time. I can easily believe that low radiation tolerance is fine there. I wonder if they can use the same cells for a 4 year lifetime. In any case I am confident that they can use some kind of silicon cells at the lower orbits. The ISS uses silicon cells in its solar arrays.